Saxophones Requesting guidance on purchase of budget Saxophone in india

philomath

New Member
Messages
3
Location
India
Hey everyone,

I was looking for a Saxophone around a budget of $500 in India. I have failed to find any good used instrument in India, and buying any internationally is infeasible due to more than 40% import duty.

I came across a Chateau CAS-21 Saxophone, which is available for $640 to me. Could you please take a look and tell me if I should go ahead with it? This will be my first Saxophone. I have failed to find any other Saxophone within my budget(except brands like Jinbao, Kadence, Diplomat US, Allora, Vienna, Pluto, Havana, etc). I read a few favourable reviews for the Chateau brand(Tenon factory in Taiwan), but couldn't find any specific review of the model(Chateau CAS 21).

For reference, a Mendini by Cecilio is available for $476, Jinbao for $380, Allora for $390, Kadence for $400.

Do you think the Chateau CAS 21L would be a good one to go for at $640 and would it hold any resale value a few years down the line?
 
The Jinbao can be good. If there is a shop that has them then you could try them out. Quality control can often be lacking i.e. there can be good ones, but not all are going to be good/playable without some tweaking. You didn't state whether you already know how to play. If you don't, and have a teacher, then I'd take them along to help select a good one.

Resale value for any cheap student sax is difficult to judge for us as I'd imagine India is not going to have the same demand and markets as Europe or USA. As a guess I'd think that Mumbai would be the place to look for a good used instrument due to the Bollywood industry.
 
So....if you buy a used alto sax from abroad for, say $300-350 plus shipping add another $90-120....and import duty is adding another $150-170...the total = $550-640+/-...which is likely a bit cheaper than the Chateau.

Just taking your info and assigning numbers to it. Seems to suggest you could buy something like a used Jupiter, Bundy, maybe contemporary Evette-Buffet, even a Taiwanese-made Olds, etc. for the same price or a bit less than the Chateau. You might conceivably even find a Vito-branded Yamaha (possible, although usually they run a bit more).

All would be better horns...but then you would need to firm up your buyer's radar a bit more and get some assurances from seller as to play condition....plus, wait for the horn to arrive.

So...maybe that is worth it to you...or maybe the quicker gratification of buying a budget asian model (which you realize may not have too much longevity, and will, as Wade notes, seriously lose resale value) just to get something new and get it in your hands sooner....is a better option for you .....
 
A quick search reveals that the CAS-21 is Chateau's entry level student model. It sells on Amazon for around $1000 and on Music Medic for $965. If it is in good condition $600 would be a fair price for a used one IMO. As @nigeld indicated the Chateau line of saxophones are made by the Tenon company and are manufactured in Vietnam. They have an excellent reputation in the US. Curt Altarac at Music Medic would not endorse or sell them if they were not a good quality saxophone.
 
Thank you so much for your most prompt response.

The Jinbao can be good.
I shall check them out.

You didn't state whether you already know how to play.
I learnt to play about 7 years back, and out of touch for 5 years. Would consider myself beginner-intermediate, not good. I am however not in touch with any teacher as of now. Also, most stores are more than 500 km away from me, so will have to close the purchase online or over the phone. I understand that it will always be in my best interest to purchase only after physically checking out the instrument though.

As a guess I'd think that Mumbai would be the place to look for a good used instrument due to the Bollywood industry.
I am trying to find players in India, in hope that they could either sell something lying around, or connect me to some dealer who could do the same. As mentioned, I would be happy to have a used instrument in good playing condition.

I thank you very much again for your response. Have a good day!
 
So....if you buy a used alto sax from abroad for, say $300-350 plus shipping add another $90-120....and import duty is adding another $150-170...the total = $550-640+/-...which is likely a bit cheaper than the Chateau.

Just taking your info and assigning numbers to it. Seems to suggest you could buy something like a used Jupiter, Bundy, maybe contemporary Evette-Buffet, even a Taiwanese-made Olds, etc. for the same price or a bit less than the Chateau. You might conceivably even find a Vito-branded Yamaha (possible, although usually they run a bit more).

All would be better horns...but then you would need to firm up your buyer's radar a bit more and get some assurances from seller as to play condition....plus, wait for the horn to arrive.

So...maybe that is worth it to you...or maybe the quicker gratification of buying a budget asian model (which you realize may not have too much longevity, and will, as Wade notes, seriously lose resale value) just to get something new and get it in your hands sooner....is a better option for you .....
Your calculations put a lot of things in perspective and I appreciate the time you took to reply. As a first time purchaser, I would find it extremely risky to invest in something overseas, as you yourself mentioned that I will need to be very careful about it. I could still consider the more reputed dealers like junkdude, brassandwoodwind.ca, etc and have been monitoring their pages, as I read in multiple places that almost all the instruments that they sell are very good quality and well-restored. Over the past 2 weeks, they havent had anything that could fall within my budget(incl shipping+customs). Thanks for the suggestion though, and I will keep that in mind as I search for an instrument.

I have heard good things about Chateau saxophones, but nothing good or bad about the CAS-21. I believe it is made in Vietnam, where Tenon have a factory.
A quick search reveals that the CAS-21 is Chateau's entry level student model. It sells on Amazon for around $1000 and on Music Medic for $965. If it is in good condition $600 would be a fair price for a used one IMO. As @nigeld indicated the Chateau line of saxophones are made by the Tenon company and are manufactured in Vietnam. They have an excellent reputation in the US. Curt Altarac at Music Medic would not endorse or sell them if they were not a good quality saxophone.
The model you linked to is Chateau Model CAS-22GL. I am not sure what or how different is it from the CAS-21(The one available in India). You mention $965, I am able to get the CAS-21 for $620 in India from the official distributor. Is this to mean that I should consider the instrument?

I really appreciate everyone's time and thank you all for replying!
 
Your calculations put a lot of things in perspective and I appreciate the time you took to reply. As a first time purchaser, I would find it extremely risky to invest in something overseas, as you yourself mentioned that I will need to be very careful about it. I could still consider the more reputed dealers like junkdude, brassandwoodwind.ca, etc and have been monitoring their pages, as I read in multiple places that almost all the instruments that they sell are very good quality and well-restored. Over the past 2 weeks, they havent had anything that could fall within my budget(incl shipping+customs). Thanks for the suggestion though, and I will keep that in mind as I search for an instrument.


The model you linked to is Chateau Model CAS-22GL. I am not sure what or how different is it from the CAS-21(The one available in India). You mention $965, I am able to get the CAS-21 for $620 in India from the official distributor. Is this to mean that I should consider the instrument?

I really appreciate everyone's time and thank you all for replying!
I am not intending to make this any sort of sales pitch...I do the same thing Junkdude does, and generally my offerings are far cheaper. I have sent you a PM.

There may also be some sellers people here can recommend in Europe or perhaps AU ???...who sell refurbished horns ???

You are correct, if you were to do it long-distance...go with a reputed seller who has a return policy.

Honestly, tho...back to the cheap new horn option...it would satisfy some immediate wants: youd have your horn, it'd be new, and it'd probably be somewhat reliable for at least a while...so it'd be the quicker alternative to get one in your hands. The flip side would be resale and reliability in the longer run (say, after the first year or so)....
 
I have heard good things about Chateau saxophones, but nothing good or bad about the CAS-21. I believe it is made in Vietnam, where Tenon have a factory.
I tried some at Frankfurt Musik Messe a few years ago, and the funny thing is I was more impressed with the playability of the cheaper models over the more expensive ones.
Build quality seemed up to par for the price - but if I were buying one for myself I'd go for the cheaper models.
 
How about a Buescher "TrueTone" alto saxophone: those made from 1926-1931? They sometimes sell quite reasonably if a person is patient; which for playability are simply fantastic! Classical saxophonist John-Edward Kelly played a silver-plate 1928 model and required all their students play similar Bueschers.

We paid $400 for our first, a 1930 gold-plate model during 1996, that was playable for a few years, sat awhile then got restored during 2014 for $1350 by Seattle's Carlo Cennamo www.cennamowoodwinds.com

We now have a second 1926 model we paid only $100 for plus $30 shipping which needs a restoration though is pristine otherwise..bare brass with nickel plated keywork..even the original case is pristine..I got lucky.

We are also waiting on another 1926 Buescher TrueTone alto that's being restored now, we paid $410 in our hands from an online sources. The restoration cost $475, perhaps since in New Mexico rather than Seattle?

What I think would be your best bet, would be to take a look at the 2nd Ending website where George tries to present for sale, nice used musical instruments they have fixed up. www.2ndending.com

George will fix you up nicely, or make sure to give you good advice.
IMG_20240909_132642.webp
 
Another fine alternative may be a Selmer/Buescher alto. These were made once Selmer bought Buescher during the 1960s, said to be largely based upon prior Buescher design though not as fine quality control..thus, marketed as 'student' instruments and priced less than so-called 'professional' models of other manufacturers.

A year or so ago, we bought for someone a Selmer/Buescher alto of this type; an online purchase from Sam Ash Music they'd advertised for $199 which cost $212 delivered, said to be in good condition with lots of good service still. They often sell similarly, who would provide decent sales support, if there were any issues. www.samash.com

There are many discussions of these saxophones in sax related websites: however Carlo Cennamo also advocates for them too, in their website; touted as better than many instruments selling for much more, as fundamentally sound in design and manufacture, while also mass produced extensively so that often available for really decent prices..

We have one that cost $50 plus $52 shipping, we had to get an used neck for online about $30 from a similar Bundy alto saxophone, plus a case found online very cheap for $40 or so, and a mouthpiece for $11 from a toy online made like a recorder using alto sax mouthpieces..so, about $180 total that plays okay, even.

Surely, two good examples of feasible options?

Looking for an instrument online, try to pay attention to the presentation. Are any photos exemplary, giving a good idea of what is being sold. Does the seller seem reputable? Ask questions..are they fine giving replies?

IMG_20240909_131622.webp
IMG_20240909_131622.webp
 
Thinking further, in the situation there; making sure any sax you buy is properly serviced and playing well seems important. Because there may be limited resources in India.

This means finding a seller trustworthy about making sure any instrument plays well, and will continue playing well too. So, George and their 2nd Ending business, or a large reputable business like Sam Ash or sometimes Carlo Cennamo too.

There are others too; so once you have contacted a few folk, someone should be able to fit your needs. Just go slow and methodically, until you feel informed, confident & prepared to proceed.

Another thing more individual, is an embouchure. Classical saxophonist Harvey Pittel suggested the one we use, when asking what famed saxophonist John Coltrane had played? To demonstrate, Harvey put a thumb in my mouth, saying to think of the thumbnail as if the reed. A player uses absolutely no pressure from their teeth, above or below the reed or mouthpiece; keeping a seal with the lips, using all the associated musculature of the lips, face and head, etc. Myself, if not playing awhile, can take about three months practice to have my embouchure back.
 
The original poster hasn't been seen for a long time. He was also clear that importing to India wasn't an option due to very high import duties. So the info above is likely to be of use to US-resident readers rather than the original poster.

Even importing saxes from the US to Europe isn't really cost effective. Import duties are low, but factoring in high shipping costs, VAT (sales tax) which applied to the item and the shipping, it's just not financially viable. I've tried it and it's not worth it.
 
A quick search reveals that the CAS-21 is Chateau's entry level student model. It sells on Amazon for around $1000 and on Music Medic for $965. If it is in good condition $600 would be a fair price for a used one IMO. As @nigeld indicated the Chateau line of saxophones are made by the Tenon company and are manufactured in Vietnam. They have an excellent reputation in the US. Curt Altarac at Music Medic would not endorse or sell them if they were not a good quality saxophone.
 
Davinder Kumar sold us a curved soprano marketed as their "baby saxophone" during 2004, for $104 in our hands in Arcata, CA. These are made in India, which despite a simplified mechanism with no low Bb and a very positive G#, have a fantastic hard rubber mouthpiece and sound great.

Those were sold via the www.trmusicals.com website which seems active again after a hiatus. Though their offerings seem different; while a few years ago Davinder was selling the same type saxophones elsewhere on the internet.

The instrument we had was obviously far below the standards expected of even very cheap conventional saxes, however played really well and was inherently sturdy despite for instance puffy red leather pads meant to make adjustments less critical.

Though obviously not what the originator of this thread may be looking for, I would be curious how affordable these saxes are there in India where they are made? What is a good comparison? How are the native made saxophones accepted in India, and what musicians play them, and what do they play?
 
By the way, trmusicals.com was said to've begun by trying to grow and market reed cane from India.

Two of their reeds came with their saxophone, that played well; which had a nice honey color and perhaps a little sweeter flavor, whose grain seemed a little coarser than usual that may've simply been variance normal to such things?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,472
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom