PiccoloPirate
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,205
- Location
- South Florida
^^^^
Wet or dry?
Wet or dry?
That’s very informative, thank you for your reply 🙂I have had a reed geek for a while now and I think that they are not as reliable in the process of flattening the back of a reed as the manufacturer would have us belive. As a tool to smooth the back of a reed fresh out of the box, I think they are fine. But to remove the convex-ity that occurs as a new reed swells, I have serious doubts that they are effective and this is why:
If the back of the reed is not flat, i.e. humped or convex, there is no guarantee that swiping the reed geek up and down the reed is actually going to flatten the reed because it is impossible to guarantee that the geek is travelling absolutely parallel to the reed. In fact it is entirely likely that the geek will make matters worse because it might just as easily increase the hump as remove it as your hand rocks slightly with each pass.
I have a good amount of experience at scraping reeds because I was an oboist at Music College and for quite a few years thereafter, always making my own reeds. Although the construction of an oboe reed is entirely different to a sax or clarinet reed, the basic tenents of blade usage remain constant - it has to be controlled accurately.
As ever, YMMV. Although I wholeheartedly agree that a single reed works better with a flat back, I don't believe that attempting to flatten one with a reed geek is necessarily the answer.
