Teaching Pythagorean tuning and the circle of 5ths

Is this why we bend notes? Adjusting the harmony and looking for the sweet spot.

It used to confuse me that I could tune a guitar in an open tuning but was never satisfied and always fiddling with standard tuning... and the first fret less bass I heard sounded so sweet.

Some of the maths is too much for my poor head. Respect to those that not only understand it but can dumb it down to my level.
When playing in an ensemble without a fixed pitch instrument, a simple rule of thumb is when you have the 3rd of a major chord lip it down, and when you have the 3rd of a minor chord lip it up. If you have the 7th of a dominant seventh chord lip it down.
 
When playing in an ensemble without a fixed pitch instrument, a simple rule of thumb is when you have the 3rd of a major chord lip it down, and when you have the 3rd of a minor chord lip it up. If you have the 7th of a dominant seventh chord lip it down.

Interesting comments John. Ones Ive not heard before.

For me, Im more interested in trying to adjust to fit in, or to make it sound more in tune, than I am concerned with anything else. Which note of a chord Im playing is way down my list of concerns.

If it doesnt sound right harmonically, I may ask to come back to it later, to check. But in the heat of the moment, Im simply trying to make the communal sound be better in tune.
 
Thanks Nigeld. I am going to have to study that to get my head around logarithms. I am finding it difficult to understand why dividing the number of hz difference between two notes a half step apart by 100 doesn't give a cents to hz relationship that is closer to your figures.

400Hz to 800Hz is an octave or 1200 cents with 400Hz difference.
800Hz to 1600Hz is also an octave and also 1200 cents but 800Hz difference.

There are fewer cents to the Hertz the higher you go.
 
When playing in an ensemble without a fixed pitch instrument, a simple rule of thumb is when you have the 3rd of a major chord lip it down, and when you have the 3rd of a minor chord lip it up. If you have the 7th of a dominant seventh chord lip it down.

I'm not sure I agree with you about the 7th.
 
This comes from years of playing. The 7th has a strong pull to resolve downwards to the 3rd of the chord that follows. It always sounds better to my ear when it is slightly lowered. As any barbershop singer, they will tell you the same thing.

"Slightly", I might agree with, but that's not what barbershop singers do.

It depends whether you think the seventh in a dominant chord represents a 7/4 ratio with the root (7th harmonic) or 16/9 (up two perfect 4ths). The barbershop guys go for the 7/4 which is way, way flat of ET (31 cents I think). 16/9 is only 4 cents below ET which is so small I wouldn't think it needed conscious adjustment.

The dominant 7th chord with a 7/4 seventh is much more stable than with 16/9. It doesn't have the same feeling of wanting to resolve, which is why barbershop quartets and blues singers can use it on a tonic chord. I believe this is because all the notes come from the harmonic series. They are all overtones of the root.

In the 16/9 dominant seventh the third and 5th come from the harmonic series but the 7th comes from an inverted harmonic series. i.e. down 2 perfect 5ths from the root or just down a 5th from the tonic). It has what WA Matheiu calls reciprocal energy and Harry Partch calls utonallity. I believe that this mixture of overtone and "undertone" is what causes the instability of the dominant seventh. It's feels like you've gone in two opposite directions at once and you're being pulled back to the centre.
 
Dibbs You are moving into areas that I am not familiar with (again). My understanding of the tension of the dominant 7th chord is that it contains a "tritone". The 7th wants to resolve down 1/2 step to the 3rd of the tonic chord, and the 3rd of the dominant 7th chord wants to resolve up 1/2 step to the tonic.
 
Dibbs You are moving into areas that I am not familiar with (again). My understanding of the tension of the dominant 7th chord is that it contains a "tritone". The 7th wants to resolve down 1/2 step to the 3rd of the tonic chord, and the 3rd of the dominant 7th chord wants to resolve up 1/2 step to the tonic.

Yes. That's another way of looking at it.

The harmonic 7th isn't really a tritone at all. It's approx. 2 2/3 tones.

So often in music there is more than one way of looking at something and coming to a similar conclusion. The jazz musician's tritone substitution is the classical musician's augmented sixth chord, for example.
 
Yes. That's another way of looking at it.

The harmonic 7th isn't really a tritone at all. It's approx. 2 2/3 tones.

So often in music there is more than one way of looking at something and coming to a similar conclusion. The jazz musician's tritone substitution is the classical musician's augmented sixth chord, for example.

Ok, now you've lost me. The interval C to F# is a "tritone", it consists of 3 whole steps (6 half steps). It is in the center of the octave from C1 to C2---6 half steps away from each. In the key of G, the D7 dominant 7th chord contains the 7th (C) and the 3rd (F#). Together those two notes form a "tritone" which gives the dominant 7th chord its unstable sound seeking a resolution.
 
Ok, now you've lost me. The interval C to F# is a "tritone", it consists of 3 whole steps (6 half steps). It is in the center of the octave from C1 to C2---6 half steps away from each. In the key of G, the D7 dominant 7th chord contains the 7th (C) and the 3rd (F#). Together those two notes form a "tritone" which gives the dominant 7th chord its unstable sound seeking a resolution.

The harmonic 7th isn't part of that system.

See here. Harmonic seventh chord - Wikipedia

That article suggests 9/5 as a just minor seventh. That's up 2 fifths and down a major 3rd and is actually sharp relative to ET.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,056
Messages
578,186
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom