Playing the saxophone Playing with a vocalist?

If only all saxophones were that mellow. Even then, there are issues for me when there are saxophone/singer unisons. Sting probably didn't care anyway.
For me there is a bit too much playing when Sting is singing but because its so mellow it doesn't detract from the overall performance and it works well.
I have been playing for one band with a vocalist for the last 20 years, I will do very little filling whilst the singer is singing but will have my time when it's my solo.
 
Do the saxophones usually sit out when the vocalist sings the melody?
You can play while the singer is singing but more in the background. To fill the gap is to start play your fillings just before the gap and get off the filling just after the singer starts to sing again. Try to get a nice flow, less, "stiff/staccato". To know the lyrics helps up. Build your fillings based on the lyrics and play to words with your sax. Jamie Anderson's video "Stop Improvising" is useful when it comes to this play fillings as well. Think in variation of phrases.

If you are the only sax/horn player in a small band with a singer. What to do ...

.... play your sax from the start of the song or join later? As an enthusiastic woodshed honker I try to play as much as I can. I think it's harder to play less. So just sit out if you have been told to do so.
.... play and backing the singer in the background.
.... solo of course, but play it in same style as the singer would sing it. No too much "listen and see what I can do".
... backing other instrumentalists when they are playing a solo.

This is what I've been told and heard at workshops/clinics.

Listen is important.

Here is two videos with the Boston sax man Scott Shetler. Two R&B songs.

"Fool In Love" (Ike Turner). Baritone fillings, solo, backing the guitar solo ..... and Metalite mpc is a part of the baritone sound!!!!!
View: https://youtu.be/lMgTZMspyQ8?feature=shared


"Bring It on Home". Tenor sax instead of bari. A song that often was played at our jam.
View: https://youtu.be/fQAYQhirgOU?feature=shared



The saxophone and the human voice blends good. Much better than the guitar, piano, trumpet ...... .
 
Last edited:
The D'Addario Rico Metalite mouthpieces seemed to have fallen out of popular use over time, for example, the on-line US store Musician's Friend only has in stock their M9 Bari, M7 Tenor and M7 Soprano in stock, alto was discontinued a while back. Plus, those are commanding a higher price of say, $45 US. And, as I have observed, it is the player more than the mouthpiece that makes the sax sing, although the mouthpiece does play a part.

(But, sometimes the sax is blamed when say for a neophyte, a simple change in mouthpieces can make a great improvement in how the sax performs.)
 
I bought a Metalite M9 baritone mpc because I was curious it's are bad as lots of sax players claims. I have over the years talked a lot about baritone mouthpieces, from baritone specialists to guys who are just accidentally playing bari sax, from professional bari players to woodshed honkers, like myself, who are just making noise for fun ..... . For a woodshed honker, the Metalite is doing the same job as the Low Rider and Dukoff I was playing before. I wonder if all sax players which says Metalite are bad have been blowing/playing one?

Back to topic.
 
I bought a Metalite M9 baritone mpc because I was curious it's are bad as lots of sax players claims. [...] For a woodshed honker, the Metalite is doing the same job as the Low Rider and Dukoff I was playing before. I wonder if all sax players which says Metalite are bad have been blowing/playing one?
If it works for you and you like it, what difference does it make what others think of it? I bought several other of their other product, Graftonite in sizes for soprano, alto, tenor and bari, and overall am satisfied with them.

Now with the community band, I am using the mouthpiece that came with my tenor, it does not project like the Graftonite, but then I am balancing with the flutes, oboe, bassoon and clarinets and the darker less projecting sound volume allows me to support and blend with them.
 
Last edited:
Everybody should try a metalite. imho
It reveals possibilities that aren't apparent on other set ups. It can sing sweetly or rasp like chainsaw.

I've tried one on SATB. It got me going on soprano when I thought I'd never get there.
It was hard to play on baritone because the smiling interrupted my embouchure.
I eventually went the Selmer way on saxophones.

To my complete surprise it suits my chops and idea of sound on clarinet. Sweet or coarse, very flexible sound wise. It'll whisper or shout and compete in an acoustic environment with trumpet and trombone.

M11 with a 3.5 reed.
 
Everybody should try a metalite. imho
It reveals possibilities that aren't apparent on other set ups. It can sing sweetly or rasp like chainsaw.
I mean in a sense I agree they should try one, I think however their conclusion would be vastly different than yours.
They are atrocious, , IMHO, yeah they might produce a 'unique' sound but, honestly....other very inexpensive mouthpieces do that and much more, way better. I find their tone terrible and their blowing response ....primitive.
My 2 cents.

You can rasp and sing sweetly with other models, much more easily and far better than with any of these.

Honestly as far as the vid, I would have been interested in hearing the player ona real mouthpiece, even just an ol' Yama plastic. I would posit the tone would be much better.

I really didn't mean to derail this thread, I just think they are and have always been a piece of hardware which truly handicaps a player in so many ways.

And quite honestly, admit it, they were never made to be anything else but the cheapest alternative available.

Again, apologies for the digression. The subject was playing with a vocalist, I just couldn't help myself, admittedly,...
 
Again, apologies for the digression. The subject was playing with a vocalist, I just couldn't help myself, admittedly,...
I couldn't help myself either, and I noticed you have a few more grey hairs showing. Turned 70 this year, I've found that I'm more curmudgeon now or OCD - "old, cranky and dangerous". 😉
 
@JayeNM You're probably a much better baritone player compared to me. As I wrote earlier I was curious if a Metalite bari mpc would fit me. I admit that my other mouthpieces are better and produce a better sound. But most of the time I play tenor and I don't play Metalite on tenor.

Being a hobby Rock & Roll sax player I like Metalite baritone mouthpiece because of the/they are ....

.... tone/sound it produce. It's easy to blend in Rocksax styles (blues, rock & roll, R&B, soul, funk .....). It cuts through.
.... they are relativity cheap. For c 580.00 s e k (including freight) I could get a new baritone mouthpiece without ligature. Good for a person that don't have the opportunity to buy a mouthpiece for 2500.00 - 5000.00 s e k on a mouthpiece.
.... easy to blow. I din't had do spent too much money and time to before it played in the way I like.
... a well made piece of plastic. I didn't have to spend extra money on having it opened op and the baffle filed down which was the case with my Dukoff bari mpc.

Back to topic.
 
Everybody should try a metalite. imho It reveals possibilities that aren't apparent on other set ups. It can sing sweetly or rasp like chainsaw. I've tried one on SATB. It got me going on soprano when I thought I'd never get there.
I feel the same about the Graftonite series.
It was hard to play on baritone because the smiling interrupted my embouchure.
I've got the same problem, not able to smile at the ladies like Kenny G and play same time. :banana:
I eventually went the Selmer way on saxophones.
Although I've got a Graftonite, prefer using my Selmer S-90 option 190 alto mouthpiece. I was very fortunate that it came with the used Antigua Winds pro alto. Use 2.5 strength cane reeds. Now, the mouthpiece nearly costs what I paid for the sax. Data from Musician's Friend:
  • Facing designation-190, tip opening-1.70, facing length-22.00
It makes the sax sing, but for the community band, use the original mouthpiece, as it is much easier to play soft enough to balance the clarinets, flutes and double reeds.
To my complete surprise it suits my chops and idea of sound on clarinet. Sweet or coarse, very flexible sound wise. It'll whisper or shout and compete in an acoustic environment with trumpet and trombone. M11 with a 3.5 reed.
25 years ago, I surprised the Albuquerque band that with a wide tip opening hard rubber mouthpiece (name escapes me), with of all things, a plastic Bundy clarinet, could blow as loud as a trumpet, embarrassing the enlisted band leader during indoor rehearsal. (We used plastic clarinets for outdoor playing in case incliment weather set in, precipitation wouldn't ruin a more expensive wood clarinet.) :sax:
 
You can play while the singer is singing but more in the background. To fill the gap is to start play your fillings just before the gap and get off the filling just after the singer starts to sing again. Try to get a nice flow, less, "stiff/staccato". To know the lyrics helps up. Build your fillings based on the lyrics and play to words with your sax. Jamie Anderson's video "Stop Improvising" is useful when it comes to this play fillings as well. Think in variation of phrases. [...]

Here is two videos with the Boston sax man Scott Shetler. Two R&B songs. [...]

"Bring It on Home". Tenor sax instead of bari. A song that often was played at our jam.
View: https://youtu.be/fQAYQhirgOU?feature=shared

The saxophone and the human voice blends good. Much better than the guitar, piano, trumpet ...... .
My sentiments exactly. Sax is one of the few instruments that IMO goes well with vocal, compliments.

Some time ago, someone had posted in another forum, that to guide a large chorus had an alto playing the lead for the group to follow and keep in sync. It was so effective and the sax blended so well with the singing, that one heard the chorus rather than the sax.

This is not to say that the guitar, piano/keyboard or trumpet (perhaps muted? or flugel horn?) can also do the same. A very skilled player knows just how to control their instrument for effective playing and blending. However, the sax indeed seems a natural for this.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom