I am not as confident about that last bit. Lacking “snap” is not always so easy to sort out and would depend on why it lacks snap. Is it the spring-loaded pivots, finishing at the tube ends, location of the spring cradles, a lack of stiffness in some of the keys, or the choice of soft materials on friction interfaces? I would want to have a technician evaluate it for its potential. If that proves good (and if one has a technician willing to take it on), then I’d wait for a used one to pop up and invest in an overhaul to correct its shortcomings.
Yes I agree. I guess, as you say, that's a point that needs to be clarified by a reputable tech's inspection of a Supreme.
Selmers have always been badly setup from the factory and thus the distributers. My experiences were, on visiting the old importer Vincent Bach in London that they didn't care two hoots about quality, and in the Selmer Paris showroom 15 years ago that the resident techs were butchers with toxic masculinity issues. There was a general sense from Selmer that having an instrument or mouthpiece in top playing condition needs to be paid for by the purchaser and is not something they would bother about for just anyone.
Not only that, I visited a very good London woodwind shop some weeks ago and asked to play a Supreme alto and a Series 3 alto in comparison - both instruments were in unplayable condition! What a joke!
At least the two I played in Howarths this week were in good playing condition. Well done Howarths.
I am conflicted about the price-point. Whilst theoretically, I do not see an issue with charging a high price for an excellent instrument that will last a whole career, I am offended by Selmer's lack of commitment to excellence beyond the design process. It's a real shame and I think Selmer have taken the wrong business model at this point. I would have been more inclined to invest to improve not only the design but also the quality of the finished product 'out-of-the-box', and keep the price down a bit at least for a few years. When it had been proved that they were as serious as Yamaha and Yanagisawa about their products, then raise the price accordingly.
Simply riding on past glories will not protect Selmer from young players' perception that Selmers are difficult to play, because they are perennially badly set up.
When one compares the sort of personal service offered by, say the Sequoia people in Italy, at such reasonable prices, Selmer's do seem unjustified.
Nonetheless, there's far too much supposition going on about the Selmer Supreme instruments by people who haven't even seen one in the flesh, never mind played one. I suggest they 'shut it' until we get some hands on reviews by trusted professionals.