Playing the saxophone Reeds - no two are the same

Hi Pete

Is it possible to seal that part of the read with varnish or similar?

That's why I don't take reeds off between changes.
It sounds very unpleasant, but the gunk that gets under the reed will seal off any holes.

Well, I don't trust varnish or gunk to be as good as a flat reed.

I think of the ruler over the table analogy. To get a the right "boing" the part you hold down must be flat on the table.

with a reed, it is in two halves, the blade vibrates, but the heel (or shaft/shank, not sure of the right word), must be held firmly and not vibrate. You can easily tell the difference using the ruler/table analogy.

If the heel of the reed has a bulge, it could vibrate, sealing around the bulge with anything slightly liquid (varnish or gunk), won't necessarily help. It will create a seal yes, but that is all, it could still mean that part of the reed can vibrate.

This all gets into the argument about ligatures affecting the sound, warped mouthpiece tables etc.
 
I think of the ruler over the table analogy. To get a the right "boing" the part you hold down must be flat on the table.

You might be surprised...
Try the boing test with a bit of card placed in various positions under the ruler. You'll find that there's a point where as long as a certain amount of the ruler contacts the table, any more won't make a difference.

Regards,
 
Not that I believe this is an exact analogy, but I do find bits of card to affect the boing, especially when you compare with holding the heel down firmly all the way along to replicate a ligature.

But I also won't mind admitting my reeds sound better after a good scrape because I really want them to.
 
Natural reeds get 'gunky' very quickly in our warm climate (not right now, I haveta say!) ....I one on my JJDV for a bit too long and it removed some of the gold-plate 😱
(But Jody sent me a new one FOC 🙂 I have been very impressed by his customer service....not so much at his DV prices ! )
 
I like your expression 'martyr to reeds' (Steve Howard).
This says so much. Yes, they can be a pain but then there are so many variables it's easy to get too focused. A bit of time spent with a marginal reed can develop the ability to overcome the nuances of paying through the irregularities.
I find the biggest problem with reeds is that as I play more or less during a period of a few weeks I find myself moving up in reed strength to a 3 and then down to a 2 1/2 and then a 2 and then back up again. So I find myself clipping the ends to harden up and then start thinning them out to soften them - is this real or just my imagination?
I swear that the first car I ever had (a 1963 mini) used to go faster after I took the air filter off and put it back on again.
Steve
 
Had a lesson last night, changed my reed three times as they were all squeaky, yet days previous no problem. Then put on my plasticover. Sorted.
Re cars, i had a go faster stripe once and my present car goes much better once washed and vacuumed!! ;}
 
SteveK
Regarding your mini it would run better with the filter off because the air stream wasn't getting blocked by the filter, putting the filter back on was better than before it was removed because you'd dislodged the dirt blocking it.
I know far more about cars than I do about saxophones.
 
SteveK
Regarding your mini it would run better with the filter off because the air stream wasn't getting blocked by the filter, putting the filter back on was better than before it was removed because you'd dislodged the dirt blocking it.
I know far more about cars than I do about saxophones.
Point taken but it had the same effect when I emptied the ash trays.
Steve
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,204
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom