Jazz Star Spangled Banner arranged Russel Peterson

I know I'm probably in a small minority but I find all of these "stylized" interpretations of "my" national anthem to be in poor taste. Give me John Philip Sousa's arrangement in Ab for military band and I feel like it truly represents my country and treats the music with the respect that it deserves.

 
The Sousa arrangement is a bit heavy for my taste.

I think the best version of our national anthem (i.e. the real one :thumb:) is Benjamin Britten’s arrangement - he manages to avoid bombast and makes the harmony a little more interesting.

 
I know I'm probably in a small minority but I find all of these "stylized" interpretations of "my" national anthem to be in poor taste. Give me John Philip Sousa's arrangement in Ab for military band and I feel like it truly represents my country and treats the music with the respect that it deserves.

I totally get where you're coming from and used to share that option with you. Then I came to realize that although the words are American, the tune itself is actually (I suppose was originally is applicable too) a British one. So come to think of it, a jazz star spangled banner is the most American one.
All that being said, Souza's is my favorite as well.
 
The Sousa arrangement is a bit heavy for my taste.

I think the best version of our national anthem (i.e. the real one :thumb:) is Benjamin Britten’s arrangement - he manages to avoid bombast and makes the harmony a little more interesting.
Thank you for posting that video. I found it quite moving. Your anthem is much more melodic and singable than ours. Many U.S. musicians I know would have preferred this anthem written by William Billings during the time of the revolutionary war rather than the British tune we have now which is difficult to sing.

 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom