Reeds Rico Jazz Select: Filed vs Unfiled (w/ sound clips)

I play for about six hours a day minus Jam Sessions. The reeds are always soaking after about 30 minutes. Almost transparant! If I keep playing that reed it is totally soft within 4 hours and then breaks!

I don't do anything to my reeds when I take one out of the box apart from dampen it in my mouth for a few seconds! It plays like a dream for about 30 minutes! Then gets soft so I end up getting another reed.

I doubt the salt air is any different to Wales ;}

Do wonder if I'm doing something wrong or if I need to try harder reeds, break them in and then I'll have a playable reed for longer? :confused:
 
Hi Paul!

A few suggestions:

1. Prepare reeds according to the Alexander website, especially make sure that you are massaging them using thumb or index finger, which will make them tougher and less likely to become soggy. Then play them gently at pp - mp, not any louder, for 10 mins at a time. Do not play them to death!

2. Have at least 4 on the go, invest in a reed case, and replace the reed that you are playing when it seems soggy - massage it to get some moisture out of the reed and replace in case to dry.

3. Wet them in some mouthwash before playing, not in mouth as saliva damages reeds.

Once you have a decent routine going it should be quite easy to maintain and save you lots of money. It is often a good idea to try and prepare all the reeds in a pack and rate them - saving the very best for performance. In a packet of 10 I usually have 4/6 excellent ones (marked +1) and 4/6 slightly less good (marked 1), and very rarely have a poorer one (-1). Given your high practice commitment it may be best to have up to 8 reeds on the go, playing a different 4 each day, so they all have some recovery time.

Hope this helps.
Kind regards
Tom
 
Hi Paul!

A few suggestions:

1. Prepare reeds according to the Alexander website, especially make sure that you are massaging them using thumb or index finger, which will make them tougher and less likely to become soggy. Then play them gently at pp - mp, not any louder, for 10 mins at a time. Do not play them to death!

2. Have at least 4 on the go, invest in a reed case, and replace the reed that you are playing when it seems soggy - massage it to get some moisture out of the reed and replace in case to dry.

3. Wet them in some mouthwash before playing, not in mouth as saliva damages reeds.

Once you have a decent routine going it should be quite easy to maintain and save you lots of money. It is often a good idea to try and prepare all the reeds in a pack and rate them - saving the very best for performance. In a packet of 10 I usually have 4/6 excellent ones (marked +1) and 4/6 slightly less good (marked 1), and very rarely have a poorer one (-1). Given your high practice commitment it may be best to have up to 8 reeds on the go, playing a different 4 each day, so they all have some recovery time.

Hope this helps.
Kind regards
Tom

Thanks Tom! I'll give that a try and let you know how I get on after a week or two! Didn't know about massaging the reed to toughen it up or that saliva damages the reed! Interesting!
 
Is your embouchure too tight Paul? I think that's what did in my first Legere Sig 2 on my metal Yani 9.

The problem has started after switching to the Metal 7* so it is possible that my embouchure is a little different and maybe the problem! Will have a look at it too be sure! I do know that the corners of my mouth are tighter than they used to be!
 
You'll have to go back to a children's tenor mouthpiece................:shocked::w00t:

Love
Tom😎

and that would be ... 🙂))

Just checked my embouchure and it's fine not tight so it's just getting the reeds to last longer. Having just read somethings about reeds - I realise that I'm not breaking them in gently! I'm going 'Bat's of out hell' with them from the off! :w00t: So that probably isn't helping any! The massaging looks good so will be trying that! ;}
 
A few weeks ago I bought a box of RJS 2H filed as I'd run out of the Rico Royals. Am really enjoying them. Wonderful sound. No issues with longevity or playabilty. I'll try a box of 2Ms, but will probably switch to them from the royals. The filed reeds have, for me, a much richer sound, especially compared to the bog standard orange box ricos.
 
Apparently Links are noted for their heavy reed usage, which is why Charlie Parker switched to a Runyon 22/Brilhart Tonalin on Tenor Sax as well...........................

Kind regards
Tom

I've not heard that but looking back my problems started when I got the Link 7* for the Alto! I don't have this problem as much on the Tenor.

I'm going to set-up my A901 with the Link 7* and the YAS-275 with a Yani Ebonite 7 and do a back to back test to see which one lasts the longest over a two week period! It'll be interesting to see the results!

If so I might opt for a Berg Larsen on the Alto!
 
A few weeks ago I bought a box of RJS 2H filed as I'd run out of the Rico Royals. Am really enjoying them. Wonderful sound. No issues with longevity or playabilty. I'll try a box of 2Ms, but will probably switch to them from the royals. The filed reeds have, for me, a much richer sound, especially compared to the bog standard orange box ricos.

The orange box are hopeless! I love the Royals but since using the RJS I have to say they are my reed of choice! I have been mainly playing the unfiled as it has the desired sound I like but the filed ones are more responsive for me and I prefer them for when I have to play faster!
 
Brian,

Thanks for the feedback and support on conclusions. As far as you not finding the differences as amplified as me - I think that could be due to any number of factors from equipment to playing technique, but the differences are clearly there either way.

And as far as playing the same thing for playtests and not moving around on the mic, etc. The idea behind the recordings I do is to demonstrate the overall sound of a piece of equipment. I play whatever feels/sounds good on that piece of equipment. so, yes, even on back to back reed comparisons I'll play different things. You definitely still hear the differences.

Finally, I agree that mic placement does change the sound. However, the mic was placed in the same place and though I probably did move some on the recording I'm not prone to moving around very much while I play. I stay on mic pretty well.

Basically, I'm trying to provide a good resource for players to get the general idea of a piece of equipment. The details, as we all know, will be subjective to the player, but at least they have a very good idea of what they are getting into.

Yea man, as I said I definitely appreciate anyone taking the time to post tests/reviews. They definitely can give you some valuable info about what you are getting into, the extent of which though, I can't agree would be "a very good idea". The amount of variables are so immense that you really can't tell a whole lot with these things. With every player from amazing to mediocre, there will be a million perspectives on every facet of horn playing; from the reed to the resonator.

Anyway, still I'd say is that it would be best to play something the same or very similar between takes. I mean, the point is to directly compare two things right? The odds of consistency/transparency are against us already, so we might as well measure things in a controlled way as much as possible. In your comparison, there are moments where take 2 sounds just as bright as take 1; probably because of the way you were playing the horn (volume/articulation/embouchure) and mic distance/placement. It also sounded like the unflied reed wasn't performing/responding as well as the filed one; as if it wasn't a good reed itself. I don't mean to offend your work in any way, just giving some honest feedback based on experience.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,569
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom