Tech/maintenance Separating a key cup from its arm.

You don't have to alter anything. The standard self-levelling, height adjustable (pad out), synthetic pads can be fitted with no modifications.

The key cup cutting (or small cups at point of manufacture) and through the cup pad height adjustment are further customisation.

As for promoters... working on it.
 
Saxophone players seem quite conservative, almost reactionary, in my experience.
Seriously? In the last decade or so I've seen all manner of horns turning up with utterly pointless gadgets attached to them in the vain hope that they'll produce the 'magic bullet' that so many players seem to be searching for. You know the sort of thing...great big lumpy crook screws, stupid pieces of metal that you stick into the lyre slot etc...and all foisted on the community as a (not so) cheap fillip to avoid the sheer hard graft of practising to build tone and stability.
Hardly conservative behaviour. I get the feeling that horn players these days will swallow any amount of snake-oil, providing the manufacturers have persuaded at least one 'celebrity' player to get behind it.


It takes a brave heart to offer change.

Does it though?
Think about it. None of the major manufacturers have any interest whatsoever in what happens to their horns once you've bought them. You've shelled out several grand, and that's it as far as they're concerned. Will the pads last 5 years or 50? They don't care - they have your money...and they're not in the business of repairing horns.
What they DO care about though is that their products are seen to be reliable - and you can be sure there are some very serious engineers on their teams. Are they likely to resort to asking advice on a public forum? No. So when it comes to throwing the pounds/dollars down on the counter, who're you gonna trust? A highly-qualified engineer who knows all there is to know (or almost all, at least) about how horns work - or some geezer who doesn't even know how to desolder a key cup?

Yeah, it's harsh - I know, but it's the bottom line. I could well be completely wrong (and that's fine), but I don't think I will be. Time will tell.
 
It definitely would need a known/famous player to market something like that but would be slow to gain momentum and might be rejected by the tried and true functioning saxophone of over 100 years old and going strong
 
...or some geezer who doesn't even know how to desolder a key cup?

Yeah, it's harsh - I know, but it's the bottom line. I could well be completely wrong (and that's fine), but I don't think I will be. Time will tell.
@Jeanette - how do I add "some geezer" to my profile name?

I am honoured by such an accolade from the esteemed guru of all things woodwind.
:thanks2:
 
So going back to the original point of this conversation - is it possible to separate a key cup from its arm for the purpose of fitting your magnet mounting system for self leveling pads?

As a proof of concept for building a new saxophone (or replacement key work) without conventional key cups - yes this has already been demonstrated by other manufacturers such as Toptone

As a viable option to retrofit your system on existing instruments - clearly not: It would be extremely labor intensive and carries a high risk of damage to key work in terms of melting and warping. Not to mention a good degree of cosmetic work required to refinish.
 
Saxophone players seem quite conservative, almost reactionary, in my experience.

Seriously? In the last decade or so I've seen all manner of horns turning up with utterly pointless gadgets attached to them in the vain hope

Slight flaw in that argument. I agree there are many many saxophone players adding those gizmos, however my gut feeling is they are still very conservative when it comes to messing with the core design and action. I've often toyed with the concept of an electronic method to operate keys, but I wouldn't mind betting those same player who embrace the lefreque will still go "nah."

I know a lot of highly-qualified engineers who can't desolder a key cup.

I think it's true that designers don't necessarily need to be technicians and vice versa. Architects are not structural engineers.
 
So going back to the original point of this conversation - is it possible to separate a key cup from its arm for the purpose of fitting your magnet mounting system for self leveling pads?

As a proof of concept for building a new saxophone (or replacement key work) without conventional key cups - yes this has already been demonstrated by other manufacturers such as Toptone

As a viable option to retrofit your system on existing instruments - clearly not: It would be extremely labor intensive and carries a high risk of damage to key work in terms of melting and warping. Not to mention a good degree of cosmetic work required to refinish.
At the outset I decided to publish my design on here, SOTW, and Youtube to gather opinions from players and technicians. I'll often start new threads with whatever is in my head, just to keep me on the straight and narrow. Many thanks to all who offer opinions, positive or negative.

I've said a few times since starting this thread that I won't now try to separate the key cup but will cut around a centre 10mm to hold the magnet. This cutting away of keys is purely experimental to see how key touches may be supported and other areas of key interaction maintained.

As for the new pads, for clarity, there may be three options:
1/ Unadulterated retro-fit into existing key cups.
2/ Manufacturer fitted into tiny key cups, id 10mm, or direct to key arms.
3/ Further customisation, including multi shaped or perforated decorative key cups; through the cup pad height adjustment.

All types offer:
  • Self levelling
  • Height adjustable
  • Easily removed/replaced
  • Impermeable to air and water
  • Low percussive noise
  • Hard wearing
  • Washable
  • No stickiness
  • Easy resonator swap out
 
I've often toyed with the concept of an electronic method to operate keys, but I wouldn't mind betting those same player who embrace the lefreque will still go "nah."
Have you seen the Belgian autosax? I agree that there is a conservative attitude from a large number of highly-qualified saxophone players towards changes in the core design. Probably because they invested soo much time on the traditional saxophone and don't want to see it as sunk costs. As an example: Michael Brecker once said that the toptone saxophone made playing too easy.
 
Last edited:
Out of idle curiosity... Is heat the best way to go?

Maybe the join would crack appart nicely with the application of gentle but firm leverage? Maybe if you scored around the join, say with a glass cutter or hard, sharp implement to start a point fracture..? See what I mean?
Of course, if the cap is weaker than the join, the cap will tear...
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,680
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom