Tech/maintenance Octave key problems

Kevin D

New Member
Messages
3
Location
California
Hi, my friend and I are working on a yearlong project for my engineering class, we both play tenor sax and love music and we are trying to make a solution for octave key problems, or make it a little easier and less expensive to get it fixed. It would be greatly appreciated if you could take this short survey just to help us with the production of this. Thank you in advance.

 
One should not have to sign in to take the survey, im not sure if it requires it or not on the form but if it does it's 100% anonymous. The problem itself is the general octave key and how it may bend and break over time and create squeakage or difficulty playing notes.
 
If people can make money selling Klangbogens, I'm sure fancy rubber bands for octave keys will be a big seller as well.

Personally, I've never found weak springs to be the root cause of octave key issues. Disconnected/broken springs or binding or bent or misaligned parts or blocked or sticky pips or leaky pads, yes, but not weak springs. So this product has very little relevance except as an overpriced band-aid to mask the root cause. So I would never buy or recommend such a product. What would be useful is a book about how to diagnose and fix octave key (and other) issues that the average player could handle using everyday household items and tools.

Best of luck to you.
 
This is an excerpt from the handout from a workshop I presented to band directors a few years back about octave key adjustments.

If the instrument will not play in the lower octave
∙ Check to see that there is at least a 1/16" gap between the neck octave key ring and the post extending from the body. If not place your thumb between the ring and the body of the neck and then gently push down on the octave key. Should you go too far, place a pad slick or tongue depressor under the pad and carefully push back on the ring until the desired gap is achieved.

If the 4th line D does not play or goes to a higher note (overtone)
∙ Press the thumb octave lever hard without pressing any other keys and see if the neck octave key opens. As in the previous case, make sure there is a gap between the ring and the post. On some saxes with a “spongy” cork stopping the thumb octave lever a wider gap may be necessary. *

*To test the octave key adjustment---finger G and forcefully hit the thumb octave key several times watching the neck octave pad. It should not move if in good adjustment. Then finger from G to A while pressing the thumb octave. The neck and body octave keys should alternate opening and closing completely.
 
Last edited:
What would be useful is a book about how to diagnose and fix octave key (and other) issues that the average player could handle using everyday household items and tools.
Something like this?


Printed out, the article runs upwards of 150 pages - and still doesn't cover every conceivable problem on every kind of octave mech.
 
If people can make money selling Klangbogens, I'm sure fancy rubber bands for octave keys will be a big seller as well.

Personally, I've never found weak springs to be the root cause of octave key issues. Disconnected/broken springs or binding or bent or misaligned parts or blocked or sticky pips or leaky pads, yes, but not weak springs. So this product has very little relevance except as an overpriced band-aid to mask the root cause. So I would never buy or recommend such a product. What would be useful is a book about how to diagnose and fix octave key (and other) issues that the average player could handle using everyday household items and tools.

Best of luck to you.

Probably most people with Yamaha (mentioned specifically to include YAS-23 lines, etc.) or modern, SA-80 or Selmer-descended designs are not going to have too many problems with octave settings done by techs, because *all* techs will become familiar with those.

Some vintage makes -- a lot of vintage makes -- will end up with octave spring issues ("weak" isn't the right word for the cause, but usually it will be a combination of spring tensions working against each other, rather than cooperating with each other...sort of like "weakness" in humans! lol). The same mechanisms that have three or more springs coordinating with one another, pushing in sort of different directions, will also often have a linkage key that lots of techs (who don't specialize, or who have heavy student/school account loads) won't see that often, and may fail to set up well. Usually it will be because the same linkage key, linking the keytouch key to the G and the body octave linkage key (that links to the neck octave key, which also includes another spring, i.e. the neck octave key flat spring, whose tension does matter), and that intermediary key may also link to the G twice, for example, and to the body octave linkage/lever twice, etc..

A flowchart online for octave issues is definitely doable, even one that covers every octave mechanism in existence, with detailed 3D clickable illustrations, etc. -- well, it is definitely doable, now. It will require a pretty good tech, if you only have 1 to inform the project, because I'm pretty OK, have 20+years experience, and don't have *any* school/student accounts, ever, and I still encounter octave mechs that rarely come up that I would not be able to recall/detail from memory (e.g. a vintage Borgani curved sop that was just here, confused the hell out of me for a good while, a few days ago).
 
The octave problems sound to me like embouchure issues which may (or may not) be affected by too soft a reed, and/or mouthpiece placement on the cork.
It can be a useful exercise to play octave without using the octave key - just embouchure and air stream.
If you have issues in a particular register it could be down to leaks - not the actual octave key.
Typically tenors suffer from octave issues due to neck pulldown changing how the octave key closes.
Other issues are where the sax is picked up around the octave mechanism and it gets bent. Or where an end plug isn't used and the mechanism gets bent. This sort of damage may or may not be obvious to see.
There's a lot of other issues, but generally speaking octave issues can be other things than the actual key.
 
Hi, my friend and I are working on a yearlong project for my engineering class, we both play tenor sax and love music and we are trying to make a solution for octave key problems, or make it a little easier and less expensive to get it fixed. It would be greatly appreciated if you could take this short survey just to help us with the production of this. Thank you in advance.


I am an engineer of several decades, have taught introductory as well as graduate-level engineering classes, and graded many such projects.

Why do you identify this as a problem and why do you consider it difficult and expensive to fix?

If you cannot justify your assumptions, then the whole project falls apart.
 
Basically, octave key problems disappeared when two things happened: 1) The Selmer teeter-totter design became the standard mechanism; 2) Yamaha started extending the neck key so the pin didn't protrude past the receiver.

At this point in time, for an instrument with both those features, you've basically got to engage in outright abuse to have issues, and if you do they're easily fixed. Now take something like a Conn 12M octave mechanism - that's complicated!
 
Basically, octave key problems disappeared when two things happened: 1) The Selmer teeter-totter design became the standard mechanism;
News to me.

Granted, the issue are less complex - but they still routinely crop up, and they still result in the same problems.
In fact the mech has brought its own problems. Assuming no damage it's a very reliable mech...but it keeps soldiering on until there's so much wear in it that almost nothing at all happens when you press the thumb key down.
 
I am an engineer of several decades, have taught introductory as well as graduate-level engineering classes, and graded many such projects.

Why do you identify this as a problem and why do you consider it difficult and expensive to fix?

If you cannot justify your assumptions, then the whole project falls apart.
Logic doesn't apply to the music accessory market unfortunately. Just look at how much money is being made selling imaginary solutions to imaginary problems, relying solely on magic and psychology (Klangbogen, heavy mass screws, gimmicky ligatures, gold/silver/copper necks, etc.). I'm sure these glorified rubber bands for dodgy octave keys will be a big seller even if the school project earns an F.
 
I'd like to see a project on the "engineering undergrad project questionnaire" problem.

The regular occurrence, around various discussing fora, of project questionnaires that show really inadequate preparation. A few hours, in this case, searching here, sotw, reading sites, taking to tecs and band leaders of and experienced players etc (qualitative research) analysis of which would result in a set of reasonable questions for which a questionnaire could add quantitative detail.

It rarely happens. Shame.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,676
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom