Playing the saxophone Over the Rainbow - last note

Jeanette

Organizress
Cafe Moderator
Messages
26,816
Location
Cheshire UK
Level
Eternal Beginner
I am playing the above on sop as arranged by Giuseppe Parmigiani for sax quartet. It is in F major the last 2 bars are crotchet g quaver e and f crotchet g crotchet a and finally semi breve G. That last g just sounds wrong, could it be?

thanks in advance

Jx
 
The G is right. The last chord hangs without resolving to the more comfortable F.
Screenshot 2023-01-23 at 20.50.21.webp
 
If this is the arrangement, then it's ending on a 6/9 chord, with the 9 in the sop part. Seems pretty out of character given the vanilla harmony in the rest of the tune. I'd change the sop and alto notes so you'd have SATB play FGAC.

I much prefer the Puerling arrangement my quartet plays:
View: https://youtu.be/sL5tqx9FYYs
 
If this is the arrangement, then it's ending on a 6/9 chord, with the 9 in the sop part. Seems pretty out of character given the vanilla harmony in the rest of the tune. I'd change the sop and alto notes so you'd have SATB play FGAC.

I much prefer the Puerling arrangement my quartet plays:
View: https://youtu.be/sL5tqx9FYYs
I love Puerling's amazingly creative harmonic ideas and this wonderful arrangement. I was disappointed that the recording wasn't by the Singers Unlimited whose sound will remain imprinted in my consciousness forever. Hat's off to your quartet if they can play all of Puerling's dissonant harmonies and passing tones in tune which is no easy task.
 
I love Puerling's amazingly creative harmonic ideas and this wonderful arrangement. I was disappointed that the recording wasn't by the Singers Unlimited whose sound will remain imprinted in my consciousness forever. Hat's off to your quartet if they can play all of Puerling's dissonant harmonies and passing tones in tune which is no easy task.
Thanks. I've been a huge Puerling fan forever. We've got about ten of his arrangements for my quartet, a few of which I adapted myself from Singers Unlimited, which is tough because those can have 8 or more overdubbed parts. Gives me chills every time we play them. I've struggled to transcribe Singers Unlimited tunes for years and decode those brilliant harmonies. I've got lots more arrangements in the pipeline that I may never finish unfortunately.

We eventually nail the harmonies, but it takes a few rehearsals to get everyone to lean into the dissonance and get the blend just right. But we've been at it about 10 years. When we get it perfect, it's magic.

I wish there was a SU version of Rainbow. But he actually wrote that arrangement in 4 parts for Linda Ronstadt. I don't know if she ever actually recorded it. I remember Puerling said in an interview that's he's written arrangements for other artists that they ended up not being able to execute. We play another 4 part one he did for Manhattan Transfer back in the 80s (Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square). They nailed it of course.
 
To my ear it sounds as if it should be an F ending on the tonic chord. A misprint perhaps?
That's what I thought. 🙂

The G is right. The last chord hangs without resolving to the more comfortable F.
I suppose it will sound better when we are playing it together.

If this is the arrangement, then it's ending on a 6/9 chord, with the 9 in the sop part. Seems pretty out of character given the vanilla harmony in the rest of the tune. I'd change the sop and alto notes so you'd have SATB play FGAC.
Thank you

Jx
 
That's what I thought. 🙂
Ending on a 9th is quite common in mainstream jazz. It can sound a bit corny but maybe it can sound cool depending on context.

I agree that just playing the melody without the chords or other instruments it may well sound odd, but in context of the harmony it should maybe make more sense. Even if it sounds corny.
 
While discussing this wonderful tune I was reminded of the lovely arrangement by David Wolpe. I am posting it here for those who may have not heard it. It provides one of the rare occasions that one gets to hear the whole introduction of the song. Surprisingly the song was cut from the movie three times by the MGM executives before they were talked into keeping it.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-njkHOQTRoM
 
I've played that Wolpe chart!

Lots of good baritone sax.

And yes, the verse is rarely heard. A lot of tunes have verses, few people are aware of them. There's a whole, humorous, verse to My Funny Valentine that's pretty much never performed, that sets up the chorus a lot more clearly.
 
I note that in the verse, even the Marine Band had some challenges keeping the time together and rubato at the same time. I remember this well from rehearsing that chart.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,619
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom