Possibly a stupid question!

simonmcg

Member
Messages
20
Hi guys and girls,

Although I'm sure this is a bit of a silly question I'll ask it any way in the hope someone can help me out.

I have bought a BG ligature (sort of leather ring with single screw to close it on the reed). I've been attaching it with the screw at the top of the mouthpiece (reed held by leather ring). When I went to my first lesson my tutor said he thought it should be the other way around but wasn't entirely sure.

The strange thing is it seems to work either way!
 
No the screw should be at the top "in sight". The BG and some Rovners have a rail insert to hold the reed. in place and apply a vertical load through the reed perpendicular to the table.

I hope that's clear. Maybe try it the other way round to see what happens?

Simon
 
Usually ligatures are designed so the the screw is on the right hand side. This is how you can tell which way upi it's meant to be.

Unfair for lefties, about time someone brought out a left handed ligature.
 
thanks guys, it would seem that I have been playing it correctly which is a relief. As always the speed of replies on this forum staggers me.

In answer to your question you'll be very pleased to know I don't combine my job with my hobby, which is probably just as well!
 
The lig that came with my alto is the usual two screw metal job and it holds a reed nice and snuggly on the original mp and I can tootle away all day with barely an unwanted squeak. But a while back I got a Yam 6C and more or less given up on it because it squeaks like crazy. This post prompted me to look further into what was going wrong and it transpires the external diameter of the Yam is slightly less than that of the original mp ... which means the one lig I have (until I can get another one) doesn't hold a reed end firmly on the table even with the two screws wound right in. Last night I fished out the Yam and fixed a reed on it by tightly winding three elastic bands around it instead of using the conventional lig. Bingo ... plays like a dream and completely squeak free. The important bit seems that holding the reed very firmly, all along its tail length (however its done) matters most. I'll go shopping for a properly fitting lig for the Yam when I can spare the time ... I live in the sticks and most of the decent music shops are in the cities where parking is a pain and a whole day can easily disappear on those excursions!
 
SimonMcG wrote:
Hi guys and girls,

Although I'm sure this is a bit of a silly question I'll ask it any way in the hope someone can help me out.

I have bought a BG ligature (sort of leather ring with single screw to close it on the reed). I've been attaching it with the screw at the top of the mouthpiece (reed held by leather ring). When I went to my first lesson my tutor said he thought it should be the other way around but wasn't entirely sure.

The strange thing is it seems to work either way!

I use a Rover lig on both tenor and soprano. I have found that is doesn't matter which way up you use it as the differences in sound are miniscule and could depend on not only which way up the lig is but also how tight it is, how far up the reed it is, whether it is angled or flat against the reed and what side of the bed you got out of this morning; if it sounds OK then it's OK.

Cheers

Moz
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom