Beginner Saxes Newbie doubts about buying used

  • Thread starter Thread starter Account Closed 8973
  • Start date Start date
So like why are online adverts of saxophones even a thing? What's the point if you're supposed to try it out yourself before purchasing it?
Because lots of people are willing to gamble, myself included. If the pics are really good, it usually works out ok. But also better to buy from someone who has lots of experience selling, or you'll have shipping damage. I've even insisted on pictures of the horn as it's being packed. I've been burned too many times before.
 
From an economic point of view, you should always be aware that new horns loose a significant fraction of their value in the moment you carry them out of the shop.

That means, particularly if you are on a budget, you get more saxophone for the money buying used, and your resale loss is smaller. But only if the price is OK in the first place and if the horn is OK. That’s where you need help.

An older Rampone is not a common option for a beginner, so only your teacher can tell you. But I feel you should also have the option to try the feel of a modern horn in comparison for yourself.
 
So like why are online adverts of saxophones even a thing? What's the point if you're supposed to try it out yourself before purchasing it?
Such a great question!
Because lots of people are willing to gamble, myself included.
For gamblers it's often the excitement that is important. Then you remember the wins and (try to) forget the loses.

But this is not a good strategy for beginners.
 
If you don't know what to look for, and you don't, don't buy online. Nobody here knows the Rampone, it may well be a decent horn, it's not a top line horn and you won't find one at that price but at least you will know that it's genuine and in working order. You don't say what other horns are available in the shop you are thinking of visiting, or their prices, it would be interesting to know.

If/when you go to the shop you can see what's available locally for the money you have to spend, you can actually blow the horns and see how you feel about the whole thing. Then you can decide if you really want, or particularly, really need, to look elsewhere. Maybe you need to plan a trip further afield but the horn will cost what it costs, I see that Raffaele Inghilterra is selling one for €1.300, so that maybe the going price for that horn. If you sell it you will lose money, same if you buy a more expensive horn, that's life with most musical instruments, but if you learn to play on it then it's worth it. Ask for a sconto anyway.

I assume that since you have a teacher you already own a saxophone of some description, in which case if you don't see what you want to buy for what you have to spend, buy nothing and save up.
 
Last edited:
If you don't want to risk buying unseen/online private sale, your only other option is to buy from an online shop which gives a good after sales warranty: if it reaches you damaged you can just send it back and get a new one, but you have to do your homework to find a reputable online store.
This will apply to new instruments, so if you are on a budget, you will have to resign yourself to getting something not as good as what you could afford on the second hand market. You will also take the devaluation hit on the new instrument, meaning that if you wish to sell the next day, you would have lost some money on the purchase price.
 
The option of hiring an instrument has already been mentioned, and that is certainly worth looking at.
When I started, about 20 years ago, I didn't have enough money to buy a saxophone (even second hand). So I bought a new yamaha YTS32 in a shop that offered loans (through a bank). That way I could start playing straight away and pay for it in the 1 or 2 years after the purchase. Maybe the shop you would go to has a similar service?
The Yardsale section is certainly a good place to look, I bought my baritone through the yardsale about 3 years ago. There are 2 tenors at the moment that might fit your budget:
 
And there is also the option of buying new on-line.
If there are no shops in your region that sell the brands that you would like to buy, you could try buying on-line from a reputable shop.
I have read good reports (on this and other forums) about these companies:
Pre Owned Saxophones they also offer 0%financing and hire of saxophones, but only to people living in the UK
Tenor saxophone | Matthew's Music
This one is within the EU, so less hastle with customs
 
The option of hiring an instrument has already been mentioned, and that is certainly worth looking at.
When I started, about 20 years ago, I didn't have enough money to buy a saxophone (even second hand). So I bought a new yamaha YTS32 in a shop that offered loans (through a bank). That way I could start playing straight away and pay for it in the 1 or 2 years after the purchase. Maybe the shop you would go to has a similar service?
The Yardsale section is certainly a good place to look, I bought my baritone through the yardsale about 3 years ago. There are 2 tenors at the moment that might fit your budget:
Both of those are without doubt better horns although neither really wants to post them and they are likely to need a set up after their travels. I can't believe that Martin is still there.
 
As a beginner myself I doubt that a really good sax will help you much. Of course a bad one will make things a lot more difficult. To me a used sax is like a used car. If you can identify deficiencies and repair them yourself then you have a much larger selection than someone who cannot. People who cannot repair their own cars or saxes should probably stick with new or reliable brands that have been through a dealer's shop to repair any issues.
 
Can I ask where @Account Closed 8973 is based? In a European country with a strong transport network I'd be surprised if there was anywhere not within two hours of an established used sax seller. My suggestion would be that it would be worth traveling to buy a sax, but if you're not near a technician to buy something with a reputation for playing well and being reliable (a Yamaha or if you can afford it a Yanagisawa) and then learning to do the basics of maintenance yourself.
 
As a beginner myself I doubt that a really good sax will help you much. Of course a bad one will make things a lot more difficult. To me a used sax is like a used car. If you can identify deficiencies and repair them yourself then you have a much larger selection than someone who cannot. People who cannot repair their own cars or saxes should probably stick with new or reliable brands that have been through a dealer's shop to repair any issues.
I disagree. I think a beginner should buy the best saxophone they can afford. And the car analogy is not a good one. It is quite feasible for a new player to buy a used sax safely if:
1. The seller has a return policy, or is someone you can trust.
2. A competent player can try it out for you as soon as you get it.
3. You have access to a good repairer for any tweaking that is required.

I have bought several used saxophones from internet sellers. On the whole I have chosen reliable brands (e.g. Buescher, Buffet-Crampon, Yamaha and Yanagisawa). I have had to return a couple, but the others (including my first ever saxophone) were fine. When I bought my first saxophone I paid a local professional to try it out. The cost was the same as a lesson.

When buying any used saxophone one should budget for setup and minor repairs.

I think it is useful for a player to be able to rectify small simple problems (such as a spring coming out of its cradle or a piece of cork falling off, of G# linkage adjustment), but in my opinion, complex regulation is best left to a professional.
 
I googled Saxophone Shop Italy and got many outlets, some with an online catalogue. FS is cheap and working, call the shops, visit, test.....I flew 10000kms for my Selmer. Buying a good sax requires some serious advance work.
 
I disagree. I think a beginner should buy the best saxophone they can afford. And the car analogy is not a good one. It is quite feasible for a new player to buy a used sax safely if:
1. The seller has a return policy, or is someone you can trust.
2. A competent player can try it out for you as soon as you get it.
3. You have access to a good repairer for any tweaking that is required.

I have bought several used saxophones from internet sellers. On the whole I have chosen reliable brands (e.g. Buescher, Buffet-Crampon, Yamaha and Yanagisawa). I have had to return a couple, but the others (including my first ever saxophone) were fine. When I bought my first saxophone I paid a local professional to try it out. The cost was the same as a lesson.

When buying any used saxophone one should budget for setup and minor repairs.

I think it is useful for a player to be able to rectify small simple problems (such as a spring coming out of its cradle or a piece of cork falling off, of G# linkage adjustment), but in my opinion, complex regulation is best left to a professional.
I am of the opinion in most things that people who cannot repair their own equipment, i.e. cars, musical instruments should probably buy new or nearly new (used sax would be okay if it has nearly new pads, and all of the leaks chased out, no missing corks or felts, no sticky keys, etc.). I say this because repairs can quickly become a money pit and you will always be at the mercy of what the shop / repairer is telling you and how long you will be without your instrument while repairs are made. As for complex regulation, that is another matter all together. IMO, for the student the dang thing either plays or it doesn't. Leaks can be chased out with with an LED leak light and hobby heat gun but fine tuning a student level instrument is probably a waste of time and money.
 
“New or nearly new” makes all the difference if someone is on a budget.

It may not be too difficult to find someone within reach who also tried to play saxophone and now wants to sell a barely used Yamaha student horn. There must be tons out there. As there is a teacher who can check it, that would be what I’d look for.

BTW, I bought a couple of saxophones over the years, new ones, vintage ones, used newer ones.

My personal favourites are mostly vintage horns, after adjustments and investments.

The newer ones all turned out really good only after the first overhaul, therefore quite nice but in the end quite expensive.

The best deal and requiring the least amount of setup were almost always the used newer ones, especially if they had been played until recently.

Maybe that’s why I would not really recommend a new horn to a beginner on a budget, only to a beginner NOT on a budget.
 
This is a well built horn. New on a budget.
 
Yes, it may be good, at least to start with and apparently these are better than they were years ago. And I agree you can hardly beat the price.

Economically it is still a “single use item”. If he decides to sell or upgrade in 1-2 years, most of the money has just disappeared. That’s the point I am trying to make.
 
This is a well built horn. New on a budget.
I have read good things about Thoman in general, and apparently their saxes are quite good.
But the OP is looking for a tenor, so he should be looking at these: Thomann Tenor Saxophones
Most of the cheapest ones are not in stock, the cheapest tenor (almost) in stock would be this one Thomann Antique Tenor Sax at € 555
 
Tenor. Doh!
Can we assume the tenor is the same quality as the alto?
They are a copy of the 62, so have all the regulating screws.
Having said that, it's twice what I paid for my used yts25, which did need a little fettling.
 
Economically it is still a “single use item”. If he decides to sell or upgrade in 1-2 years, most of the money has just disappeared. That’s the point I am trying to make.
I think it works a bit like this (but these are just my fairly rough assumptions)

  • New saxophone (with full warrantee) has private resale vale of 50% - 65% depending on desirability of brand.
  • Used saxophone from reputable dealer has private resale value of 75% - 80%. Lower due to selling on private market as buyers assumes more risk if you are not dealer.
  • Used saxophone bought privately theoretically should not drop in resale value provided decent condition assumed. But much depends on a buyer trying and being confident as opposed to buying online and assuming a risk. Or else you may have overpaid.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,673
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom