Reeds Reed waste

that is very interesting but looks bl..dy complicated especially if your eye sight isn't that good...john

The chart is more comprehensive than anybody usually uses. Buying the reeds that, when good, give you the sound you want, gets you most of the way there. The vast majority of the time the only work I end up doing to a reed is softening it up (reed rush on the sides surrounding the heart) or lateral balancing. Push gently against the tip and feel for more resistance on one side or the other, then scrape the tip a bit on the stiff side. Also flattening the back with a reed knife sometimes wants doing, as reeds swell and warp.
 
Hi guys,
Sorry to go banging on again, but as Morgan said, don't throw them away, work on them. I never throw a reed away without giving it a chance (usually successfully). I think a lot of the problems beginners have, could be avoided if they were shown how to adjust the reed to the mouthpiece being used. It isn't rocket science, and I think, should be regarded as one of the first basics in sax tuition!

johnboy.
 
Fair enough guys, but I still think that the range of brands exists because different cuts suit different players.
Mostly I can play every reed in a box, because I've found brands that suit me - what varies is how well they play, some are ok, some are great. The great ones I reserve for gigs, the others I use for practice or rehearsals.

If you're having trouble with Javas, try another brand. Once you've found a brand that suits, 9/10 will work and you won't need to 'convert' one cut of reed into another!

This is not the same as 'evening up' the balance of the reed if you're unlucky enough to get a badly cut one, that's a great idea. Long term though, I tend to take the easy way out, paying slightly more for a box with better quality assurance procedures.

Nick
 
I couldn't agree more!

I have just been breaking in a new box of Marca Jazz Alto 2.5's and all are excellent (+1, rather than 1 , - 1, or unclassified according to what I write on a reed) This cut works for me and my experience on soprano and tenor is the same - all excellent. Similarly with the Alexander DC's, Francois Excellence & Rico Jazz Selects reeds that I have used - spot on. Other cuts (Vandoren V16 & La Voz for example are much less likely to play well for me, however soft/hard. Hence it way well be the case that certain cuts are more likely to suit your emerging/established style of playing than others, and that some experimentation may be useful before settling on a reed that suits, quality issues aside.


Some people would describe the Marca reeds as too bright, for example. I primarily describe them as responsive, but neither dark nor bright. So it may all end up being quite subjective, influenced by the sound that we seek to create, and which reeds facilitate that, in addition to any issues of brand reliability, mouthpiece wonkiness, bad luck etc.

Kind regards
Tom😎
 
Rico Royals do it for me, as well, and I don't think that I have any waste to speak of. I hardly ever have to do even the least adjustment to them. There was this sax player who wished that his best pal was the guy that put the one good reed into every box of Vandoren. A couple of years ago Vandoren reeds were being faked in China. One worried sax player asked, on SOTW, how he could tell the difference? Easy, he was told, with the fakes you get two good ones in a box.

Jim.
 
Apart from a couple of loose ones that were so badly cut they were unplayable, all the reeds I've bought have been usable. They do vary, but not usually to the point where they can't be played. Mostly rico's for me, red box and royale.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,511
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom