Playing the saxophone Overboard on overtones

Messages
700
Location
USA
There are many overtone threads here (I like this one), and everyone talks about Rascher's Top Tones book. It seemed like a 'thing to do' so since August I was doing a few minutes of overtones every practice, on B. After some time I could sound the first two overtones, and the third but not consistently. It felt like a good warmup. This seems like a common experience for beginners.

A couple of weeks ago I happened upon an online book by Michael Furstner. It doesn't seem that well known (there's one or two references on SOTW and none here that I found). If you follow that link you'll see the URL looks like you're entering the dark web and the text has a similar quality as late night TV shows about aliens building the pyramids, but nevertheless (or maybe for those reasons) I found it quite compelling. Furstner makes a somewhat bold claim,

If you practice one hour or less per day : use 75% of your daily practice time on Overtone practice and nothing else, until you break into the Head Register. (Play enjoyable relaxing things like ballads for the remaining 25%).

As I was looking for references to Furstner I read a lot more about overtones (maybe I should have questioned my sanity after finishing the 80 page thesis "Analysis of Overtone Production Techniques in Saxophone Teaching Methods"). I wasn't going to go completely overboard but I decided to replace the other voicing exercises I had been doing with all overtones practice, so for the last couple of weeks I've been setting the timer for twenty minutes and working from Bb to Db.

Furstner helpfully provides a chart (as a GIF no less, but I think he made it in the late 90s) to track your progress on the first twelve overtones. After a couple of weeks I can sound the first three overtones from Bb to Db though the 3rd on Db is quite difficult.

I feel like the overtone practice is a much better workout of air support and voicing than long tones (probably because my long tones are bad, but there you go). Also I've noticed that focusing even just 20 minutes on one thing has a much different feeling than I would have expected. Maybe because before I tended to cover 5 or 6 things in the hour or so I have for practice so my mind is staying more on the surface of things? Hard to say.

Anyway, what I'd really like to know is if anyone has read Furstner's book. It can't be totally unknown can it?
 
looks like you're entering the dark web and the text has a similar quality as late night TV shows about aliens building the pyramids
:mrcool:rofl: indeed !

Thanks for sharing, not familiar but I am now also intrigued here and having a read.

I do a slice of overtones practice everyday, but sometimes not much of that sounds nice. If that was all I worked on each day and replaced 75% of my routine I'm not sure I could endure it.
 
Wow, six months goes by quick.

I'm still doing 20 minutes of overtones a day (well lately I'm kind of cheating because I include some pitch bending in that), but I have yet to break the "4th wall" consistently. Maybe Furstner was on to something with his Head Register idea. I feel like I have picked up on some things though:

* To get the 4th OT of low Bb I learned about bumping palm D somewhat early on, but it wasn't that reliable. What I didn't realize was that if I open the F key, then I get the 4th by bumping palm D pretty much every time. Once I have the note I can close F and concentrate on holding the pitch. This might be related to the following.

* I can get the same note (palm D) by fingering low G and blowing the 2nd OT. This is several times more reliable than bumping palm D when fingering low Bb, but I'm guessing the voicing for the 2nd OT of low G and the 4th OT of low Bb is different, even though it's the same pitch -- anyone with ideas on that?
 
I'm guessing the voicing for the 2nd OT of low G and the 4th OT of low Bb is different, even though it's the same pitch -- anyone with ideas on that?
Good question and something I've thought about too.Hopefully someone who knows more can swing by with a more definitive answer, but ...
I am working with the Sinta book and the way presented there to access new "modes" (eg. Fundamental, 1st mode, 2nd mode etc.) is to climb up in one mode, maintain pitch and then "match" as you revert to the lower fingerings.

I don't know if the reason this works is because the voicing is basically the same or because you are already playing a note that isn't a fundamental you are closer to it than you would be otherwise and it requires less adjustment to hit. I'm sure there's some fascinating science somewhere related to lengths of pipe, oral cavities and precision tolerances of a fundamental Vs high overtone.

Either way, personally, I find venting or matching overtones helps because it's a reliable way to get to the note and eventually build to getting it cold.
 
the voicing for the 2nd OT of low G and the 4th OT of low Bb is different, even though it's the same pitch -- anyone with ideas on that?
It's the same note, but probably not the same pitch. As overtones have no relation to equal temperament, then unless you manipulate them with your embouchure to fit equal temperament then tuning is probably more like just intonation, although even that is probably not true of a saxophone whose acoustics are based on an imperfect design.

This is due to the fact that an ideal conical bore instrument would be a cone that is not truncated by a mouthpiece but is of course not possible so the mouthpiece volume sort of compensate for the "missing cone."

saxwithcone.webp


TLDR: don't expect any overtone to be perfectly in tune except maybe the first and possibly the second.

 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,315
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom