Having started on clarinet at the age of 12, I’ve learned and grown « carrying » a straight horn on the right thumb. 5 decades later, I’m aware that it might become more difficult and painful.
I think though that it answers to the question above. Someone like Sidney Bechet who spent most time playing soprano just got used to it, and developed his right hand and thumb accordingly.
I’m mostly unable to play soprano with a sling. So far.