Saxophones Straight Soprano Good, Curved Soprano Bad

My posting was tongue in cheek, but personally I have not found a curvy soprano that I liked playing - and that includes trying a couple of Yanagisawas. However, I am a beginner, and other players don't find much difference between straight and curvy, so I may be odd.

I compared the key layout on a curved and a straight soprano and it was the same. But these were both Elkharts, and a different manufacturer might have different spacing. Holding the straight one out in front does get tiring, so the curvy is more comfortable to hold.

You need to try both sorts to find out which you yourself prefer.

I have been trying out sopranos recently, and for what it's worth, my current view is that one should either pay less than £300 or more than £1800. (The exceptions to this rule would be a used Yamaha 475 or a vintage soprano.) It is possible to get a good used Chinese or Taiwanese soprano for under £300, and the next step up from that would be a Yamaha or a Yanagisawa or a Sequoia. Personally, I like the Elkhart Deluxe and Sakkusu "Tick-Logo" models - made in Taiwan. But intonation on cheap sopranos can vary a lot from instrument to instrument, even ones that are supposedly identical, so you need to try them.
Thanks for your helpful response which I appreciated.
I really would like a straight soprano but the more I research the more complicated it gets.
It seems it is not possible to use a neck strap with a straight one and that is a must for me as I have arthritic fingers and couldn't support it.
Maybe I should pop in to Dawkes and try one out.
Thanks again for your opinion.
 
@Rosemary Joy If you use a padded neck strap it is perfectly possible to play a straight sop but you may still find that your right thumb gets tired/sore after a while. As Colin the bear says, the curvy has many advantages for ease of holding and comfort. Remember that the purpose of a musical instrument is to make music! The ideal instrument and setup will let you express yourself without getting in the way. I still find my curvy excellent for this. What it looks like is irrelevant, especially if you play with your eyes closed in true Jazz style! 😉
 
Thanks for your helpful response which I appreciated.
I really would like a straight soprano but the more I research the more complicated it gets.
It seems it is not possible to use a neck strap with a straight one and that is a must for me as I have arthritic fingers and couldn't support it.
Maybe I should pop in to Dawkes and try one out.
Thanks again for your opinion.

I use a neck strap with my straight soprano, but my right thumb is bearing most of the weight and it gets tired. A curved soprano is more comfortable.

As you say - you need to try them.
 
I play mine straight soprano with a neck strap (well actually usually I use the same jazzlabs saxholder as on my tenor, just pull it up a bit). Without the 'strap' its heavy and awkward to hold...no make that impossible to hold I think.
 
I sometimes use a neck strap with my sop it takes a little of the weight but not a lot. It is interesting though how different makes/models can weigh differently so worth trying a few. I had sellers weighing saxes when I bought mine to find a lighter one 🙂

Jx
 
I sometimes use a neck strap with my sop it takes a little of the weight but not a lot. It is interesting though how different makes/models can weigh differently so worth trying a few. I had sellers weighing saxes when I bought mine to find a lighter one 🙂

Jx
Interesting: I find it a very odd question but a customer asked me the same and I found put a strange result about my Sequoias:
Silver: 1.46 kg
Lemon: 1.25 kg
200g of plating?
 
I asked a seller to compare a YSS 62 with the YSS 675


I just weighed them on my postage scale, which is accurate to a tenth of an ounce. The 675 weighs 49.8 oz. (3 lb 1.8 oz.) and the YSS-62 weighs 44.8oz. (2 lb 12.8 oz.). So the 62 is 10% lighter than the 675. It is really easy to feel the difference when you pick the two horns up. The keywork is also sprung much more lightly on the 62, so depressing the keys takes significantly less force on the 62 than on the heavier-sprung 675.

So 62 is 1.27 Kg and 675 1.411Kg

Jx
 
I use a neck strap with my straight soprano, but my right thumb is bearing most of the weight and it gets tired. A curved soprano is more comfortable.

As you say - you need to try them.
Thank you Nigeld for helping me make my mind up. It's definitely a curved one for me. As you say it's more comfy and that's important if you want to enjoy playing.
 
a straight one is hard on the thumb.
Possibly harder on the thumb the more vertically you hold it. Ideally it should be as close as practical to horizontal so you head is not bent over or the mouthpiece is at a more acute angle to your mouth. (Ideally it is close to 90 degrees to your teeth)

Of course this position may cause fatigue to your arms and needs getting used to but should not be concentrating weight on your thumb as it would if in a more pointing downward position.
 
Funny statement.
I played a curvy (Yanagisawa) for 2 decades, mostly because it feels closer to the other saxes, and is easier to transport, record and amplify.
I kept getting cool or dumb comments, about it’s toyish or clownish look.
I recently got a straight horn mainly for curiosity, and to check how it feels before my right thumb grows too old.
I play the latter these days, typically standing gigs, traditional jazz.
It is rather cool to have one of each Japanese makers. Face to face. Great horns to play all the way.
 
I've had trouble with my right thumb in the past but spotted a Jupiter one piece at a very nice price and after reading SH's review bought it.

It came as a pleasant surprise to me that I've had no problems with the offending digit. The horn doesn't feel heavy at all. I've tried using a sling but unsuccessfully. The position feels wrong.

The one piece design ensures that there's no leaks at the non existent joint.
Moving from curved to straight, I thought the silly comments would stop, but no.
"Is that a golden clarinet?" is the latest.
 
7 years on from my original post arguing for straight sopranos, I have recently bought an old Yani SC901 curvy with the old-style bell key touches. My Sequoia straight soprano sounds great, but my thumb gets too tired. The Yani sounds fine, is comfortable, and is fun to play.
 
I think that for most, it's the ergonomics (of either) that decide which is the one for them. Years ago I had a curved Yani top of the range. I just couldn't hold it comfortably.

Recently I had a "student" straight Yani - hated it. Sound was tight and small to me. Got a used Selmer series 2. Is completely straight, which is a bit awkward. Not as instant a blow as the Yani (if you haven't played it for ages) but after a day or two it's amazing.

Always use a sling..
 
I never played a curved soprano. I've had 3 straight ones but most of the curved ones I saw were kids students models and I was not impressed!

I've got a feeling they would feel like toys in my hands. Especially after a few years playing mostly tenor and already feeling alto a bit small...
 
Straight sopranos in one piece for me. The day they started to cut up the tube on a soprano sax ..... .

But I have owned and played fully curved sopranos. Not Conn, Burscher, Selmer ..... but some terrible Italian curved sopranos. Junk. We used to say that Swallow, Lark, Gulf ... saxes were bad. I think the Italian curved sopranos were in the same league.

I have 4 straight sopranos. All in one piece.
- Conn New Wonder 1925.
- Kohlert 1927
- Buescher 1928
- "Schenkelaars" (Keilwerth, Nauheim stencil) c 1952-53

The Conn soprano is the one I use to play. Better for me because I play metal mouthpieces and a Dukoff or Selmer sounds good on the Conn.

I really don't understand how a sling can help up on a straight soprano? If the sling should pick up weight you must play with in a very bent position !?!?!?! We do embouchure exercises to get a better tone. We must do exercises to hold a sax as well.
 
I really don't understand how a sling can help up on a straight soprano? If the sling should pick up weight you must play with in a very bent position !?!?!?!

I find it helps to stop it from either slipping out of your mouth or rocking from side to side when you hold it forwards. Which means your fingers can be more relaxed.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,446
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom