Tech/maintenance Sticking pad

Punchysax

Member
Messages
499
Location
Hitchin
Hi all,
I have a beautiful 1941 Martin Committee 2 alto that has been fully overhauled. Plays lovely , I have a sticking G sharp pad , after not being used and then getting out again the pad seems to always be stuck shut. I generally will just wipe with a small piece of paper , any ideas that will stop this .
Thanks

View: https://youtu.be/eHFky8X_kso
 
The best you can do is to carefully clean the tone hole rim and the surface of the pad, then hope for good results. Yamaha Pad Powder Paper will help.

In the end, the only permanent cure is to replace the pad, carefully cleaning the tonehole rim at the same time. Or, let the pad get old and hard.
 
Does it stick only once when you first take it out to play?

I used to experience that on some of my horns. It became a habit to finger the G# when I assembled the horn, then it didn’t stick for the rest of my play session.

If it is chronically sticky, clean the pad and tone hole as Turf3 comments.
 
Hi all thank you its intermittent , sticks if after a break form playing or if I don’t use that key for a while . If I re her to wipe it before playing generally it’s ok however I put it down to one of its quirks for a 84 year old horn , sometime the octave vent key sticks also , it’s the character of the old girl👍
 
Wedge it open before you store it. Key leaves or a rolled up business card.

Don't put the card under the pad it may deform the seal. Somewhere in the mechanism under a key arm.

On a modern saxophone G# and C# are linked and it's easier to prop open C# and do both.

It can cause panic and confusion if you forget to remove it before playing.
 
When a pad is sticky I use to clean the pad with a cotton pad. Dampen the cotton pad in lukewarm water + soap. Dry the pad with a clean paper after the cotton swab I use pad swab, or pad papper or just a strong kitchen paper after I have been playing. I use pad saver on my martin saxes as well so the soft soldered tone holes joint are dry. F palm key pad and Eb pad use to be the pads I need to dry a little bit extra.
 
You can try a coat of spray lacquer on the pad after it's been cleaned and dried. Of course, you have to take the key off the horn first and mask everything but the pad. If the tone holes were leveled during the overhaul, you can also paint some lacquer on the rim of the tone hole with a cotton bud.
 
Very common problem for most sax players, including me on alto and tenor at some point. Haven't had an issue since I started using key leaves (cheap eBay knock offs at least) a few years ago. But key leaves may not work on a really old horn. If you open the low C# pad by lifting the pad itself with your finger and the G# also opens, key leaves will work.
 
I have a beautiful 1941 Martin Committee 2 alto that has been fully overhauled.
Beautiful sax and nice playing there.
That G# key didn’t leave the bench that way. Don’t shoot your tech. This is common and related to the nature of the mechanism and new pad(s).
Works fine, install new pads / overhaul. Problem(s) starts.

The pad is not seasoned (surface worked in). The porosity of the leather is working like miniature suction cups.
Surface tension to broad Martin chimney rim. Everything is clean & smooth. Great for gluing things together.
The unit was just fully serviced, keys fitted…respring or springs adjusted ?

The G# cup is sprung to open. Usually very lightly / minimal. Depress the G# touch. If the keycup didn’t open, gently lift to open. Feel how light the action of spring opening is. With the horn horizontal & key up. The cup should stay positively open. Not sluggish.
The G# touch is sprung heavily to close the G# cup. Usually just enough to close the key. Not so much that your pinky finger is uncomfortable in use. There is a balancing act between the two.

If the spring balance appears good.
Please don’t drag a paper across the pad while closed. It’s not dirty. This is probably not helpful as it’s abrasive on new pad.
I would try to apply either cigarette lighter fluid or Pledge polish. Either very sparingly and just to tonehole rim. Drop on Q-tip or heavy paper. Close key to transfer product onto pad.
This may take a few attempts. Pre and post playing.

If the spring balance appears inconsistent or incorrect. Contact the tech.
 
Last edited:
In my opinion, most new pads, ready to be installed, are more or less sticky. The pads I have in my boxes are from the mid 90's. After dry fitting I use to clean the new pads. Saxophone repair was not paying my bills. This is a very slow method as all other methods I use(d).
 
I put it down to one of its quirks for a 84 year old horn , sometime the octave vent key sticks also , it’s the character of the old girl
I don’t think it’s related to the age of the instrument. Pads sticking is either the pad or the tonehole. Either can be fixed. Sometimes weak spring tension can affect a slightly sticky pad that would otherwise open.
 
I don’t think it’s related to the age of the instrument. Pads sticking is either the pad or the tonehole. Either can be fixed. Sometimes weak spring tension can affect a slightly sticky pad that would otherwise open.
It is also a design quirk by using leather as a sealant. It is very easy to make glue from leather. Every pad has a bit of this glue in the leather. In most cases it is not enough to stick, sometimes it is too much. By cleaning and drying it is possible to reduce the amount on the surface of the pad. Which decreases the amount of glue and stickiness in time.
 
Very common problem for most sax players, including me on alto and tenor at some point. Haven't had an issue since I started using key leaves (cheap eBay knock offs at least) a few years ago. But key leaves may not work on a really old horn. If you open the low C# pad by lifting the pad itself with your finger and the G# also opens, key leaves will work.
Same here.
I used to clean the pad and tonehole rim using a pipe cleaner and lighter fluid, as specified by Stephen Hawkin in his manual.
That solved the issue for quite a while.
Since I started using Key-leaves, I don't need to do this anymore.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,196
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom