Miscellaneous RIP Bridges, the Middle 8?

6441

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,846

"Bridges used to be a core feature of popular music, but they’ve become an endangered species, right next to the sitcom laugh track.
With today’s pop songs increasingly devoid of bridges, how do we form emotional, heart-swelling connections to pop songs? For Jenna, the answer lies in the earthquake that hit the world in 2018: TikTok."

I didn't listen (don't care that much about pop music), but was interested in the compositional aspect of the bridge. In my compositions, I usually write two sections, although I rarely use traditional forms like AABA or ABA which used to confuse me to no end at jam sessions. I still have to pay close attention to follow an AABA in an extended jam.

View: https://soundcloud.com/randulo/enough-2020-kirkdrums
 
I'd say bridges and C-sections (no not that kind) have always been a bit sparse in pop music since around the 90's at least.

To me, in rock/pop...a good bridge, or beyond that - a song which has 3 sections, usually illustrates a composer who knows something...(usually).

I dunno why this band popped into my head when I read this...but the Mexican group Mana, with Fher Olvera (lead singer) as their main composer, is a good example of a pop/rock band's compositions containing different sections. I will often listen to their tunes, where just the verse-chorus are catchy and interesting enough and certainly would have sufficed for a mega-rockband single...and then they throw in a bridge or C-section which really elevates the song, IMHO.

(Oh...the article/episode, despite its promising title....sadly, is pretty shallow and disappointing by the end....holy cow what a mish-mash list of bridge songs. These people get paid to write/broadcast this and THAT is all they can come up with ?)
 
Last edited:
Oh...the article/episode, despite its promising title....sadly, is pretty shallow and disappointing by the end..
I was intrigued by the title, which made me think, but only quickly scanned the text as I don't acre. The concept, though... most of what I'd find the best non-classical music, if not blues-based (let's not go there again!) has a bridge. The ubiquitous I Got Rhythm pattern had to have one to break that diatonic monotony. There are, of course, plenty of blues with a bridge in jazz, too. The Beatles, The Kinks, Gerry and the Pacemakers, all that stuff had a lot of bridges. A lot of music today consists of very long vamps with the mix and the beat changing of time. A good, interesting composition needs some way to change the tension, and that way is usually the bridge and sometimes breaks. Otherwise, you can use the "orchestration", a lofty word that I mean here is "whose playing at once?".

So let's say we're vamping in G.

"Let's bring on down real low"
the bad lowers volume and everyone drops out except a quiet drum part.
The bass joins, and develops from simple to an actual structure of little groups of groove variations.
Now the singer (or a soloist) starts some failry low volume work.
Two places to go from there:
a. Full stop, then everyone back at full volume
b. The horns (or guitars) come in as the rhythm section stops completely.

Compared to What, modulate a half-step up when it starts ghetting monotonous.

Or... do all those things! Great example of performance dynamics, not to mention not-too-shabby playing.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pFX5nn7XElY


Everyone go practice now!
 
The A B A or "sonata form" is perhaps the most often used form in classical, jazz, and pop music because it works. Exposition, Development, and Recapitualtion can be found in jazz combo recordings as well as many big band charts. The tune or "head" is played (and repeated) [Exposition] then the elements of the melody are "developed" through improvisation [Development], and then the "head" is repeated at the end (to remind the listener what tune it was to begin with 😉) in a type of Recapitulation.

It is not uncommon for jazz musicians to remember the verse but forget the bridge on songs they play that are audience requests. In the quartet I played in for many years, the piano player had a "utility bridge" to play on those occasions that he called "Melancholy Bridge". When he didn't know a song he would say, "I'm sorry, the band doesn't know that song, but we can play one with a lot of the same notes in it". The person making the request would say thanks and walk away satisfied.
 
The A B A or "sonata form" is perhaps the most often used form in classical, jazz, and pop music because it works.
Interesting, I would have thought AABA was most common in jazz, especially with vocals. I lose count often in those, unless I know the tune well. As for not knowing the bridge, I was playing a concert as leader and we needed an extra tune, so I called "Everybody Has the Blues" (James Taylor) and in the last bar of the verse, I realized the guys wouldn't know the bridge. We all instinctively played Ryhthm Changes bridge, since the A section is kind of based on that.
In the music I play, the B is the bridge, not development but part of the expo. Development is the part in the next group of solos. But that's my music, where I make my own rules 🙂
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I was intrigued by the title, which made me think, but only quickly scanned the text as I don't acre. The concept, though... most of what I'd find the best non-classical music, if not blues-based (let's not go there again!) has a bridge. The ubiquitous I Got Rhythm pattern had to have one to break that diatonic monotony. There are, of course, plenty of blues with a bridge in jazz, too. The Beatles, The Kinks, Gerry and the Pacemakers, all that stuff had a lot of bridges. A lot of music today consists of very long vamps with the mix and the beat changing of time. A good, interesting composition needs some way to change the tension, and that way is usually the bridge and sometimes breaks. Otherwise, you can use the "orchestration", a lofty word that I mean here is "whose playing at once?".

So let's say we're vamping in G.

"Let's bring on down real low"
the bad lowers volume and everyone drops out except a quiet drum part.
The bass joins, and develops from simple to an actual structure of little groups of groove variations.
Now the singer (or a soloist) starts some failry low volume work.
Two places to go from there:
a. Full stop, then everyone back at full volume
b. The horns (or guitars) come in as the rhythm section stops completely.

Compared to What, modulate a half-step up when it starts ghetting monotonous.

Or... do all those things! Great example of performance dynamics, not to mention not-too-shabby playing.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pFX5nn7XElY


Everyone go practice now!
Right on, 100%.

And as bass has been my longtime primary instrument, I gotta tell you this can drive me bats...particularly the number of songs which not only sit on a single 4, 8, or 12 bar progression and never leave...but also songs which sit on a single chord for their entirety.

I actually have a policy...I will NOT play those one-chord or two chord songs...unless we rearrange them and add a bridge or some sort of interlude or something...some sorta something in there which adds .....(gasp)....a second or third chord. 😱

This might seem like a picayune subject to some, but it really does have its impact in the long term view of things.

I will tell you one way it does:

Over the years in various groups I have put ads up for singers and either tried them out with the band or simply have traded online samples with them. They younger 'kids', talking 20-something particularly....some have 'written' their own songs, which I always give a listen to.
What I usually hear...in the 'contemporary R&B' or 'neo-soul' or even pop-rock vein of things, is the singer (who most often has simply had a backing track created with a drumbeat, perhaps some keyboard chords, and a synthesized bass line...no real back-up band of human beings)... having concentrated on their lyrics, obviously...then of secondary importance was the beat they chose....and of ancillary importance was any sort of chord progression and any sort of attempt to move the composition to a build-release sort of dynamic, even where the lyrics themselves call for it. Oftentimes, there are a few points where the notes of their melody do not even match with the pre-recorded chords.
Yet they think its a completed song and are quite happy with it.

At BEST, a somewhat clued-in singer songwriter has "verse-chorus" in their head, at least, so there's at least a A and a B. But more young pop/contemporary songwriters/singers....they really do not even have a grasp on the basic tenets of a compositions 'form'. They just have the words they wanna get out there, and they just shoehorn them into a pedestrian, oftentimes trite instrumental track devoid of any real dynamic.

I think part of this is also due to, as we have discussed in multiple threads here, the decrease in availability of instrumental (and vocal, too, admittedly) music programs at the youth level...combined with the 'ease' and availability of using technology to create your own backing tracks.

Absent in the latter is the entire dynamic of actually interacting with other musicians in a live situation in order to hash thru and suss out the final product (song). There's no 'need' to do that any longer.
Harrumph.

Damn kids these days....(spits on ground, kicks dirt, walks away....)
 
Last edited:
Right on, 100%.

And as bass has been my longtime primary instrument, I gotta tell you this can drive me bats...particularly the number of songs which not only sit on a single 4, 8, or 12 bar progression and never leave...but also songs which sit on a single chord for their entirety.

I actually have a policy...I will NOT play those one-chord or two chord songs...unless we rearrange them and add a bridge or some sort of interlude or something...some sorta something in there which adds .....(gasp)....a second or third chord. 😱

This might seem like a picayune subject to some, but it really does have its impact in the long term view of things.

I will tell you one way it does:

Over the years in various groups I have put ads up for singers and either tried them out with the band or simply have traded online samples with them. They younger 'kids', talking 20-something particularly....some have 'written' their own songs, which I always give a listen to.
What I usually hear...in the 'contemporary R&B' or 'neo-soul' or even pop-rock vein of things, is the singer (who most often has simply had a backing track created with a drumbeat, perhaps some keyboard chords, and a synthesized bass line...no real back-up band of human beings)... having concentrated on their lyrics, obviously...then of secondary importance was the beat they chose....and of ancillary importance was any sort of chord progression and any sort of attempt to move the composition to a build-release sort of dynamic, even where the lyrics themselves call for it. Oftentimes, there are a few points where the notes of their melody do not even match with the pre-recorded chords.
Yet they think its a completed song and are quite happy with it.

At BEST, a somewhat clued-in singer songwriter has "verse-chorus" in their head, at least, so there's at least a A and a B. But more young pop/contemporary songwriters/singers....they really do not even have a grasp on the basic tenets of a compositions 'form'. They just have the words they wanna get out there, and they just shoehorn them into a pedestrian, oftentimes trite instrumental track devoid of any real dynamic.

Damn kids these days....(spits on ground, kicks dirt, walks away....)

Sounds like they could usefully work with a songwriting partner who knows a bit about music. Partnerships worked well for many of the greats. Knowing your own limitations is nothing to be ashamed of and it's good to be open to outside suggestions from someone sympathetic.

Rhys
 
Sounds like they could usefully work with a songwriting partner who knows a bit about music. Partnerships worked well for many of the greats. Knowing your own limitations is nothing to be ashamed of and it's good to be open to outside suggestions from someone sympathetic.

Rhys
I absolutely agree. I mean, honestly...sometimes...the seed of a decent song is IN there...it's just undeveloped....yet they think its just fine and some actually become a bit offended when in a band setting other players start throwing around ideas on changing it, to make it more musical....
But then I have also had some young singers who appreciated those efforts as well...
 
I gotta tell you this can drive me bats...particularly the number of songs which not only sit on a single 4, 8, or 12 bar progression and never leave...but also songs which sit on a single chord for their entirety.
Arrangement is a lost art, mostly replaced by a mix that starts with a beat, brings in some synth stuff, some of which sounds like a buzz saw, a few whoops, and then the bridge, which is the same thing with bass and no saw.

I meant to say above, the few times I've been leader, I've explained to them that even in a trio there are 8 combinations to orchestrate.

Silence
one of the three as single soloists
X & Y
X & Z
Y & Z
X & Y &Z

In a quartet, there are 16 of those permutations. Quintet, 32. That's a lot of variation in density alone!
(Density being the number of attacks.)

I worked with one band where the drummer and violinist played a long passage with no bass or guitar.

Without dynamics, it's awfully boring unless the singer or one player is so incredible no one is listening to anything else.

Here's a nice demo of the principle IMO.
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OZ7EvYTCXGw
 
Interesting, I would have thought AABA was most common in jazz, especially with vocals.
In my understanding the "ternary" (3 part) form can have different variations: AABA, ABBA, AABBAA etc. which are essentially the same. When I taught a high school music fundamentals class years ago one of the questions on my test was "What is ABBA?" One of the students wrote "a Swedish vocal group" which I marked as wrong. The next day he brought in an ABBA album to show me and I changed his score on the test embarrassed that I was not keeping up with current pop music.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,552
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom