Tone or Sound Player has more control over mouthpiece tone than saxophone?

Ahhh but what about Reeds.

I bought a D5M for my alto, as I wasn't entirely happy with my S80 C*. I still preferred the C*.

After neglecting rotating reeds and having no idea which were good and bad out of my collection, I tried a Java Red (rather than green), and it transformed the sound. I've tried slightly harder greens, but keep going back to the red.

At my first rehearsal with the Reds, my solo caught everyone by suprise, to the point everyone stopped counting the bars. At my next lesson I assembled the sax, and just played a few notes, to see my teacher spin round and look with a smile and nod of approval.

For me, the reed has made the biggest impact, that appears to be evident to others.
 
Ahhh but what about Reeds.
I agree reeds do make a big impact, but I don't think it's one that the player has any control over. In other words whatever you do with your embouchure can control any inherent tone that is imparted by the mouthpiece - but not really going to change the inherent tone of a reed.
 
A long tone can change over the key changes. Control or ......
Alternative fingerings can change the tone. Still in tune but different color. Control or .....

I have heard young sax players (jazz) saying that Clarence Clemons played out of tune. Maybe he was but not on songs/part they were referring to.
 
A long tone can change over the key changes. Control or ......
Sometimes (when just intonation is happening ,e.g. playing over strings) a long tone might (or should) change pitch. For example when playing a long F# over a D major but then the chord changes to Ab7 and the sustained note changes from F# to Gb.
 
Last edited:
Ahhh but what about Reeds.

I bought a D5M for my alto, as I wasn't entirely happy with my S80 C*. I still preferred the C*.

After neglecting rotating reeds and having no idea which were good and bad out of my collection, I tried a Java Red (rather than green), and it transformed the sound. I've tried slightly harder greens, but keep going back to the red.

At my first rehearsal with the Reds, my solo caught everyone by suprise, to the point everyone stopped counting the bars. At my next lesson I assembled the sax, and just played a few notes, to see my teacher spin round and look with a smile and nod of approval.

For me, the reed has made the biggest impact, that appears to be evident to others.
Red French filed.

Green American/Regular cut.


Selmers like French cut reeds imo. Vive la difference. 🇫🇷🇺🇸
 
Sometimes (when just intonation is happening ,e.g. playing over strings) a long tone might (or should) change pitch. For example when playing a long F# over a D major but then the chord changes to Ab7 and the sustained note changes from F# to Gb.
I don’t agree. I know what you’re saying about string players not conforming to tempered tuning etc and that a note acting as a minor third should be flatter than if it was functioning as a root for example.

But, the effect of keeping a note the same while the chord changes underneath must be exactly that - the note doesn’t change, microtonally or otherwise. That’s the beauty and effect of it. It would sound odd otherwise. Think of Claus Ogerman’s writing - chords materialise into other chords via voice leading, the notes held over don’t change their tuning.
 
I don’t agree. I know what you’re saying about string players not conforming to tempered tuning etc and that a note acting as a minor third should be flatter than if it was functioning as a root for example.

But, the effect of keeping a note the same while the chord changes underneath must be exactly that - the note doesn’t change, microtonally or otherwise. That’s the beauty and effect of it. It would sound odd otherwise. Think of Claus Ogerman’s writing - chords materialise into other chords via voice leading, the notes held over don’t change their tuning.
A couple years ago Jacob Collier did a video where he modulated a quarter tone. Using common tones. It’s really ear opening.
 
That’s what I thought until it happened to me.
What happened to you?
You found yourself change automatically?
It sounded out of tune if you didn't?

Of course, this begs other questions/observations:

If a piano was involved, this question wouldn't be posed.

Now, should the string players be more mindful then of their "natural" tuning and "temper" themselves if the (presumed) soloist has hit a note and stayed there while they change chords underneath.

Does it matter too much? (how bad does it sound?) - let's not forget that string players are all playing "out" with one another which is why a section sounds so rich.

Does anyone have a link to this J Collier video? Probably easy enough to find.
 
What happened to you?
It was a recording session where I was playing with strings . I can’t remember if it was live (at the same time as the strings) or not but in the control room it was pointed out by the producer that my F# seemed to suddenly be out of tune when the chord changed. There was quite a discussion because it sounded fine once the strings (except strong bass in rhythm section) were removed from the mix). The strings on there own sounded fine.

So we did a take with me getting more strings in headphones and I concentrated very much on listening to that change and I certainly did need to adjust.

Thinking about it, the chord change may have been F# to D.
 
It was a recording session where I was playing with strings . I can’t remember if it was live (at the same time as the strings) or not but in the control room it was pointed out by the producer that my F# seemed to suddenly be out of tune when the chord changed. There was quite a discussion because it sounded fine once the strings (except strong bass in rhythm section) were removed from the mix). The strings on there own sounded fine.

So we did a take with me getting more strings in headphones and I concentrated very much on listening to that change and I certainly did need to adjust.

Thinking about it, the chord change may have been F# to D.
This is an anomaly. It feels wrong to me, having to modify the tuning of an already sounding note because the strings "did their thing".

With piano concertos/chamber groups they won't be able to do this (or shouldn't), so why do it in this case?

In fact, in my other life I played the Mozart Clarinet Quintet plenty of times. I'm trying to remember any such problem - ie did Mozart avoid writing something that could become a problem in this way? I do remember having to modify where my perceived tuning was on my clarinet, but there again, the string players weren't Perlman, or Ma etc.
 
A couple years ago Jacob Collier did a video where he modulated a quarter tone. Using common tones. It’s really ear opening.
I find it all a bit "emperors new clothes". There again I'm not totally sure what he is saying happened with the "4 magic chords" - is it not a case of slightly sharpening each time thru say, 3-6-2-5 ?

And if you digitally sharpen his G half sharp resolution chord, does it become a dull Ab?
 
Which begs another question:

On: this key is bright, this key is dull etc..

In the “old days “ of tape, (cassettes too), machines could run fast or slow. Cassette decks were pretty awful for it. So, if you take a piece that is all “uplifting/bright” keys and play it on a cassette deck that has a slow running motor, do you sit there thinking that the piece is a bit dull?

Can the same be said of a performance by an orchestra playing to A=438 and another at 443?
 
I think the bright vs dark keys thing relates back to days when keyboards were tuned differently in different keys. This is not so long ago, in historical terms: only a couple hundred years. Bach's "Well tempered clavier" was not tuned in equal temperament.

I know that Db, for example, is considered a "dark" key. I think the thirds are a little lower in Db than in C on a piano. This has something to do with "stretch tuning" and is also dependent on the order that the strings are tuned. And on the person doing the tuning 🙂

Nowadays of course most keyboards are digital, and equal temperament is truly equal. I'm not really sure this is an improvement...
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,519
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom