Mouthpieces Pop Test - How long should it last until the pop?

I can do the pop test. I can't use a standard 2-screw ligature. I don't care if the the reed is not 100% flat the table is just 11 mm long ...... and it's playable.
1748587702869.webp
 
The springiness of the reed, the tip opening, and the length of the lay are all factors that effect a mouthpiece's ability to "pop".
It’s probably fair to say that the harder a reed the less likely it is to fail a pop test. So maybe after all, the test does have a use, letting you know when you have a hard reed.
No SYOS mouthpiece passes the pop test but play amazingly???

Syos have said:

Syos mouthpieces don't seal because of the roughness of the material we use. But as you can observe, they play well and are free blowing.
 
So now I had to test out my DV HR which has a similar cut out in the table. It went ‘pop’. A satisfying way to start the day.
Yes I take it back. The more I think about it, the more it seems those mouthpieces with a cut out window on the table are more likely to pass a pop test.
 
I like the pop test. In my view it is a check of the geometry of the mouthpiece when done with a proven reed, synthetic being the more reliable I guess. It's obviously not an indication of how well a mouthpiece plays. Just how the reed seals to it.

Syos mouthpieces clearly don't pass the pop test out of the box. I have a few of them and I worked on them so they do. You may not believe it has anything to do with it but I'm convinced they played better after I 'fixed' them. Especially the soprano pièces. 3 of them!
 
What does the pop test do/show/prove?

And what is it?
Does nothing, shows nothing. Well accepted to reject good parts and accept bad parts. And yet there are those who cling to it as an article of faith, that it somehow tells them SOMETHING, except of course they ignore it when their actual experience contradicts the results of the test.

So I guess you could say that if you have already decided to accept or reject a mouthpiece or reed, you can use the results of the pop test to justify your choice, IF the results agree with you. And if they don't, you ignore tham.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,325
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom