Reeds reed softness

Hi John

An old thread I know but I'm finding my reeds are getting too wet and I'm thinking to try your idea. I just wonder what glue you are using, is it just a PVA..


Thanks

Martin

Hi Martin,
Yes, waterproof PVA does the job, but I wound up using a glue for repairing plastic items.
I now use a Fibracell. It took a bit of getting used to but after rework, I found that I get a good strong sound and tone from it and of course it doesn't absorb moisture!

John 🙂;}
 
A reed that gets waterlogged will be slower to respond due to the increase in mass,

Not heard that one before. So harder reeds are slower than softer ones too I suppose. And you can actually tell the difference in response times?

Just bright and playable reeds becoming dull and lifeless over the course of a gig, then feeling dead for two days before brightening up again.. (the reed, LOL)

This isn't just one reed, its everyone I use and they are only a few days out of the box too.

I'm inclined to think that you're playing on the wrong strength reeds then. They're in your mouth - they're going to get wet. You need to take that into account when you're testing them.
 
Not heard that one before. So harder reeds are slower than softer ones too I suppose. And you can actually tell the difference in response times?



I'm inclined to think that you're playing on the wrong strength reeds then. They're in your mouth - they're going to get wet. You need to take that into account when you're testing them.

I have a case stuffed with reeds of various strengths and some different brands and always seem to be getting the same result, if it were "wrong strength" then why would a reed remain dull for a day or two before becoming playable again, it has to be that it's drying out.
I have harder reeds, I'll give it a try.
 
Not heard that one before. So harder reeds are slower than softer ones too I suppose. And you can actually tell the difference in response times?

.

The slower response time would show up in the timbre and volumer. My guess is that the mass of a reed increases by about half. Given that the poor little reed is trying to flap both the longitudinall and transverse axes it's going to notice that. After all how fast and how high would you jump with a 75 lb bag of cement in your arms lol.
 
The theory is that increasing the stiffness of a reed will increase it's natural rate of vibration, while making the tip heavier will slow it down. As the reed gets wet, it softens and the tip gets heavier. So it's natrual rate of vibration goes down. similar to tongue drums and other objects with one free end which vibrates. And as we know from note bending, the reed vibration affects the tone and pitch of the sax.
 
Hi Martin,
Yes, waterproof PVA does the job, but I wound up using a glue for repairing plastic items.
I now use a Fibracell. It took a bit of getting used to but after rework, I found that I get a good strong sound and tone from it and of course it doesn't absorb moisture!

John 🙂;}

I might try the old DIY trick of massively diluting PVA to make it soak in as you do for sealing new plaster. Its an idea...

I hate fibracells, never got to like them on the Alto. I've had great results with the legere on the Alto but cant get on with it on the Tenor, yet... more perseverance maybe.

Thanks John :welldone
 
Over the past few weeks I have been studying Ray Reeds -The Saxophone Reed . The Advanced Art of Adjusting Reeds... 170 plus pages of reed geeking including dealing with the natural warping of reeds, measuring with a dial gauge, making corrections etc etc. not recommended for anyone but the most fanatic about their reeds ROFL but I am finding a really significant difference in my reeds already and I am still in the learning experimenting stage. How many strokes of a ReedGeek to remove .001 inch and how to blend that into a 3mm x 3 mm area etc etc. I was fortunate and purely by luck early on to get one to REALLY SING so am motivated to wade through it. His writing style is quite pedantic but the amount of knowledge is phenomenal. The distilled wisdom from 30 plus years of obsessing on reeds, by a good player.
 
The increasing mass of the gradually wetting reed would also affect the attack and decay times.

Obvious answer, half an hour with a hot hair dryer in your mouth before playing.

:thumb:

That should work very well for them that require dry reeds.

I, of course, take the opposite view. If it's going to get wet in my mouth anyway, then I make sure both the reed and myself are as soaked as possible before playing.
 
My teacher recommends Yamaha Student Lipstick, which comes with a specially designed applicator. When I've go the hang of putting it on I can move up to Yamaha 62 pro lipstick, which is quicker to respond to application, using the technique of my choice........................🙂
 
My teacher recommends Yamaha Student Lipstick, which comes with a specially designed applicator. When I've go the hang of putting it on I can move up to Yamaha 62 pro lipstick, which is quicker to respond to application, using the technique of my choice........................🙂

Is that the shade often referred to as "cork grease" Tom? 🙂
 
My teacher recommends Yamaha Student Lipstick, which comes with a specially designed applicator. When I've go the hang of putting it on I can move up to Yamaha 62 pro lipstick, which is quicker to respond to application, using the technique of my choice........................🙂

Have you thought of using lip preparation, id est, balancing the lips laterally and in depth.

The CaSLM is bringing out a Lip Modification Kit, containing, anti-sceptic wipes, small angle grinder, various finishing sand papers, plasters and a disinfected small stapler.

Advance orders accepted.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,686
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom