Reeds Reed query

I haven't discarded a reed because it's 'bad' in probably 20 years. I don't do trimming/scraping either. Play them straight out of the box. YMMV.
Edit: Actually I don't recall ever discarding a reed straight out of the box. But then I've only been playing 52 years. Some of the more experienced among you may have come across some duff ones.
We’re all different. My buddy and I (ex-Royal Phil, Royal Liverpool clarinet) both found regular blue box Vandoren clarinet reeds to be inconsistent in the early 2000’s (when we were both playing clarinet seriously) and the V12’s were much better for both of us.
 
When I was a young kid, just starting out, my school music teacher told my parents that I would benefit from private lessons. She and my folks sent me to Jim Russell, may he rest in peace. He taught me many things, but two which stand out to this day were -

1) being brave enough to take my clarinet apart with a screwdriver. I now do most of my own repair and maintenance work on my instruments.

2) how to work on reeds. He used reed rush, I now use 400 grit sandpaper, but I play all but the most horribly deformed reeds.

Many people look on reed adjustment as some sort of dark art, but in reality it’s quite simple. You just have to play well enough to be able to tell what a good reed is like, and be willing to experiment. Yes you will ruin reeds. A couple boxes of ruined reeds is a small price to pay for a lifetime of not having to worry about reeds at all.
 
When I was 10 (the one year I played an instrument till I was 56) , my clarinet teacher would scrape and faf with reeds ... taught me f'all apparat, in retrospect, how to butcher reeds. Thank god for u tube.
 
When I was a young kid, just starting out, my school music teacher told my parents that I would benefit from private lessons. She and my folks sent me to Jim Russell, may he rest in peace. He taught me many things, but two which stand out to this day were -

1) being brave enough to take my clarinet apart with a screwdriver. I now do most of my own repair and maintenance work on my instruments.

2) how to work on reeds. He used reed rush, I now use 400 grit sandpaper, but I play all but the most horribly deformed reeds.

Many people look on reed adjustment as some sort of dark art, but in reality it’s quite simple. You just have to play well enough to be able to tell what a good reed is like, and be willing to experiment. Yes you will ruin reeds. A couple boxes of ruined reeds is a small price to pay for a lifetime of not having to worry about reeds at all.
+1. My clarinet prof did the same for me. It also involved using the college windows as a flat surface too. I wonder if the cleaners ever knew what the marks were…
 
+1. My clarinet prof did the same for me. It also involved using the college windows as a flat surface too. I wonder if the cleaners ever knew what the marks were…
Jim worked a deal with a local window shop, which was on the same block as the local music store (Forrest’s in Berkeley, CA - they are still in busines, primarily dealing in oboes now). He had them take the offcuts from 1/4” plate glass windows, and make small plaques (1” x 3”) and bevel the edges. He sent all his students there to buy them. Every clarinet playing kid in Berkeley had one of these small pieces of plate glass in their case.

Recently I tried to get a similar set of plaques made, and the window shop said they don’t have any offcuts. Windows are now all made to specific sizes, which they buy from factories, and so I would have to pay for an entire pane. I declined.

My solution was to search Amazon, and found that the ubiquitous Asian manufacturers have cornered the market on small glass plaques - they sell them as pallettes to manicurists, who use them to mix acrylic nail goop. You can get similar small slabs from dental suppliers at 10 times the cost. I suspect they come from the same factory…
 
Jim worked a deal with a local window shop, which was on the same block as the local music store (Forrest’s in Berkeley, CA - they are still in busines, primarily dealing in oboes now). He had them take the offcuts from 1/4” plate glass windows, and make small plaques (1” x 3”) and bevel the edges. He sent all his students there to buy them. Every clarinet playing kid in Berkeley had one of these small pieces of plate glass in their case.

Recently I tried to get a similar set of plaques made, and the window shop said they don’t have any offcuts. Windows are now all made to specific sizes, which they buy from factories, and so I would have to pay for an entire pane. I declined.

My solution was to search Amazon, and found that the ubiquitous Asian manufacturers have cornered the market on small glass plaques - they sell them as pallettes to manicurists, who use them to mix acrylic nail goop. You can get similar small slabs from dental suppliers at 10 times the cost. I suspect they come from the same factory…
I have (had?) one also - but windows are easier 😇
 
An interesting thing about people/reeds:

In Brecker’s biography there’s a story about Brecker being late for a studio date and his band took guesses about the reasons. I can’t remember all the details but one guess was that he couldn’t find a reed. I think there were four guesses, and all were correct.

My point is that we are all different and even with his ability he was scratching around for a reed.

There are good articles and booklets on Reed “Doctoring” as it was often referred to. By Paul Harvey I think. Whilst being relevant still, it is maybe 50+ years old. The Reed Geek is a great bit of kit and is much smaller than most other tools, save a small square of wet n dry paper as mentioned above.

It’s a good thing to get into, as many a reed will just need the back flattening and the Reed Geek is particularly good at this, as is wet n dry and toughened glass - or the proverbial window…

Disclaimer: do not use wonky hand-blown windows
 
You use it as the flat surface when working on the top part
OK, but Mr.Pedantic is concerned that this is working on the top part, as opposed to flattening the reed which implies you are working on the bottom part, ie flattening the part that goes against the mouthpiece table.
 
OK, but Mr.Pedantic is concerned that this is working on the top part, as opposed to flattening the reed which implies you are working on the bottom part, ie flattening the part that goes against the mouthpiece table.
Yes I clocked mr Pedant 🙄
 
Jim worked a deal with a local window shop, which was on the same block as the local music store (Forrest’s in Berkeley, CA - they are still in busines, primarily dealing in oboes now). He had them take the offcuts from 1/4” plate glass windows, and make small plaques (1” x 3”) and bevel the edges. He sent all his students there to buy them. Every clarinet playing kid in Berkeley had one of these small pieces of plate glass in their case.

Recently I tried to get a similar set of plaques made, and the window shop said they don’t have any offcuts. Windows are now all made to specific sizes, which they buy from factories, and so I would have to pay for an entire pane. I declined.

My solution was to search Amazon, and found that the ubiquitous Asian manufacturers have cornered the market on small glass plaques - they sell them as pallettes to manicurists, who use them to mix acrylic nail goop. You can get similar small slabs from dental suppliers at 10 times the cost. I suspect they come from the same factory…
You can buy welders visor glass quite cheap from many places (including amazon), it's toughened and flat, as long as you don't want to see through it, although, I use it for sun gazing and putting over the camera lens to take pictures of the sun. Just a thought.
 
I worked in a music shop back in the 70's. All reeds landed on a light table before they were sold. If a player wanted to buy 25 Rico we had to open 2 boxes because 3-5 reeds were not good enough to sell. We got new reeds from the wholesaler. I bought the bad reeds (for less money) and started to learn how to make reeds playable/ to play better. When I had some reeds ready I went to the clarinet and sax teachers at the public music school so they could give the student new reeds. And when the students/parents was going to buy new sax, reeds ..... they came to us.

Here is the tools that I use(d): Wet stones, plexiglas, razor blade, reed trimmers, sand paper. Very basic tools.

I have lots of reeds waiting to be cured! 1,5 Rico soprano reeds!! After reed treatment they becomes softer!


IMG_4897.JPG
 
Last edited:
A light table sounds nice. When I used to buy reeds singly, the store almost always had an open box, and most guys just held them up to the window, or the shop’s light if it was night time.

I have since discovered that holding a reed up to the light doesn’t tell you much. Only grossly deformed reeds need to be discarded, and you don’t need a light source for that. If a reed is cut well, and the blank was reasonably even, the reed can be made to play well.

That picture takes me back, Rico Brown Box for the win! To be fair, you could usually count on 2-4 out of 25 reeds being grossly deformed…. but the rest, now those were great reeds! Of course, for me a 3 1/2 is more appropriate…
 
A light table sounds nice. When I used to buy reeds singly, the store almost always had an open box, and most guys just held them up to the window, or the shop’s light if it was night time.

I have since discovered that holding a reed up to the light doesn’t tell you much. Only grossly deformed reeds need to be discarded, and you don’t need a light source for that. If a reed is cut well, and the blank was reasonably even, the reed can be made to play well.

That picture takes me back, Rico Brown Box for the win! To be fair, you could usually count on 2-4 out of 25 reeds being grossly deformed…. but the rest, now those were great reeds! Of course, for me a 3 1/2 is more appropriate…

The light table was built in to the desk so it was easy to use. We also looked for deformed reeds. But that's was what we could. Of course, I could test play them .....😉
 
Welders glass, as stated, works.
A piece of marble, used for countertops, works as well.
A cabinet shop usually has some leftovers.
If playing in a bar/pub with pool tables and heavy drinkers, if you were negligent about your reed chores, just cut a flap of felt and use the slate. Fold the felt back down, put the rack and balls back, leave cue stick on top, and walk away quickly. :rolleyes:

Just another reason why flutes are greater than horns. :clapping:
 
Last edited:
Just thinking out loud but, through all our saxophone journeys we have probably amassed a few mouthpieces that have been put to the side in favour of others, I recently, (since reading this post), dug out some old reads and old MPs and have found that the old Yamaha 4 is great with a box of Rico 3.5's where, with my Otto 8 I can feel the veins popping on my head when I get above the octave, but is perfect with the Java reds 2.5's (which is my reed of choice (at the moment anyway)).

I have also found that a simple reed trimmer one of the wife's old emery boards buys me a couple more weeks on a good reed. I'm not good enough to pick out some of the tiny differences that a lot of you guys can and in the end, I just want to be able to pick it up and play, we are our worse own critics.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,503
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom