Playing the saxophone Several notes in a row?

I actually played that chart (a transcription of it) many years ago. If I recall, I used “deedle” tonguing for it.

“Deedle-eedle-it”.

Tongue flicks the reed like you do when playing tongued legato, not a full tongue. Alternate repeated notes are half-tongued, with the tongue lightly on the reed; the change in tone makes the articulation sound, and the release of the tongue starts the next note. (The first alto could also use bis Bb alternating with 1+1 or 1 + right hand, but I don’t think it would sound good here.) The bari part looks a little hard - this kind of light tonguing is hard to do low down on the horn.

Jamie Anderson gives a lot of information in his videos on articulation - worth a watch for a composer, or an advancing sax player wanting to play more authentically.
View: https://youtu.be/1OdjU9__Q4A


This is different than the example you gave, because the crescendos, accents etc. give an indication of which notes can be ghosted or half-tongued. I (and I suspect others) interpreted your example to mean each note must be played the same, and this is hard to do. But the phrases in Fantail above give enough information that change how I would play it. (Sal Nistico could probably cut it though!!!!)

Note that this is kind of advanced; I would expect pros and maybe college level players to cut this, but at high school level Fantail is a stretch. Fun to try, and for some kids doable, but certainly not the average school band.

I meant generally; both in jazz and classical music.

I mean: For a brass musician, given how the mechanics of our mouthpieces work with our mouths, it's not always easy to discern (not obvious or guessable) what an instrumentalist with another mechanical principle of producing sound does to achieve similar effects. If someone would ask me how difficult it is for a saxophone or a clarinet to articulate different notes, in different tempi and registers, I could only draw informed conclusions rather than claiming knowledge.

This is why my first note examples were very anonymous; in the hope of getting answers covering all aspects of the possible interpretation. Say that the notes would have been notated in staccato, or tenuto, accentuated or portato; what would that mean for a saxophonist? In classical music? In jazz?

From what I've read here, I would assume that all and any articulation gets somewhat easier with higher register, but does that count for all saxes? Is a baritone easier over a certain register, or will it still be cumbersome to articulate? What about a soprano? That is the kind of specialized knowledge I look for with my question and my examples.
 
Last edited:
Given your talking about 1/8 notes at 200 bpm I’d suggest that staccato is impossible on most instruments.
Are you meaning 16ths? Quaver staccato at 200bpm is not that upper end - getting there, but not that bad. It would be about normal tempo for 16ths in the Mozart Clarinet concerto for example, and the 1st movement might be something like 105bpm.

Faster still would be the Nielsen clarinet concerto - and stylistically more notes would be expected to be staccato without a slur in between. Players that can double tongue will go a fair bit faster still.

If talking about the OP’s (low) original example for sax then it’s certainly not nice.
 
For a brass musician, the best way to understand single and double reed instrument tonguing is to think of single tonguing. If you would double tongue a passage normally, it will likely be at the edge, or well past the edge, of clean articulation for a reed instrument. While many pros can do a form of double tonguing on saxes and clarinets, it’s not a standard technique, and does not sound clean compared to a brass instrument.

The “Dooden” or “Deedle” tonguing I described above is a case in point. The notes do not sound the same, as alternate notes are somewhat muffled. In a delicate passage in classical music this might not be acceptable; in the jazz example from Fantail it is.

Some reed players can do a “ta-ka” form of double tonguing (I personally have little success with that, due to my mouth shape). But even there, the “ka” notes will not have as distinct a start, since the tongue doen’t physically touch the reed. Since these notes occur quickly, usually, this is not that noticeable, but I don’t think you can count on every reed player, even at pro level, to be able to do this.

[EDIT] - @Pete Effamy ’s comments about clarinet above are spot on. Fast single tonguing and double tonguing are easier on a clarinet than a saxophone. I believe when I was studying clarinet seriously I was able to get staccato 16th notes in a scale up to 120 BPM. On a good day…. I doubt I could do 100 today, but I rarely play clarinet anymore.

I think this is partly due to clarinet having a cylindrical (sort of) bore, rather than conical (sort of) like the saxophone does. And it’s smaller. And the mouthpiece is less open. And…. But rapid tonguing on clarinet is easier, I think, than on soprano sax, which has a similar size mouthpiece. [END EDIT]

Finally, you are correct with regard to larger instruments and ranges. On saxophone in particular, the extreme low end (say, from written D and downwards) is harder to tongue cleanly. And larger saxophones are generally slower to respond, though I think tongue speed and agility are really the limiting factor until you get to baritone. I believe the same is true of brass instruments - can you imagine Carnival of Venice on a tuba?
 
Last edited:
I’m wrong about the Mozart clarinet concerto Rondo movement. This faster 3rd movement would be something like 92bpm. So we are under the 8ths at 200bpm.

Sorry - it’s getting late; 3rd movement is in 6/8 so 16th passages are in dotted crotchet..

No, I am losing it - 1st movement up there at 120bpm give or take. But as S Keller says, hard as it is on clarinet at this speed, it’s certainly harder on sax in the low register especially
 
Last edited:
I believe when I was studying clarinet seriously I was able to get staccato 16th notes in a scale up to 120 BPM. On a good day…. I doubt I could do 100 today, but I rarely play clarinet anymore.
Pretty much exactly the same for me, though I considered my speed to be a little on the tardy side next to a really good classical player. For a classical pro clarinettist I think it’s in the region of “getting away with it”.

I’ve gotten slower too now that I don’t play clarinet.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,427
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom