Intonation Sax in tune but playing sounds flat

It sounded great to me but, in my personal opinion it sounds too good. Try to relax a little when you play, don't try to sound like the original because your not. Sound like yourself and don't try to imitate someone else. Enjoy the music and your enjoyment will be heard.
 
It sounded great to me but, in my personal opinion it sounds too good. Try to relax a little when you play, don't try to sound like the original because your not. Sound like yourself and don't try to imitate someone else. Enjoy the music and your enjoyment will be heard.

Yup. Maybe I was trying to hard. Ok, so its not me.. 🙂 woo hoo!!
 
Tuning is a complex subject and Al's comment derives I suspect mostly from the issue of 'equal temperament' tuning (which is how keyboards are tuned) which is what most tuning meters will show you.

Trouble is, ET is a compromise to enable keyboards to play in 'any' key. This is does by compromising the tuning in various places, such as major thirds are way too wide, fifths are slightly too narrow etc.

Good players of non-keyboards instrument will adjust to tune these things. Most of us lack that level of skill...
 
To me it is a bit misleading to call a performance "flat" when what you mean is "lacks energy and intensity". Flat is commonly associated with pitch in music hence the "misleading" part. I had a teacher once who said, "If you are not tired at the end of a phrase, you are not doing it right." The point is that "physical energy" is turned into "sound energy" when one plays a musical instrument. If you want more energy coming out in the sound, you have to put more energy into the tone production.
 
To me it is a bit misleading to call a performance "flat" when what you mean is "lacks energy and intensity". Flat is commonly associated with pitch in music hence the "misleading" part. I had a teacher once who said, "If you are not tired at the end of a phrase, you are not doing it right." The point is that "physical energy" is turned into "sound energy" when one plays a musical instrument. If you want more energy coming out in the sound, you have to put more energy into the tone production.

That trouble with words in everyday use and technical use again. Physical energy (chemical, strain, kinetic) is being turned into sound energy (and heat, kinetic etc.) when you play an instrument. But a more energetic performance in sound energy terms is louder ie the sound waves have a bigger amplitude. More energetic in performance terms (vibrant, intense) is not so much volume as attack of notes, breath support and so on?
 
It sounded great to me but, in my personal opinion it sounds too good. Try to relax a little when you play, don't try to sound like the original because your not. Sound like yourself and don't try to imitate someone else. Enjoy the music and your enjoyment will be heard.
How spooky is that. I was lying in bed this morning thinking we hadn't heard from you for a while and voila 🙂

Wonder who else I can conjure up!

Jx
 
That trouble with words in everyday use and technical use again. Physical energy (chemical, strain, kinetic) is being turned into sound energy (and heat, kinetic etc.) when you play an instrument. But a more energetic performance in sound energy terms is louder ie the sound waves have a bigger amplitude. More energetic in performance terms (vibrant, intense) is not so much volume as attack of notes, breath support and so on?
Your point is well taken. Most listeners at a live concert can pick up on the amount of energy the performer or group is investing in the performance at hand. It is not necessarily how loud the music is either, but the sum of many variables some of which are intangible. I will note however that the "intensity" of a player's sound can be a function of the harmonics generated by the input energy even at softer levels.
 
@Jeanette I'm now worried that you were lying in bed thinking of me! :headscratch:
Oops didn't think that one through, not sure how my train of thought went but I think BOTM was where it started and how long will I love you ...........

Am I making things worse? Lol all innocent thoughts I promise 🙂

Missing your recordings and stories though

Jx
 
This discussion on sounding flat, Jbt's comments about feeling tired and Taz's comments really show what's wrong here. You can't liven up a performance by adding in a bit of technique X. You need to feel and live the performance. If you're consciously thinking about which ornaments to use, it comes over in your playing.

What makes the original so good is that most people get an emotional lock into it, but it's not cheese. What makes it bad is the endless airplay which has, sadly, clichéd it.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,385
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom