Noisy middle A

tommy_ng

Member
Messages
124
There is a "fizzy" noise whenever i play the middle A (octave key is open). In contrast, the middle B and G are comparatively quiet. This noise is particularly prominant when the sax is "wet"... Feeling like "water" is being squeezed out from somewhere

Even worst when i bite the mouthpiece harder..

Can anyone help???

8|
 
Hi Tommy!

Which A are you calling middle A? As far as I am aware you are referring to upper A, not lower A (are there more than 2?).

Which Sax are you talking about - Tenor or Alto? If Tenor I assume that you are probably not settled down in your playing of it as it is in a tricky area on the sax - A G sharp & G - where the two octave keys alternate, and seems to require certain embouchure alteration. Before that is achieved it does seem to involve gurgling (sounds like water!).

At least that is my current understanding of what happens. It will go with time, in my experience of going from alto to tenor.

Hope you are well
Kind regards
Tom
 
TomMapfumo wrote:
Hi Tommy!

Which A are you calling middle A? As far as I am aware you are referring to upper A, not lower A (are there more than 2?).

Which Sax are you talking about - Tenor or Alto? If Tenor I assume that you are probably not settled down in your playing of it as it is in a tricky area on the sax - A G sharp & G - where the two octave keys alternate, and seems to require certain embouchure alteration. Before that is achieved it does seem to involve gurgling (sounds like water!).

At least that is my current understanding of what happens. It will go with time, in my experience of going from alto to tenor.

Hope you are well
Kind regards
Tom

I have this problem with my alto, not tenor... It should be the upper A then (the octave key is open). There is no problem to play upper A with the octave key close.

My friend told me not to use the octave key altogether, as told by his sax teacher....

:erm:
 
Pete Thomas wrote:
It is an octave key issue, a good tech will be able to diagnose exactly what. It is a common issue.

It is my Walstein.....

Pete, am i right to say that the problem is within the cork? The octave hole not properly done?

:erm:
 
B****y Walsteins, just not set up properly.

Sorry, Tommy, I forgot that you were buying in reverse order - not the usual Alto to Tenor, but Tenor to Alto.

I does sound like a trip to the tech to me, as well. I admit to being unable to see the cork on your octave key, even with my eyesight!!

Kind regards
Tom 🙂
 
Tommy Ng wrote:
Pete Thomas wrote:
It is an octave key issue, a good tech will be able to diagnose exactly what. It is a common issue.

It is my Walstein.....

Pete, am i right to say that the problem is within the cork? The octave hole not properly done?

I can't answer that, the best thing would be to discuss it with whoever you bought it from. If it's Woodwind & Brass I'm quite certain you'll get a good customer service - they use very good techs to set the horns up before sales, that's one thing I know as I seen them do it.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom