- Messages
- 2,079
- Location
- Oneonta, NY
Are we playing Password now?
Yes, the Impressionists tried it for years. Debussy La Mer sounds like the sea - cos I watched the Onedin Line as a kid and it sounds like that..Describing a sound is quite meaningless. Like trying to paint a smell. It's all just jargon. 😉
Yes, the Impressionists tried it for years. Debussy La Mer sounds like the sea - cos I watched the Onedin Line as a kid and it sounds like that..
Indeed, but it didn't sound like the sea back then 😉The sea in the Onedin Line sounds like music from the ballet Spartacus by Khatchaturian:
Rhys
These are words I would expect to be used for every good classical player.Focused, centered
This was a real problem for me also Clive. A HUGE problem. With all the practicing I was doing , my thumb felt like it had slowly broken. I literally had to click my thumb back into position which was incredibly painful. It took a couple of months to heal.I've just traded my straight sop for a curved neck sop. The straight sop (Jupiter) bruised my right thumb middle joint every time I played.
The curved neck sop (Yamaha) does not. There seems to be a subtle but important difference in the thumb rest position between my two saxes (my Yamaha thumb rest position seems higher so my thumb no longer gets bruised by the rest). This is independent of ergo benefit of using neck strap on curved neck sop. (Note I don't have any tendinitis or strength problems).
We are all different and our thumbs and hands are all different. If you have thumb problems it may be worth trying different brands to see if one suits your thumb more than another.
My bruised thumb was more of an annoyance but I was certainly concerned it could get much worse over time unless I took action to eliminate the cause. I don't think pain should ever be ignored or else worse problems await. For me, the curved-neck Yamaha sop has eliminated any right thumb issues. My sore thumb was mainly caused by the Jupiter thumb rest. However, the straight neck did give me a tired back from holding it out for a long practice. The curved neck has eliminated the tired back, allowing my practices to be longer with no ill effect.This was a real problem for me also Clive. A HUGE problem. With all the practicing I was doing , my thumb felt like it had slowly broken. I literally had to click my thumb back into position which was incredibly painful. It took a couple of months to heal.
I honestly can understand your frustration and desire to try something new.
Even so, nothing should be painful while playing an instrument. Pain should never be ignored. That’s right.My bruised thumb was more of an annoyance but I was certainly concerned it could get much worse over time unless I took action to eliminate the cause. I don't think pain should ever be ignored or else worse problems await. For me, the curved-neck Yamaha sop has eliminated any right thumb issues. My sore thumb was mainly caused by the Jupiter thumb rest. However, the straight neck did give me a tired back from holding it out for a long practice. The curved neck has eliminated the tired back, allowing my practices to be longer with no ill effect.
In my case the Yamaha keywork is much more ergonomically friendly than the Jupiter I had previously, too. The Jupiter was recently serviced and leak free but the keywork was uneven and the springs/pads were spongy with poor tactile feedback to let me know the keys were properly closed. That tended to induce a firmer grip on the right hand keys that exacerbated my sore right thumb. The Yamaha keywork is lovely and even, the springs more on/off with clear tactile feedback, and my fingers are significantly lighter on the keys as a result. This minimises the oppositional force needed by the right thumb. I wanted to upgrade the Jupiter before the firmer gripping bad habit got too ingrained.
All that together with the slightly higher thumb rest position no longer bruising my thumb and the curved-neck allowing the neckstrap to support the weight and I have no thumb issues at all. 🙂
Well written. You explained that exceptionally well & clearly know what you’re talking about.Focused, centered, and compact are words I have seen used to describe a tone that is produced with a "firm" embouchure. Pinched and "stuffy" are terms I have used to describe a saxophone tone produced when playing too high on the mouthpiece pitch. In my teaching experience, mouthpiece pitch is a useful "tool" when used to measure the pressure of the bottom lip against the reed.
A tone produced by an embouchure that is less tight is sometimes described as being spread, or having an edgy sound. A more exaggerated and derogatory term for a tone produced by a loose embouchure would be "flabby".
In my teaching beginning clarinet students the biggest challenges at first were to: 1) get them to put the top teeth on the mouthpiece, 2) keep the chin "flat" and 3) to play with an embouchure tight enough not to produce a "flabby" tone. In order to accomplish this I had them to produce an F# concert on the "tone producer" (mouthpiece and barrel) and hold a steady tone at that pitch for 30 seconds before going to the entire clarinet. Playing a concert C on the mouthpiece alone would accomplish the same thing, but is too difficult for most beginning students. Another technique I used was to have them tighten the embouchure until the reed closed off, and then relax it just enough to make a sound. At this level, having the students play "at the top of the pitch" is an effective way to eliminate the "flabby" tone most beginning clarinetists start out with.
While I appreciate both examples, if I must choose, my personal preference for classical clarinet sound is the first example. I find the pure sound more beautiful. The second more colourful but not as pure as I'd prefer.@jbtsax compare these two:
John McCaw and Michael Froest
View: https://youtu.be/9GnJBLwOjFo
View: https://youtu.be/O4cAKATejfE
Frost is a fabulous player. Whatever anyone's preference the two exist and this is the whole basis of my argument - that Eugene Rousseau says that the clarinet should be or is played at the top of the mouthpiece note. My contention is that should be "at the top, or near the top" - otherwise the more open sounds are not explained. That's all. I'm not commenting on which is best, they are merely different classical schools of playing and we either like one over the other of more probably elements from each.While I appreciate both examples, if I must choose, my personal preference for classical clarinet sound is the first example. I find the pure sound more beautiful. The second more colourful but not as pure as I'd prefer.
I have ordered the Deluxe WAW Sax Thumb Rest for my Tenor. I'll post photos of it with reference to both my Soprano and Tenor when it arrives so you can see it doesn't really work for the soprano because of the limited space above the thumb rest. I find my Yamaha Tenor thumb rest too low even though my Yamaha Soprano thumb rest is just right.Nikki
Deluxe WAW Sax Thumb Rest works for Alto and Tenor by providing a bridge over the F# trill keycap, allowing right thumb to be placed more naturally opposite the index finger. I asked manufacturer and he has no plans to make it for Soprano unfortunately. This is simply 3D printed. Maybe an enterprising Café member could customise a 3D print model that would work for soprano? (Sopranos vary a lot in design but maybe someone could make for the most popular Yamaha 475!)
Thumb Splint stabiliser is available with bars to stabilise around thumb (transfer weight to base of thumb) or to simply act as a reminder not to gorilla grip keys or lift weight with thumb.
Clive
Fröst's virtuosity is beyond doubt, but I find it highly unpleasant to watch him perform on video. For some reason, straight woodwind instruments seem to incite players to make lots of (in my eyes) silly, distracting, and unnecessary movements. Recorder players are the worst in that respect - google Maurice Steger on Youtube. For a laugh, here is an "instructive" Earspasm video:Frost is a fabulous player. ...
He’s an interesting guy. I’ve seen him in an interview saying that he watches previous performances and sees that he sometimes gets carried away. I think he is talking of his playing rather than his movement. I think he might have used the word excitable even.Fröst's virtuosity is beyond doubt, but I find it highly unpleasant to watch him perform on video. For some reason, straight woodwind instruments seem to incite players to make lots of (in my eyes) silly, distracting, and unnecessary movements. Recorder players are the worst in that respect - google Maurice Steger on Youtube. For a laugh, here is an "instructive" Earspasm video:
The only straight woodwind which escapes this pattern is the cornetto. The intonation is so difficult to get right, that one would be nuts to introduce variability in the embouchure by swinging the instrument around. Here's a very watchable example of the cornetto master, Bruce Dickey:
Fröst's virtuosity is beyond doubt, but I find it highly unpleasant to watch him perform on video. For some reason, straight woodwind instruments seem to incite players to make lots of (in my eyes) silly, distracting, and unnecessary movements. Recorder players are the worst in that respect - google Maurice Steger on Youtube. For a laugh, here is an "instructive" Earspasm video:
The only straight woodwind which escapes this pattern is the cornetto. The intonation is so difficult to get right, that one would be nuts to introduce variability in the embouchure by swinging the instrument around. Here's a very watchable example of the cornetto master, Bruce Dickey:
