Reeds Reed storage question

ESJohn

Senior Member
Messages
1,652
Location
Ohio USA
I'm quoting this from daddario.com:

"Can I store my reeds in the plastic reed holders that they came in?
Plastic reed holders protect the reeds before the box is opened by the purchaser, but they are designed to be used only for initial transport from factory to customer. It is always best to move the reeds to an air-tight reed storage system to protect the life of the reeds."

I've been storing my reeds in the original plastic holders (and inside a larger plastic case originally designed for holding chewing gum that holds ten reeds) ever since I began playing as an adult. I know the subject of reed storage has been discussed here before, but I'd like to hear the latest from the cafe. Do I need to upgrade my thoughts on this? It is getting annoying to have the empty holders laying around with nothing to do. Then again, I'm not a soloist or gig player so I don't go through reeds all that quickly and I'm not sure how much my sound would improve by taking the above advice.

How do you store your reeds and what benefit(s) do you feel you attain by that method?
 
... It is always best to move the reeds...
... to our own brand reed case, 30 quid + replacement humidity control sachets.

Anyway: looking forward to a few pages of "I do this" and "I do that" and no definitive conclusion, I suspect because it depends on your habits, habitat and needs.
 
For about six months I kept my reeds in their plastic cases all together in the plastic package my cleaning swab came in. Then one weekend while buying a new set of reeds I had GAS (always comes at the worst times) and bought a D'Addario reed case and now they're in there. I don't use the humidity pack.

I haven't noticed any difference between the old setup and the new one, but our climate here is relatively neutral and I suspect I could keep them all on something flat just about anywhere and they'd be fine.

Now that I've done my duty in helping fulfill mizmar's prediction, I'll leave you with this interesting thread from a few years ago Reeds - What's wrong with cardboard reed holders? - Cafesax
 
I like the cheaper D’Addario reed cases. The ones that come in colors. I prefer them to the air-tight holders, even without the humidity packs. Mold is a thing.

The plastic sleeves the reeds come in don’t do a good job of keeping them flat.

Actually, my favorite reed case is the old “Reed Wallet”. No longer available. I made one like it using a 3D printing service. Maybe I’ll buy myself a 3D printer for my birthday..


1709345821293.webp


1709345938268.webp
 
Santa brought me a small reed case that has a glass plate in it. Since moving over to that from just keeping reeds in the plastic sleeves it's at least felt like my reeds have lasted longer. I dont know if it's because the plate helps keep them in shape better, they also seem to dry out more slowly, or if just pure randomness of my latest box of reeds.

I've unscientifically convinced myself there's a difference, much like rotating reeds 🙂
 
As someone said above, we all tend to optimize our specific practices, often influenced by other decisions, or observing bandmates.
I'm a fan of contoured hardshell saxophone cases. One immediate consequence is the scarcity of storage volume, at least in the horn cases.
Each horn case has to be self-sufficient. It contains at least (the horn +) 1 mouthpiece with lig & cap, 1 strap, and 3-4 reeds, each in an individual Vandoren reed clip. Most contoured cases won't even accept any square reeds box.
As I play synthetic reeds, they last 6+ months, and just need to be wiped after playing.
All the remaining gear, like the stands, the iPad, spare ligatures, mouthpieces, reeds, straps, etc.. fits into an accessory bag, which has flashy colors, to decrease the risk to forget it somewhere.
As my bands/gigs can be single horn (usually tenor), but also tenor & baritone, or tenor & soprano, or any other combination, this organisation turned out to be the safest and most effective.
The small purse below fits snuggly in my tenor case, with 2 pieces and 4 reeds.
TenorAcc.jpg
 
I use a 4-reed case for my 'current reeds' that I've had forever. I lost the the 'humidifier' years ago. But since I give every current reed - along with the mpc table - a good moisturizer (lick) before playing, I'm not too worried about the lack of 'humidifier'. I soak new reeds - but also 'current reeds' in water form time to time. Just to make sure that they never get bone dry.

Keeping reeds in plastic reed cases wouldn't work for me at all. One of the things I really like about my reed case is that it 'dots' for each reed from 1 to 4. So my 'best current playable reed' is in slot 1, slot 2 is a good backup reed, slot 3 is so-so and slot 4 is 'if all else fails ..,'

I know (have read) that best practice is:
- play in and 'grade' reeds, noting which adjustments might improve tone and playability
- adjust reeds (or just chuck them) as necessary, adjusting the 'grading'
- rotate the reeds you play so that you always have a selection of reeds that sound good and play well

Many years back, I used to do this and I certainly found the benefits!

TBH, over the years I've just gotten lazy. As long as I have at least 2 reeds in slots 1 & 2 that are 'playable' and sound OK at rehearsals and occasional concerts, I'm generally happy. I still have slots & 4b as a backup.

Reeds wear out and I have an unfortunate habit of chipplng/cracking the 'thin end' of reeds. Just through playing. They're still (just) playable but not ideal. So my 'reed rotation' mostly consists of replacing damaged or worn reeds with new ones.

PS.
FWIW, I always dry my reeds and clean my mpc (and sax) at the end of each session. But in a series of 'jazz improvision workshops' I've played alongside a fellow tenor player who told me that he never takes his reed from his mpc. What amazed me was that he was using the same reed for 3 months or more. While I needed to change mine every 2-3 weeks, Go figure!
 
I don't make a distinction between reeds. I keep four or eight in a reed case and rotate them, one each day. I do adjust each reed, balancing it side to side, before it goes in the case, but otherwise just play one a day. Or maybe two if I'm doing a rehearsal, and a gig or two, but those days are long in the past for me.

I stopped breaking reeds in when I discovered it made no difference to how long they lasted or how well they played.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,523
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom