Playing the saxophone Passion or skill?

I heard a recording of our community jazz band's gig last week (my maiden voyage).

It sounded much better and tighter to what I heard whilst playing. There were a few 'bum' notes - not all from me I'm glad to say - but the audience didn't seem to care or even notice.

We got applause after each song and some whoops at the end (the finale was Green Onions) and some were singing along. I think a good time was had by all despite not being note perfect. It wasn't the Albert or Carnegie Hall but it was fun.
I'm delighted, @cappers! I seem to remember you saying some time ago somethings like "well we'll be playing in a pub so I doubt that many people will be listening anyway". Yes, all bands have highs and lows in terms of audience interest and appreciation at different 'gigs'. So I'm delighted that your "maiden voyage" went so well. For the audience, the band and for you personally.

It sounds like you can take away a lot of positive things from your 1st concert experience! Not least in terms of your self-confidence in playing in the band.

PS. Your comments just underline what I and many others have mentioned: amateur musicians are usually much more critical of themselves (occasional wrong notes, 'fluffed' solo's, etc.) than most audiences are.
 
Are you suggesting the Audience thought Coltrane was playing from a score?
He was probably improvising but all impros start from some kind of music score. Whatever it was it turned me off bebop but thankfully i’d heard him play other stuff so he remains up there with Sonny Rollins, on tenor, as GOATs for me. But I see where you’re going, if it was impro there can be no wrong note. You’re right. Still sounded awful to my ears.
 
He was probably improvising but all impros start from some kind of music score.
Different things IMO. Improvising being a spontaneous creation and a score requiring a (sometimes lengthy) thought process that is written down and can go through various edit processes and revisions)
 
Ok, I get it. My impros usually come from a score that I lift notes and chords from that somewhat alter the tune. I thought it was the norm. My bad.😞
 
Satisfying for the player is achievable. Satisfying for the listener depends on the player knowing the tastes of the listener(s). This is not always possible although you may find out whether or not you have succeeded after the performance.
 
Ok, I get it. My impros usually come from a score that I lift notes and chords from that somewhat alter the tune. I thought it was the norm. My bad.😞
There's a difference between working out a solo and improvising.

My improv. often comes from hearing a tune for the first time, twice through and off we go. No score, no lead sheet, just ears and fingers finding a way. Granted it won't be anything complicated. The hard bit is when the rhythm section are busking and don't know it either. Feel the bars and finish on tonic. (and keep a straight face) 😐
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,354
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom