Personal Tutors - essential at every stage? or a luxury?

mark_whiteley

Member
Messages
46
How about a new beginners topic.

I think we all accept that having a personal one to one tutor is the best starting point for a wind instrument. Unlike , say guitar, where to a certain extent, self teaching is possible.

But, I have been having one to one lessons (2 different tutors) for almost 2 years and I am now (after some really wonderful tuition I have to say) I am considering going it alone (for economic reasons)

and I am asking myself:

Have I got the self discipline to practise consistently without the 'pressure' of preparing for the next lesson?

I know there are sufficient good, books, instruction DVD's, CD's and even online video lessons, some of which can be had for free, but...

The big question is: Is it possible to progress just as quickly without a personal tutor to be your critical friend and challenge setter ?

What does everyone think about this? What are your own personal experiences. After a certain point as a beginner, are personal tutors good value for money or a luxury we can do without ?
 
[color:green]I've been playing for a year and have a lesson once a fortnight (it was once a week, economic reasons again!!). I think I would find progress much slower without having lessons. If I want to learn a new tune, and am having problems, I tend to give up on it, whereas if my teacher gives me a tune, I will stick with it until I can play it reasonably well.

Also, once I can play the tune to my satisfaction, my teacher usually tells me where I'm going wrong, or at least, where I could do things better.

I'll probably go on to do Grade II soon, and I'm sure having lessons will greatly improve my pieces, and help with the aural and quick studies will be essential!!![/color]
 
When I think I've got a tune right my teacher will often point out an error. That is one great value of a teacher - spotting the flaws you don't spot for yourself.

My teached has said his objective to get me to the position where I can reliably spot my errors for myself. After three years I'm still miles away.
 
I think it can certainly help. I also think it's essential for a complete beginner.

Over the last few months I haven't had a tutor and I my progress has slowed. I'm planning on getting a tutor again soon, just having a fortnightly lesson.

I think sometimes weekly is too much. It is hard to find time to practise and I certainly don't manage to practise every day now that I have university and a job. Before when I was just at school I could easily get an hour done a day, most of the time 2 or more.
 
I would argue that we do need and benefit from regular fresh input. I have had a tutor for the past two years - now fortnightly for 1.5 hours, rather than weekly for an hour due to increasing petrol costs - and recently had a 2 month break. It was a change and meant some time out for my usual routine, and trying other things, but I did miss the challenge and input and am glad that we have started again. I am taking my Tenor along, rather than my Alto, which has been the only sax for the past 18 months.

So I'd recommend some decent input, preferably in human form, though books and CD's have their place.

Kind regards
Tom
 
Thanks to all of you for your comments on this so far on this topic.
.
I agree with you Linky that a lesson a week (which is what I've
had for 2years) is probably too much. No sooner has it finished
but the next week is upon me and (probably like most tutors) my
tutor doesn't really understand that it's not always possible to
practise every day.

So maybe reducing to a fortnightly lesson and at the same time
trying to increase practise time, would be the best way
forward.

Linky wrote:
I think it can certainly help. I also think it's essential for a complete beginner.

Over the last few months I haven't had a tutor and I my progress has slowed. I'm planning on getting a tutor again soon, just having a fortnightly lesson.

I think sometimes weekly is too much. It is hard to find time to practise and I certainly don't manage to practise every day now that I have university and a job. Before when I was just at school I could easily get an hour done a day, most of the time 2 or more.
 
If you might need motivation when you don't have a tutor try and find a local concert band or similar (if you're comfortable that you're at a level to give it a go).

No, you won't get the one-to-one help on specifics, but you'll learn a lot AND have a reason to keep working on the sax. Add to that a less regular session with a teacher - they can help you with a more focussed lessons, perhaps working on band pieces you're struggling with.

Lots of reasons to work and progress.

Phil
 
I had a years worth of (term-time) lessons and found them very valuable. I got a bit caught up in the technical side of things - scales etc. I moved home and have given up the lessons for a while in favour of just finding the sheet music for songs I know (or half know) and just enjoying playing for the sake of playing. I must admit that my sight reading has improved enormously and so has my fingering/note changes.
More to the point, I'm thoroughly enjoying it all. Songs like "Moondance" and "Careless Whisper" as well as some of the old standards and some pop stuff are great to work out and play. The people next door don't bang on the wall quite so often either. 😛
 
I've only been learning for just over a month, so my personal tutor has been invaluable in getting me started.
However, she is a classical player and has no knowledge of jazz/blues/rock. She is giving me a good technical education, but away from her lessons I'm starting to experiment with the sort of music I want to play.
Luxury? No. I need her for my technical education. I'm not a sax player yet, so I'll continue with my lessons and eventually make a decision.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,509
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom