Reeds Reeds wearing out

I think similarly. My concern is to make sure that the reed is stroked on a flat surface after playing so that the fibres are compacted a little, before being returned to my reed case - they then dry and are soaked for at least a minute or so before being played again....

Kind regards
Tom

BTW I hear that Nick plays better when he is also soaked....!
 
BTW I hear that Nick plays better when he is also soaked....![/QUOTE]

Yep, that's a beer bottle in his hand!

Back to topic.

Some people do apparently suffer from the "soggy reed" problem. I always give my m'piece & reed a quick slurp of beer, it always gets a laugh.
Fibracell, and to a lesser extent, Plasticoat, don't work through absorbing moisture! I think they work because of aerodynamics!!! ( I only have experience of Fibracell).

John.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi Everybody

Recently I have found myself in a similar situation to Mandy,that constant search for a playable comfortable reed,only managing to find two or three useful reeds in a box of ten and then when the joy starts and the ease of playing helps you to improve only to have the reed go off too soon and have to start all over again with the search.So I decided to have an experiment with a number of synthetic reeds and various reeds I had not tried before,so off I trotted to my local music shop with a plan to sort this problem once and for all.The result was a bill for £65 and many various reeds to try,the outcome may surprise a few of the members it certainly surprised me.I have been considering to blogg the results of this exhaustive test,anybody interested let me know ad I'll have a go at putting it in black and white.....john

ps this will be purely from a novices point of view
 
Hi Everybody

Recently I have found myself in a similar situation to Mandy,that constant search for a playable comfortable reed,only managing to find two or three useful reeds in a box of ten and then when the joy starts and the ease of playing helps you to improve only to have the reed go off too soon and have to start all over again with the search.So I decided to have an experiment with a number of synthetic reeds and various reeds I had not tried before,so off I trotted to my local music shop with a plan to sort this problem once and for all.The result was a bill for £65 and many various reeds to try,the outcome may surprise a few of the members it certainly surprised me.I have been considering to blogg the results of this exhaustive test,anybody interested let me know ad I'll have a go at putting it in black and white.....john

ps this will be purely from a novices point of view

I am always interested in what others have to say about reeds, both cane and synthetic.
 
I used synthetics 45 years ago (PTDs) as I am allergic to cane. Nearly gave up on my first lesson but luckily my teacher was a tester grader for PTD. 'Retired' for 30 years but on my 'comeback' used Bari * (similar look and box?) then moved on to Hahn. These last for months. I find some mouthpieces better than others for synths - Yamaha plastics, (old) Berg Larsen stainless and Beechler Bellite.
Saves the argument 'Is it me or the reed?'. 'Nah, mate - it's YOU!'
PS. Still got some 40 year old PTDs - yup, they still play.
 
After sanding to suit, I now use a small amount of Evo-stick resin W, weatherproof PVA adhesive, rubbed well into both sides of the reed, wiping of any excess. This seals the fibers, preventing the reed from getting soggy.
Using this method, I have even regenerated a couple of "played out" reeds!

John.
 
After sanding to suit, I now use a small amount of Evo-stick resin W, weatherproof PVA adhesive, rubbed well into both sides of the reed, wiping of any excess. This seals the fibers, preventing the reed from getting soggy.
Using this method, I have even regenerated a couple of "played out" reeds!

John.
presumably making them into an equivalent of rico plasticovers...?
 
"Happiness is a wet Rico reed." A quote from "Round Midnight" I think. Perhaps Mandy just got a bad batch of reeds. I use Rico Royals all the time and never have any trouble with them. However I had the same problem when I tried Rico Jazz Select. With those I found that changing up a strength made no difference.

Jim.
 
This is an ongoing experiment, it is far too early to make any claims, apart from preventing the reeds from becoming soggy. However, so far I have removed ripples from the tips of two reeds, and after two weeks of playing there is no sign of them coming back! but time will tell.

John.
 
To...Justin Chune... I suspect I might have had a bad one. At the time I posted the message, I swapped the duff one out for the next one in the pack, and I have just swapped that one out as I was beginning to squeek a bit, which seems like a much longer life. I got a Rico reed box (with humidifier thingy) as a Christmas present, so hopefully I can now get 3 reeds soaked, rubbed and ready to play in rotation. Expecting better life from the reeds.
 
To...Justin Chune... I suspect I might have had a bad one. At the time I posted the message, I swapped the duff one out for the next one in the pack, and I have just swapped that one out as I was beginning to squeek a bit, which seems like a much longer life. I got a Rico reed box (with humidifier thingy) as a Christmas present, so hopefully I can now get 3 reeds soaked, rubbed and ready to play in rotation. Expecting better life from the reeds.

Hi Mandy,

It's now a reasonable length of time for your trial. Have you found any improvement?

John.
 
Hi Mandy,

It's now a reasonable length of time for your trial. Have you found any improvement?

John.

Well, I have 4 reeds in my reed box. I play one each day, and cycle through them.
So far all 4 reeds are playing beautifully and I have not yet felt any need to discard any of them.
When the first one has to go, I'll work out how long they will have lasted. I would have expected (on past experience) 2-3 weeks per reed, so several more weeks to go yet, I think.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,551
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom