Classical OMG

The music isn't found in the notes, its found in the spaces between the notes.

errrr......trimmy.......perhaps more reflection on what that actually means would help
I'll ask the same question, not being pedantic but I've heard this 'quote' many times and should of asked before, what is meant by
"The music isn't found in the notes, it's found in the spaces between" how so when music is notes !
 
Last edited:
I'll ask the same question, not being pedantic but I've heard this 'quote' many times and should of asked before, what is meant by
"The music isn't found in the notes, it's found in the spaces between" how so when music is notes !

Because if affects the phrasing, if you just keep playing one note after another with no silence it would sound very different. It's like listening to my son speak, he talks ten to the dozen without taking a breath sometimes and I can't hear what he is saying.

Jx
 
There's a local organist who sits in and deps on piano with local trad and NO bands. His solos are full of tension and release. He plays very little. Just odd notes and phrases and chords. It's captivating. Communication by sound in many forms depends on timing. Story telling, comedy, public speaking. Music is the same. A sigh can say as much as a soliloquy. I find it hard to say little with the saxophone. I always feel a good old rant coming on.
 
You don't have to understand the theory of a thing to enjoy it, and sometimes having a thing explained ruins the enjoyment of it. The difference between Charlie Parker and Lester Young for example. Frantic bebop and Lugubrious swing. It took me several decades to appreciate Parker but I got the Pres first time I heard him. It's about educating the ear and opening up new pathways in the brain and listening in different ways. You only need to hear the dog bark to know there's someone at the door but you better listen to every word and nuance of tone when the wife barks.
 
You don't have to understand the theory of a thing to enjoy it,
Exactly my point, as a listener i wouldn't understand a silence but the musician would !
Because if affects the phrasing,
Thinking more about what you say
How do you phrase a silence :confused2: you cant but you can affect the phrasing of a 'note' !

So therefore the music is in the note, to the listener
 
Notes and silence.
So therefore the music is in the note, to the listener

I feel that notes and silence are interdependent. One without the other is no use, and would probably not produce music

(unless you are john cage and write a piece of silence for 4 mins 33 secs. But thats another can of worms , probably best not opened ).

and to my ears a continuous stream of notes with no gaps/space almost never produces music that is satisfactory.

I need tension and release. the tension comes from lots of notes/business or it comes from dissonance.

the release is a resolution of the tension, or a bit of silence.

I love silence in music and for me, it certainly enhances my musical experience, whether its for a beat, or 4 bars , or whatever.

I'll take both, please.
 
Exactly my point, as a listener i wouldn't understand a silence but the musician would

Sorry to disagree. As a listener you'll hear both as the song. Like the spaces between words as someone talks. When you listen critically to well crafted and played music you'll feel tension build and be enhanced by the pauses. Think of the opening bars of Beethoven's Fifth symphony. The one that starts Dadadadaaa. It starts well spaced, but the drive of the notes makes you want to hear the repeat before the orchestra plays it. And as the opening develops, the spaces get shorter, driving the piece forward, just like putting your foot on the accelerator. Try humming the first few bars with a recording. Then try and shorten the pause between the first two Dadadadaaas. Doesn't work....

The opposite is true in a ballade - the smooth, seamless flow allows you to relax. One of the reasons why Coltrane's version of Summertime grates for me and some others is the way he kills the smooth flow with excessive punctuation. Try playing Stairway to Heaven. Clichéd maybe, but how would it sound with linger spaces between the words? There's a lady....

And it's the subtle timing differences in the spaces that they're talking about when they say the music is in the spaces. Not the gross examples I've given The right hesitation in a tango. The right pause between phrases in a solo.....
 
I've read that but don't agree with it, when i listen to a piece of music certain notes, phrases stand out due to articulation but spaces don't stand out or make me go wow loved that bit !

You lot are thinking and answering with your musicians head on and not as a listener (before you got into music)

Play a piece of music to Dave and ask him what stands out, guarantee it won't be a space !
So in my mind a listener, listens to the notes not the spaces, a musician does both.

@kevgermany
Kev i know what you are saying but it's the dadadadaa that stands out not the space between, like you say the space adds to the tension but before i started learning about music, i wouldn't of had a clue about tension in music and nor would the majority of listeners.

DeBussy's quote is a quote made by a musician and understood by musicians
 
Last edited:
The one that starts Dadadadaaa. It starts well spaced, but the drive of the notes makes you want to hear the repeat before the orchestra plays it. And as the opening develops, the spaces get shorter, driving the piece forward, just like putting your foot on the accelerator. Try humming the first few bars with a recording. Then try and shorten the pause between the first two Dadadadaaas. Doesn't work....
If you say the dadadadaa, quickly it sounds like an old train going over the joins in the track, there's a piece of music starts with that repeated three times. What is it?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,469
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom