I play tenor and I have 2 wind synth, Roland AE10 and Yamaha YDS120. First off, the AE10 keys are not like a sax. The YDS120 looks very similar, but I don't think it would be a very good tool to replace an acoustic sax. There is always a millisecond delay with the sound and key press. With the app one can program the delay and make it more like one's own playing, but still it couldn't replicate the nuances of tone changes with how one blows. It would be very difficult for manufacturers to replicate the force and resistance of actual keys. I couldn't make them as effective practicing tools. I see my two as different instruments. I think there is one "half sax" synth without the bell on the market. I believe it is a good instrument. Yet I feel like it is a waste if only use as a practicing tool.