I heard a recording of our community jazz band's gig last week (my maiden voyage).
It sounded much better and tighter to what I heard whilst playing. There were a few 'bum' notes - not all from me I'm glad to say - but the audience didn't seem to care or even notice.
We got applause after each song and some whoops at the end (the finale was Green Onions) and some were singing along. I think a good time was had by all despite not being note perfect. It wasn't the Albert or Carnegie Hall but it was fun.