Reeds Reed comparison video for tenor

mrblackbat

Opinionated grumpy northerner
Messages
1,301
Location
United Kingdom
I put together a bit of a comparison video of various reeds today as a Forestone Black Bamboo MH landed.

The reeds, not necessarily in the order in the video are:-

Boston Sax Shop Black 3
Boston Sax Shop Silver 3
Forestone Black Bamboo MH
Gonzalez Jazz Local 627 3
Legere American Cut 2.75
Marca American Vintage 3
Rico Jazz Select Filed 3M
Rigotti Gold Jazz (Blue box) 3L
Rigotti Gold Jazz (Blue box) 3M
Vandoren Java Red 3

Curious to see which you like best, which you think is which (PM me if you like). I'll post a video with my thoughts on each and the order later.

View: https://youtu.be/pq-F6TwybZ0
 
Same tune, but played differently with some including low notes and some not. Same with some using top of the horn and some not. What I got was your ease of play and enjoyment of # 5 and #7. We tend to sound like ourselves on any gear and from there it's a matter of what suits you, the mouthpiece and to a lesser extent your horn. We know that reeds vary a lot and preferences are a personal thing.

Experienced players (like you) can usually make most gear work as we adjust to reeds that are too hard, too soft, have harsh or mushy tendencies, etc. So once again it comes down to the player's preference, their tonal concept and which reeds best suits all those factors.

Very Interesting giving us this comparison, but (for me) it would have been more interesting to know initially which reeds were which as there are lots of examples here. Would I go back to listen more carefully once knowing which ones are which?
 
Same tune, but played differently with some including low notes and some not. Same with some using top of the horn and some not. What I got was your ease of play and enjoyment of # 5 and #7. We tend to sound like ourselves on any gear and from there it's a matter of what suits you, the mouthpiece and to a lesser extent your horn. We know that reeds vary a lot and preferences are a personal thing.

Experienced players (like you) can usually make most gear work as we adjust to reeds that are too hard, too soft, have harsh or mushy tendencies, etc. So once again it comes down to the player's preference, their tonal concept and which reeds best suits all those factors.

Very Interesting giving us this comparison, but (for me) it would have been more interesting to know initially which reeds were which as there are lots of examples here. Would I go back to listen more carefully once knowing which ones are which?
I have a follow up video with my thoughts immediately after the takes, and will include the list of reeds too there. But I thought it interesting not to share initially to see what people thought without the likelihood of bias.

And yes played differently unfortuately and the last portion of each take will give an idea of level of comfort, I think. There are two reeds hat there are definitely harder than I’d like.

I can share the reed order with you via PM if you like?
 
Yes please. Also noted you've shared this on SOTW.
Tried sending a PM but your inbox is full! 😄

I'm sorry but they all sounded more or less equal to me. It will be interesting to know what you thought.
That's interesting of itself; there are definitely clear differences from behind the horn while playing and I do hear those on recording. But they aren't as pronounced on record. I'll be popping up a "thoughts" video with the order in a few days.
 
That's interesting of itself; there are definitely clear differences from behind the horn while playing and I do hear those on recording
I'm tempted to convert your video into several MP3 files, label them randomly but record secretly which is in which sequence on the video, and see if you can identify which is which...
Ideally in a little which when you've forgotten details of the session.
I'm not being snarky or such. Genuine curiosity.
 
Tried sending a PM but your inbox is full! 😄


That's interesting of itself; there are definitely clear differences from behind the horn while playing and I do hear those on recording. But they aren't as pronounced on record. I'll be popping up a "thoughts" video with the order in a few days.
Very sorry about that. I forgot about it being "full" and have had difficulty in trying to purge the PMs, without having any success. Do you know the trick? I'd looked at the site's advice and there's nothing that seems to give a step by step method. I'd had this trouble before and I think the moderators did it for me (some time ago, so I don't remember).

Thanks for trying!
 
I'm tempted to convert your video into several MP3 files, label them randomly but record secretly which is in which sequence on the video, and see if you can identify which is which...
Ideally in a little which when you've forgotten details of the session.
I'm not being snarky or such. Genuine curiosity.
Do it! Though I can just send you the individual files....

I think there are some that are close and so I might not identify exactly which was the 3L and 3M Rigotti for example; and the two synths I might get the wrong way round. But some others that I think I'd definitely get right.
 
OK.
I've shared a folder with MrBlackBat...
Ive taken each of his MP3s.
- delted the first phrase
- delted after about 4 phrases - he went off in all sorts of directions, possibly inspired in different ways by the different reeds
- renormalised everything to the same level.
- saved with random, 5 character file names.

so, there's no distortion, but some unfamiliarity.

- the key file is also there, but locked (so, kinda, escrow)
- there's a spreadsheet with just the file names ... And no edit history! See how easy it is the leak information
 
Last edited:
I had another listen and this time I listened harder. There are differences but they seemed to fall more or less into two camps where one had more edge and the others were warmer. I preferred the first one.
 
Three and nine were my favourites. Not too edgy, not too stuffy. Seven was my least favourite, it sounded like a wasp in a jam jar to me. Thanks for the comparison.
 
OK.
I've shared a folder with MrBlackBat...
Ive taken each of his MP3s.
- delted the first phrase
- delted after about 4 phrases - he went off in all sorts of directions, possibly inspired in different ways by the different reeds
- renormalised everything to the same level.
- saved with random, 5 character file names.

so, there's no distortion, but some unfamiliarity.

- the key file is also there, but locked (so, kinda, escrow)
- there's a spreadsheet with just the file names ... And no edit history! See how easy it is the leak information
Popped my answers in; one had been dropped off so I’m assuming that’s one of the rigotti golds.
 
guesstruth
UUZJKBSS blackBSS Black 3
AVORGBSS silverBSS Silver 3
GJDWDforestone black bambooForestone Black Bamboo MH
RFOJZGonzalezGonzalez Jazz Local 627 3
YVRSCRico Jazz SelectMarca American Vintage 3
TFHRRMarca AVRico Jazz Select Filed 3M
DURVHlegere ACRigotti Gold Jazz 3L
PDGYWRigotti GoldRigotti Gold Jazz 3M
OHNZAVandoren RedVandoren Java Red 3
 
I agree on the Gonzales sounding the best. The BSS and Marca sound dull and the Forestone is all over. The Rico sounds good, too, and I don't like the the Legere. On a side note, I had a box of 5 of American vintage and two of them had a chip at one side of the tip.
If you have a chance, try the Marca Superieure and the Vandoren ZZ (currently my favorite)
The Vandoren Dead....
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,066
Messages
578,479
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom