Saxophone beginners Reaching Low B flat on pinky table

Mwyatt

Member
Messages
7
Location
Saskatchewan Regina
Good evening everyone.

I had a quick question in regards to maybe getting a few ideas on modifying the pinky table or tricks to reach the low b flat key on the pinky table.

I've medium sized man hands the issue is that due to slicing a few tendons in my hand over the years I can't actually seperate my fingers to the point I can reach the b flat key consistently or fast.

I can go early barely reach the inside corner of the key let alone the center of it. I play a Yamaha 62iii so I don't think ergonomics are so much of a issue. More the prior damage to my hands.

I can post photos in a bit if it helps to better explain. Honestly I don't mind if it's something that isn't correctable as I have no illusions of being a gigging musician lol thank you all for your time
 
Solution
You could try deepening and extending the Bb key touch with Sugru [edit]. Here's what I have done on my bari:

IMG_0188.jpg
Soprano, alto, tenor or bari?

If it were me, I'd just play Bb up an octave. It's pretty rare that I have to play low Bb anyway.
I apologize for not mentioning it. The instrument is a tenor. I actually had my wife strap the instrument on and asked if she could reach the key. No issues lol so it's definitely a finger flexibility issue.

Knowing its a problem I've just ignored playing it even for scale work ect.

Thanks for the advice on just playing the octave up.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Yes there are a number of things you or a horn technician can do. On the web there is a video of a horn heavily modified for a one handed sax player. I only mention it to assure you that your problem is very solvable in scale with what is possible. Best of luck.
 
Vote:
Upvote 1
If we assume, and I think most respondents are assuming, that your table is a contemporary keywork table, then another option might be to have a tech look at whether they can extend the Bb touch to the 'left' (player's view) of the B touch, much like an old-school traditional Bb touch used to be (the touchpiece exists both below the B and C# touch, and to the left of the b touch).

It might be able to be done, depends on what the B armature and the G# mechanism is doing.
'Cratdeco2.jpg
 
Vote:
Upvote 1
If we assume, and I think most respondents are assuming, that your table is a contemporary keywork table, then another option might be to have a tech look at whether they can extend the Bb touch to the 'left' (player's view) of the B touch, much like an old-school traditional Bb touch used to be (the touchpiece exists both below the B and C# touch, and to the left of the b touch).
He's got a 62.
I play a Yamaha 62iii so I don't think ergonomics are so much of a issue. More the prior damage to my hands.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
If it was me (which it might be one day) I would get it customised because low Bb is the best note there is.

You have a good top class horn, so it is worth paying that little bit extra for a decent tech to make it work for you. Extending the Bb is the simplest and may work, but could add extra heaviness due to the extra leverage, and that is probably the last thing you want with your finger the way it is.

Thinking a bit out of the box, what I would do is get a tech to make a a lever that is operated by your left thumb, just like a low A in baritone, except it works the low Bb.

No strain on your poor pinky, and uses a tried and tested fingering (ar rather thumbing) method with a previously unused digit that will allow you a technique with no compromise.

It may cost up to a $200 but possibly less depending on what good techs charge in your neck of the woods, and is worth it IMO on a horn as good as a 62.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Thinking a little more about this, I'm wondering if you're playing lh stack with fingertips on the pearls.
There's no need to do this. I've heard it called finger overshoot. I'm playing G with the first nuckle of my ring finger on the pearl. Not such a stretch with the little finger to the table.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I want to say thank you to everyone who replied.

Balanced reaction: I had actually watched that video to try and figure out what my issue is. I really love Mr.Andersons content.

Nigeld: In my limited experience I'd never actually seen that done and will be something I'm going to look into.

Colin the bear: I'm going to attempt to either adjust my hand positioning as you indicated, failing that I'll move next to the drop the elbow. As these are both posture/ positioning and easy to try before commiting to a more expensive solution.

Pete Thomas: thank you so much for that idea and I'll be in contact with a tech out here to see what the cost of that would be. Especially since that would be a more long term permanent fix. Even more so if the problem with my hands worsens as I get older.

I genuinely can't thank you all enough for your responses.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,703
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom