Saxophones Selmer no longer supreme!

@rockplayer I trekked all over Birmingham on Thursday to find a rather large music store. When I eventually found it (it had moved from its more central location 😳🙄) they had only 3 alto's on show, no tenors at all and they were cheap student models at best anyway. Then I was informed that I couldn't play test anything anyway even if I wanted to as they stopped that since covid as I was told by the guy there "yesterday's spit, today's germs" and all that! 😳
I couldn't quite get my head around that but apparently, I could order whatever I wanted and they would get it in for purchase of course.
I declined that offer.
I mean, there's just no hope is there. This shop was huge, full of digital pianos, so my son enjoyed tinkling on them all (he's pretty decent tbh grade 8) it was nice to hear him as he doesn't play much at home lately 🙄
Full of guitars too. But there's more to music than just two instruments. Birmingham is a big city and that's the best they have to offer!!
Very disappointed 😞🤷
And as a hobbyist these days, it's not really wise or practical to go around all the private ads to try out someone's horn in my opinion anyway 🤷
Otherwise your advise is sound, I agree, try as many horns as possible...... If you can actually find any in the first place!
How much farther is it to London or Bristol ? Train or M5. M6 to M1 or train ?
You have more options in two hours than LA has in 16.
 
@rockplayer I trekked all over Birmingham on Thursday to find a rather large music store. When I eventually found it (it had moved from its more central location 😳🙄) they had only 3 alto's on show, no tenors at all and they were cheap student models at best anyway. Then I was informed that I couldn't play test anything anyway even if I wanted to as they stopped that since covid as I was told by the guy there "yesterday's spit, today's germs" and all that! 😳
I couldn't quite get my head around that but apparently, I could order whatever I wanted and they would get it in for purchase of course.
I declined that offer.
I mean, there's just no hope is there. This shop was huge, full of digital pianos, so my son enjoyed tinkling on them all (he's pretty decent tbh grade 8) it was nice to hear him as he doesn't play much at home lately 🙄
Full of guitars too. But there's more to music than just two instruments. Birmingham is a big city and that's the best they have to offer!!
Very disappointed 😞🤷
And as a hobbyist these days, it's not really wise or practical to go around all the private ads to try out someone's horn in my opinion anyway 🤷
Otherwise your advise is sound, I agree, try as many horns as possible...... If you can actually find any in the first place!
It's a problem if you want to play before buying. Just a few shops here around tha have more than new YAS and YTS student saxes in stock. Musicshops are closing down or don't sell windinsruments anymore. Not easy for parents to buy saxes for their children. Lots of money.
 
@teen37
When it comes to physical music shops with a decent selection it's dire times. Munich had 2 big music shops. Just Music that closed down its Munich shop and later all its brick and mortar shops as a fallout of COVID. Last July Hieber-Linberg, a local shop with a long history of selling instruments, closed forever. There is nothing much left for musicians in Munich. Thomann is a 3 hours drive away. Munich itself is a desert for musicians.
 
@rockplayer I trekked all over Birmingham on Thursday to find a rather large music store. When I eventually found it (it had moved from its more central location 😳🙄) they had only 3 alto's on show, no tenors at all and they were cheap student models at best anyway. Then I was informed that I couldn't play test anything anyway even if I wanted to as they stopped that since covid as I was told by the guy there "yesterday's spit, today's germs" and all that! 😳
I couldn't quite get my head around that but apparently, I could order whatever I wanted and they would get it in for purchase of course.
I declined that offer.
I mean, there's just no hope is there. This shop was huge, full of digital pianos, so my son enjoyed tinkling on them all (he's pretty decent tbh grade 8) it was nice to hear him as he doesn't play much at home lately 🙄
Full of guitars too. But there's more to music than just two instruments. Birmingham is a big city and that's the best they have to offer!!
Very disappointed 😞🤷
And as a hobbyist these days, it's not really wise or practical to go around all the private ads to try out someone's horn in my opinion anyway 🤷
Otherwise your advise is sound, I agree, try as many horns as possible...... If you can actually find any in the first place!
There is Hobgoblin music they are probably the best for wind instruments in B'ham but it is very poor compared to London.
 
How much farther is it to London or Bristol ? Train or M5. M6 to M1 or train ?
You have more options in two hours than LA has in 16.
Yeah couple hours minimum on any transport. Not scheduled for another visit just yet but will pop into Sax. Co and Howarths when I'm there for sure 😉
My comment was really referring to the lack of availability of testing different horns really. Like he said, not many shops about these days.... Or something like that huh 🙄
 
There is Hobgoblin music they are probably the best for wind instruments in B'ham but it is very poor compared to London.
Yeah, I didn't quite make it to Hobgoblin last week as it's the other side of Brum to Fair deal. But next time I'm up there I'll pop in check out what they have, although their speciality is more in the line of violins, strings and celtic instruments last time I went in anyway. But worth a look. 😉
 
Then I was informed that I couldn't play test anything anyway even if I wanted to as they stopped that since covid as I was told by the guy there "yesterday's spit, today's germs" and all that! 😳
I couldn't quite get my head around that but apparently,
What a numpty.
I can understand during COVID, but people retained their wariness since then. A shop should have ways to deal with a bit of condensation in the neck (it isn't spit in most cases) after playtesting

However the other side of the coin is that real shops are not happy that a lot of the time people try stuff out in the shop then go and buy it online. They are mostly doomed.
 
Like he said, not many shops about these days....
The internet put a nail in that coffin but more like welded it shut.
I used to enjoy a round trip to Michael Whites, Don Macrill, John Myatts and amazingly could still fit Lewington's and Howarths in on the same journey sometimes. Lots of old saxes and mouthpieces. I'm still alive no issue with yesterdays spit.
But it's a shame that you have reason to feel private visits aren't wise or practical but I get it.
However along with a lot of dreamers trying to get over the odds, it's also the most likely source of hidden gems.
 
I would not buy a PM sax but if I had to buy one of these two saxophones I would go with the PM over the Selmer. Cheaper and closer to my III in character.
I have a III so I like a more edgy and aggressive sound.
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pO5O250de9U


Moved from a Slant 7* to a Freddie Gregory MKIV 7* in my teens so I am solid on my sound profile for 25 years. Now using a Beechler Bellite 8 = 3yrs and / or a Durga 4 for 8 months. Both used pieces. I have a Jody Jazz Super Jet 8, Dukoff Miami 9, my Freddie MKIV, plus been through the full list of Guradala pieces and Bergs chasing that Brecker sound. Not playing Big Band these days.

Is Neff okay? All his sites are down.
It looks like there is something wrong with that video to me. That Selmer does not look like an old selmer to me. Looking at the side keys and low Eb & C keys, not even like a MKVII? I could be wrong... can anyone tell me what it is?
When I zoom in on the bell to body ring it looks like a flat plate as opposed to Selmer round ring.
 
It looks like there is something wrong with that video to me. That Selmer does not look like an old selmer to me. Looking at the side keys and low Eb & C keys, not even like a MKVII? I could be wrong... can anyone tell me what it is?
When I zoom in on the bell to body ring it looks like a flat plate as opposed to Selmer round ring.
The video SAYS it's a Super Action 80 series II. That's what it looks like to me. "Old" is in the mind of the person deciding. To ME a Super Action 80 ain't an "old" Selmer, but to someone who was born after it was made, it might well be. The oldest SA80s are 46, 47 years old.
 
The one advantage of buying used or refurbished, you're not the first to blow it. Give curly a ring. Some lovely refubs. there.

The TJ Evo II is competitively priced with good teviews
How does that compare to the SR? I've been tempted to look at the evo because it's in my budget range but haven't tried any TJ horns yet.
Possibly a friend of a friend may be selling his TJ but I'm not sure of the model, my friend thought it was a signature custom?? I'm waiting on some more info but it may be a while yet. 🙄
 
How does that compare to the SR? I've been tempted to look at the evo because it's in my budget range but haven't tried any TJ horns yet.
Possibly a friend of a friend may be selling his TJ but I'm not sure of the model, my friend thought it was a signature custom?? I'm waiting on some more info but it may be a while yet. 🙄
Probably telling you what you already know, (catsplaining), Stephen Howard has a lot of reviews on his site.
 
"Old" is in the mind of the person deciding. To ME a Super Action 80 ain't an "old" Selmer, but to someone who was born after it was made, it might well be. The oldest SA80s are 46, 47 years old.
True, thanks.
Did the super 80 have flat plate body to bell ring? I guess thats the most likely explanation.
It was initially the side keys and bow braces that made me scratch my head but I can't see why anybody would try to palm it off as something it's not, so I guess it's my lack of knowledge about the more modern selmers.
Screenshot 2026-11-02 at 12.20.51.webp
 
Last edited:
How does that compare to the SR? I've been tempted to look at the evo because it's in my budget range but haven't tried any TJ horns yet.
Possibly a friend of a friend may be selling his TJ but I'm not sure of the model, my friend thought it was a signature custom?? I'm waiting on some more info but it may be a while yet. 🙄
I've covered the Evo II (alto) It's very nice. In fact I'd rate it slightly over the SR in terms of build quality.
It comes out of TJ's new Chinese factory - and it looks to me like they've got quality-control nicely buttoned down.
Definitely worth a try, even if only to rule it out.
The Signature Custom range are all very good and would make an excellent secondhand purchase - assuming you liked it.
 
@Stephen Howard thanks 😉👍 I have always loved the look of the Raw from when I first saw it pictured in your book, it was love at first sight to be honest 😍😍😍🎷 but never considered them as they were always beyond my budget, but I find your comments on the Evo compared to the SR interesting 🤔☺️
I'll definitely be giving the TJ horns a go when I get the opportunity for sure ☺️
 
What a numpty.
Sure, I get that folks can be squeamish about blowing into a horn that someone else has blown - but if someone feels it's an issue then a quick squirt of a suitable disinfectant will clean a crook out in no time at all.
And in any event you're far more likely to pick up something nasty from playing a keyboard/guitar that someone else's grubby fingers have been all over.
Lots was learned about sanitizing horns during Covid. New information, nope. Keyboards, yuck !
Yeah couple hours minimum on any transport. Not scheduled for another visit just yet but will pop into Sax. Co and Howarths when I'm there for sure 😉
My comment was really referring to the lack of availability of testing different horns really. Like he said, not many shops about these days.... Or something like that huh 🙄
I mentioned Bristol because there’s one sax specialty shop, Headwinds. I’ve purchased two vintage horns from them via email. Good variety & hardworking people.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,660
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom