[Poll] Padsavers, yay or nay

Thomsax wrote:
Does an ordinary swab really take care of moisture?? You pull the swab through your sax a couple of times and it takes just a few seconds!! I think it just help to get the moisture out all over the tube so it will dry faster?

When you played get rid of the moisture with paper, swab and a Pad Saver. A swab doesn't dry the toneholes. The pads should also be dry up after playing. This is important if your sax has nickelplated rivets or resonators. Otherwise you can get corrosion problemes. This is not the case if you have plastic, sterling silver or brass resonators.

Once a month I use to rinse the neck with warm water. Lots of warm water. Let the crane run into your neck for a minute or two. This will help all saxes, with a neck, to become more freeblowing. I also think it's more important that the inside of the tube is cleaner than the outside.

Bariplayers- how do you swab your horns? It can be done but not with a Pad Saver ..... .

Thomas

Hi Thomas

Do read the Steve Howard article where he comments on much of what you raise.

Kind regards
Tom 8)
 
Pjonah wrote:

That made me shudder, I had an "experience" once (when i was 14) while on a "Duke of Edinburgh's" award map reading thing. Involved being "took short" and electrocuted from the waist up and down lol. direct contact no less! >.< shouldnt have been quite so bashfull! :blush: lol No permanent damage though 😉

col.
 
I'd mostly read anecdotal stories of padsavers leaving fibres in the toneholes and causing leaks and keeping more moisture in than they remove, which is waht made me sceptical.
On reading further however it seems that the moulting problem is more a problem with cheaper brands rather than the HW and than if you swab first then a padsaver can be useful.

The problem is now I don't know what to do 🙁 I want what's best for my sax but it's not always so easy to find even the twelve quid needed to buy a padsaver (woe is me lol). :cry:
 
Tenor; I pull through a couple of times, both ways with a chamois, clean neck with a neck mop and leave on a stand to dry. Seems ok to me, but what do I know!
Soprano; I have a long mop, is this a pad saver? which I use to dry the inside, and a small mop for the neck, then put it on the stand. Dunno if it's wrong, but aint noticed any corrosion/rust/verdigris etc, and still plays good. Or as good as I can play anyway.
 
I only us a pad saver when I pack my horns in their cases. They help to protect the octave mechanism, and stop any moisture moving around inside the saxes, especialy after a hard played gig when they get quite wet inside. Once they are back at home, I set them up on their stands in my music room/office. The air flows freely and keeps them dry without the pad savers. So Yay and Nay for me. I believe they have their uses!
 
I tend to not bother with them with my horns that I use regularly.

But I do with the ones that sit in a cupboard for a couple of months or more. I just feel better about them stored this way than having an exposed hollow tube, nothinig to do with saving the pads for me and maybe it doesn't do anything except make me happier about it. :whistle:
 
TomMapfumo wrote:
Thomsax wrote:
Does an ordinary swab really take care of moisture?? You pull the swab through your sax a couple of times and it takes just a few seconds!! I think it just help to get the moisture out all over the tube so it will dry faster?

When you played get rid of the moisture with paper, swab and a Pad Saver. A swab doesn't dry the toneholes. The pads should also be dry up after playing. This is important if your sax has nickelplated rivets or resonators. Otherwise you can get corrosion problemes. This is not the case if you have plastic, sterling silver or brass resonators.

Once a month I use to rinse the neck with warm water. Lots of warm water. Let the crane run into your neck for a minute or two. This will help all saxes, with a neck, to become more freeblowing. I also think it's more important that the inside of the tube is cleaner than the outside.

Bariplayers- how do you swab your horns? It can be done but not with a Pad Saver ..... .

Thomas

Hi Thomas

Do read the Steve Howard article where he comments on much of what you raise.

Kind regards
Tom 8)

Hi Tom,

Steve Howard's website is very good. Nice reading as well. I've vistited his website a couples of times but so far just reviews, Martin Selective Corrrosion and now even the Pad Saver article.


For six years ago I was one of five Swedish contributors to give Swedish words to "Tipbook Saxofon" (Hugo Pinsterboer). I thought about doing a saxophone manual of my own because there is so much more to tell. Lot's of work and it's not easy to get published!?!?!

Thomas
 
Well, it seems to be about 2-1 against padsavers, so I think perhaps I'll transfer mine from the used-every-day Yammy to the much-less-used Dolnet (I have a bung for the top end so no worries about damaging the octave mechanism) and maybe dispense with the one in the tenor.
 
I guess I'm in the minority in yet another category.

When I didn't use one I had problems all the time with pads needing to be replaced (this was when I played every day at university). There was a big drop off in the hardening of the pads after I started using one. However, I did run the swab through first because of accumulation of moisture towards the bottom of the bell. I kept my instruments out on a stand once ~ came home to find that my roommate had a party and ruined my Selmer soprano - terminally bent it. Little cagey ever since then about storing on the stands unless I'm in a pit orchestra.

Personal preference on this one?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,509
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom