Playing the saxophone Side Bb Key on Yani

iiVb9I

Member
Messages
47
Location
California
I just purchased a Yanigasawa TWO1 last December. I like the horn very much. Smooth from top to bottom. But for some reason I mute my Eb notes because I will rub ever-so-slightly against the side Bb. Would like to lower that key, but doesn't look possible. Wondering if anyone else has this problem. I'm not a big guy, 5'5", but my hands are not abnormally small, and didn't seem to have this problem on my old horns (old yama62 and a Taiwan custom of sorts). I've been playing for about 10 yrs ago. I did see a post once where they suggested just re--positioning the horn when playing.
 
I have both a TWO1 and a 62iii. I regularly play both. I am 5'6" with average size hands. The ergonomics are slightly different between the two. Nothing a little practice shouldn't overcome.

On the Yani the LH pinky table is much closer (about 1/4") to the palm. The palm keys are much closer (about 1/4") to the Sax body. The side keys have about 1/8" clearance from my palm and are about an 1/8" further away from the Sax body than on the 62iii.

On the 62iii, I need to be careful I don't engage the palm keys unintentionally. On the Yani I need to be careful I don't nudge the side keys and I have to use a riser on the palm D key to reach it more easily. The LH pinky table positions the C# key such that I need to do the hand rotate outwards action to reach it. Overall, I find the 62iii keys more ergonomic for me.

Bottom line is I can play both saxes with equal facility. I can switch between them easily, too. But occasionally I'll make mistakes on the Yani side keys and on the 62iii palm keys.
 
I had a similar problem with my Barone tenor at first - I would accidentally crack the high F# key, because I kept my fingers sort of flat (and near the side Bb and C keys. A couple weeks being concious of curving my fingers a bit more and the problem went away.

If this only happens when playing Eb, it suggests you are rotating your hand a little for that note. Some time working on hand and/or arm and/or wrist position may pay dividends.
 
If this only happens when playing Eb, it suggests you are rotating your hand a little for that note. Some time working on hand and/or arm and/or wrist position may pay dividends.
+1, rotating or sliding toward the sax body.

Try bell key fingerings exercises: Bb chromatically up to E and back down; C to Eb and back. All combos both to help diagnose and to find a workable remedy. I have an issue on the Yani with the transition from E to C producing a double key action due to mistiming the D and C keys. I have this issue on my Yani Sopranos, too. I don't have the issue on my multiple Yamaha Saxes.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,431
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom