Saxophones Selmer Serie III altos & their intonation tendencies

Which Selmer alto do you play David ? I want to like my Serie III, but find the tuning peculiar higher up and not as easy to play as my Mk7. Rhys

Rhys, I play a Reference 54 which I have had for 10 years. I did have a Series 3 but I found it, as you say, peculiar. In Selmer's words, it is a 'concept' instrument, and as such they understand that it does not appeal to all players. The next generation of saxes from Selmer will be interesting, rather a deal breaker for them I think, now that there are so many good Asian horns at lower prices. I am keen to know whether they will continue on their path of wider and wider octaves or whether they will return to some sense of sanity!
 
Rhys, I play a Reference 54 which I have had for 10 years. I did have a Series 3 but I found it, as you say, peculiar. In Selmer's words, it is a 'concept' instrument, and as such they understand that it does not appeal to all players. The next generation of saxes from Selmer will be interesting, rather a deal breaker for them I think, now that there are so many good Asian horns at lower prices. I am keen to know whether they will continue on their path of wider and wider octaves or whether they will return to some sense of sanity!

Thanks David.

That's interesting because I find my Serie III bari and tenor to be the most in tune saxes I have played. I wonder if Selmer were consciously aiming for something else with the alto.

Rhys
 
Thanks David.
That's interesting because I find my Serie III bari and tenor to be the most in tune saxes I have played. I wonder if Selmer were consciously aiming for something else with the alto.
Rhys

The design has been influenced by different French players, Delangle had a lot of input on the alto, Gilles Tressos and another on the bari (evidently they couldn't agree which is why it took a long time!). But Selmer do try to get a certain tonal homogeneity between sizes so that they work as a group. I just don't personally like the S3 alto, but there are some very good players who sound great on it.
 
Here's an update from me several years on from the last post on the thread.

As I wrote earlier on this thread "I want to like my Serie III [alto], but find the tuning peculiar higher up and not as easy to play as my Mk7."

I spotted an "as new" Selmer Supreme alto neck for sale at a reasonable price. As its brushed lacquer finish matched my Serie III alto, and I had heard great things about the Supreme, I bought it.

This Supreme neck fits the Serie III very well and, after I had adjusted the neck octave key, it plays wonderfully well and seems to have sorted out the previous tuning idiosyncrasies and gives a bright and powerful sound.

This combination of Supreme neck + SIII body seems to tune much more like the MkVI and Mk7 altos that I like so much and is making me excited to play alto again.

Rhys
 
Here's an update from me several years on from the last post on the thread.

As I wrote earlier on this thread "I want to like my Serie III [alto], but find the tuning peculiar higher up and not as easy to play as my Mk7."

I spotted an "as new" Selmer Supreme alto neck for sale at a reasonable price. As its brushed lacquer finish matched my Serie III alto, and I had heard great things about the Supreme, I bought it.

This Supreme neck fits the Serie III very well and, after I had adjusted the neck octave key, it plays wonderfully well and seems to have sorted out the previous tuning idiosyncrasies and gives a bright and powerful sound.

This combination of Supreme neck + SIII body seems to tune much more like the MkVI and Mk7 altos that I like so much and is making me excited to play alto again.

Rhys
Thanks Rhys.
This is an interesting observation.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,521
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom