Mouthpieces New "Vintage" Series Otto Link (HR pieces, some notes)

just saxes

Member
Commercial
Messages
330
Location
Santa Cruz, CA
Is there already a thread specifically about the HR "new vintage" Otto Link tenor pieces? If so, could some one top it, or PM me a link to it (maybe someone remembers one, immediately, offhand)? I looked, I can't find one in 10 minutes or less.

I have some notes I'd like to drop here about those pieces that could be useful to others.
 
It's the New Vintage HR piece that's been out there for several years now?

I have a #7 and I like it on my Grassi Professional 2000 tenor. Much better than my regular OL Tone Edge (which sounds tubby and is less responsive).

It worked less well on my Martin. I play a Phil-Tone Eclipse on that one.
 
Yes, they have been out for a while now. I never bought any because I don't really buy/sell accessories other than to accompany horn sales. The clearances are too small (in the retail space, but...in a way also in the boutique space except for a relatively few people in refacing/design) to justify the labor and headaches (pieces come back damaged all the time, and nobody ever believes they caused the damage -- very unpleasant dynamic to have to confront over & over).

I finally did get a couple recently, because I've got some new projects & because I have more mouthpiece needs personally than I've had for a long time. Related, I have a bunch of notes that may be useful to a variety of people (refacers, dealers, players).

The easiest thing to do, as long as (I guess?) this may serve to be an info thread for these pieces, is just get started, and let context come in later (if you let me, context will take over completely, because I'm usually more interested in context than what sits within it)....

This is just a jumping off point: initial statements to get going:

- I bought two hard rubber tenor pieces, one a 7* and one an 8* from the legitimate pipeline. They're not counterfeits unless my supplier -- one of the majors -- has gone way off the deep end during the pandemo. That's not impossible, but it's highly unlikely. To me, the other outcomes make it also unlikely, because actually if these were counterfeits they probably would be finished better, ironically, given what is actually wrong with them physically.

- I should add, right away, directly after saying that, so that the takeaway matches the reality, that despite looking terrible the pieces play pretty well (more on this later, details and minutiae). They are much better than the post-90s tenor HR Links to play.

- That said, these pieces look (physically look, at a superficial glance without tools), to anybody who knows how to reface and/or rework pieces, really really bad. The baffle in both seems probably to be from the same casting/blank as it is pronouncedly skewed. This should work, long term...I actually don't have one of the pieces now, and I think I erased the original photos I took, before starting to play around with them: P.T. on Instagram: "A couple of additional details of the "Vintage" Otto Link, straight from the box, taken with effort to depict accurately. In the interest of avoiding misunderstandings, I'll try not to comment other than to say that after taking the photos I ran the table over sandpaper to see what color it came off. It came off gold/green, like one would hope, though to me the heft feela lighter than expected. I figure there are some out there, like me, who have beem curious about these without yet actually seeing one "in the wild" as one might expect it to be, buying blind."

^ some photo documention of the 8* before doing anything to it. I think I *might* have run the facing over 800 sandpaper, lightly, one time, to see what color it came off (it came off gold/green). I don't remember what piece I did that to, though I think I wrote that I did it to the 7* -- that might actually have been the 8*, I'm not 100% sure.

BUT, you can see right away how much higher the right side of the baffle is than the left. It's not subtle. The baffle is greatly higher on the right than the left (table facing up), and the same holds for the 7*, though on the 7* the left side was a little less low, i.e. at a glance it looked more even, because the left side was higher with a sort of symmetrical pinched corner as in the right side of the 8*'s baffle. There was almost a point at the outside corner of the 8*'s baffle at the transition of the rollover, and a similar but more symmetrical (side compared to opposite side) pinched area on both sides of the 7*'s baffle. Weird. I don't remember seeing an area like that -- almost a pinched point -- inside the baffle of any pieces, but I am looking at pieces much more closely these days than in the past. I guess it could be thought of as a sort of transition to a step-baffle that is/isn't there, in a way, but it is a strange feature. Anyway, once I had worked on both pieces, it was plain that the high area on the right was overall present in both pieces. This is relevant as far as notes to both players who may seek to have these pieces refaced, as well as potentially for refacers who are asked to rework these pieces but who may not have done that yet.

In advance: my overall note (as a noob) is to highlight that my finding was that where I took the high spot down further (I left the unevenness uneven, to a degree, in the 7*, but took it down in the 8*) -- and this will surprise no experienced refacers, I think, because it's the result you would expect for a noob, given how the facing/baffle/chamber/window/rails/etc. equations would shift and change in a way that a noob would not account for all at once, or that even an experienced refacer might fail to account for all in one go -- anyway, where I made the 8* look more even and presentable, I got a result that I really dislike.

OK...that said, back to the 8* and 7* and original form, notes thereof:

- the similar baffle unevenness implies the same blank. I don't remember if these were sold as "lost wax" or what the marketing was. But the Occam's Razor explanation is that, based on the time period -- one where there was kind of a "lost wax" fad, which (not unwisely?) continues today in a more "granular" fashion -- probably the blank is in fact from some player's treasured vintage (real vintage) Slant sig Link. I think this is actually explicitly stated, somewhere, in Otto Link marketing materials, but just saying that's what it is doesn't mean it's true. My point is that the unevenness of the baffle tends to suggest it actually IS a casting/reproduction of an actual piece -- maybe even a reworked one -- because if they worked from scratch the result probably wouldn't be a blank that is so uneven in the baffle, with one side so much higher than the other. If you look at that Instagram link, the appearance is not deceiving. The baffle in the 8* really is that uneven.
You can also get an idea of how uneven the baffle is from looking at the pics here: P.T. on Instagram: "The hideous one wins. #newslantsigs #notesofanoob (Follow up details in a sec)"

The second pic is the reworked 7*, and the baffle is *still* high -- and the rails as well have already been thinned (more on this in a moment) from original, even though they are still probably a little wider than the 8* overall) -- and despite that the baffle is still high, and has been filed on as much as it looks like it has, the left side's shininess is original, i.e. I did not polish that side. That side is smooth/black/shiny because it was not touched, and it is that much lower than the right side that even after lots of filing the right side remains that much higher.

- Rails. In that same last Insta post, above, the 8* is yet untouched. As original, the 7*'s rails were probably almost a full 1/3 wider near the heel of the window than the 8*. To me, intuitively, that makes sense. The 7* is a sort of the size 10-10.5 shoe of the tenor Link sizings -- not too large that a beginner can't grow into it, not so small that a skilled player cannot feel like they have room to inflect/articulate/pronunciate/express. It makes sense to me that that "middleground" type of piece would have thicker rails for a more predictable response, requiring less care in placing/situating the reed, being possibly more tolerant of more reeds, trading less subtle response for more predictable response, especially in low notes where subtone and the complexity of how players play subtone may matter less than it will for more advanced players who seek larger openings.

[OK...pausing here for now...more notes to come, main points to come...TDLR, I know, but I don't see where any of these topics don't matter, or aren't useful to someone later....]
 
Last edited:
I bought one when they first became available here (Europe). I can't check now, but I wonder if it was always so uneven, or if they became worse down the production run.
 
Please post pics when you can! Seriously: will be instructive.

Here are some for the Insta posts linked above, in case people can't see them:

7* Link, after being reworked:
7stbafftop.webp
7stbafffront.webp


(Good place to add: what looks horrible about the reface isn't limited to the baffle -- rails are a mess as well. Will explain that later.)

8* baffle, as original:
8stfrontbaff.webp
 
Huh...can you do a video (15 sec or less) tipping it up and down slowly so the whole baffle can be seen? Is that a giant ask? Yours looks better, and quite different but it could be the angles. The bottom picture looks like there could be unevenness that the angle isn't revealing, the top looks just fine. As you can see from the photos of my order, it's possible there is a big difference.

That said, what is next to add: these pieces, the ones I ordered, actually played pretty well. I put the glass gauge on them, and I think I only had 5 feelers then (now I have more, and recognize you can't have too many) and the facing was surprisingly even. I expected it to be off because not only were the unevenness and weird shapes within the baffle immediately obvious to me, but the rails (side and tip) were kind of sloppy/wavy/not clean. But the facings measured out a lot like some of the better Links I've played, and the curves were even side-to-side.

They played somewhat like one might guess, from the differences in the rails (slim on the 8*, or toward boutique on the 8*, and fat and wide on the 7*). The 7* had a wider core, while being mostly mids, and it had more resistance than the 8*, such that for me the resistance was almost the same, with the same reed. The 8* then (per opening size, both of which were accurate to within .001 of their rating...I think both were .001 lower than marked at .104 and .114, the way I measure) was less resistant. It also just had a freer, more expressive (more flexible tone/articulation/pitch center) and a more open, less core-heavy tone. This is what I would expect from the rail difference, with it being pronounced and almost exaggerated, and it makes sense to me for the 7* to be designed that way, again, because of the wider swath of players that sizing is apt to serve (no beginners should probably be started on an 8*, but arguably they can be started on a 7* -- some will agree some will not). But a Link 7* is sort of the mean sizing for an intermediate to step up to, from a smaller opening that is less expensive and less responsive as in the past (in the near future, with 3D printing, that expectation can change, as it already is, really).

So both pieces played well, for how bad they looked. They subtoned well, had a full voice, nothing was especially difficult to articulate and the scales were reasonably even. They were workable pieces, even good playing pieces. But not special.

What would have made the 7* special: to have a more subtle balance, a freer and more expressive and open core rather than a fuller more "blatty" one, and some spooky bottom end resonance, which I think is something most of us who seek Links (and for that matter NY Meyers) want -- an outside envelope to the sound that makes the hair on the back of your head stand up and your spine tingle.

The 8* was to me, better. It didn't need any particular work. Anyway, because it was better, it made more sense to experiment with the 7*. I had two goals: if I'm lucky, to come up with a piece for C-melody (for straightnecked Conn) by accident, and then the main one of just making a piece that I like for myself, or that someone else who likes Links might like.

Oh: one more major flaw that came up as I went: the window was not centered -- it was off to one side, the whole window. This was revealed during refacing. The table on one also was pretty far from flat. I don't remember now is they had concavities in the center of the table (often stock pieces do) -- I will have to check. At this stage in my learning, if there is a concavity that is exaggerated, I will usually leave some of it. I think these were both clearly meant to be flat, but I could be misremembering. I do remember one was uneven front and back of the table versus the center. Memory says the entire center portion of the table was low.

OK...all that said, what I did to the 7*:

- flatten the table
- begin taking down the high area in corner of the baffle rollover, reduce (without completely removing) the pinched peak in that corner
- return tip opening to .105, with the goal of erring over .105 if erring, but not by much, touch up slight unevenness in facing, match numbers to some that I have in notes that I liked on other pieces
- begin thinning the rails, especially closer to the heel of the window, but overall
- file under the heel of the window, removing material
- reshape tip rail, rough improvement of
- playtest: I liked all these changes
- so: more of each, and I ended up with low notes that weren't quite speaking as easily or freely as I'd like, so I went further with the rear rails and discovered that the window -- the whole window -- was off to one side. I did my best to even that up, in effect enlarging the window (also being aware of it, I revisted the underneath area of the heel of the window, looking for a flowy round feeling and thinner transition into the chamber, there, overall
- playtest (on SBA first, for a baseline, then also on Couf Superba because I do not have a piece that I like on the Couf -- more on this in a sec, as that is a primary reason for this post)
- revisit rails, sidewalls, tip rail transition, baffle, all of it
- playtest, rinse repeat.

A terrible thing happened at the point where the piece reached the hideous appearance it has now. I had only filed the baffle with rougher jeweler's files (exactly as the existing marks would suggest), and after working the baffle and the refacing passes leaving the facing in the ugly state it's in now (but sealing well with poptest, and even on the gauges at the numbers I want), the piece is too good to risk changing.

And I just remembered another minus on the 7*: its lower range was not even with its midrange. It got suddenly and noticeably phoofy -- dark, airy, all bottom end but not in a way that had presence, from about low E down -- it was not a good thing, it was unevenness that I doubt anybody would specifically like. I sure didn't. But the process above took care of that. The scale evened out, and -- this may seem paradoxical -- the bottom end gained a broad outer envelope, the kind of spooky I'm looking for in the bottom end of "magic" vintage Links for tenor and NY Meyers for alto. It's hard to describe, but if you have experienced it you know what I mean.

In its current, hideous state, the 7* is even, easy to play in high notes (if it has a flaw, it is that the baffle may be a bit high right behind the tip rail, making high notes a little more pinched/thin than ideal, though they speak clearly and ringingly and easily -- G3 is especially easy, compared to most Links and Link-like pieces, certainly easier on all my current tenors than any Link-based piece I have now), and it gives the Couf, which tends to be too bright, an open feel and balance that the Couf needs.

[more in a sec]
 
That is one thing I specifically wanted to drop, here, about this model: that if you alter it to get a deeper bottom end, it can be a really nice match to horns that have a hot (orange/red) core but that are lacking weight in the lower end and bottom partials. More expert mouthpiece makers than me can confirm or deny, but I think it's because of all the changes, but primarily removing material from the lower and to lesser extent mid-baffle, touching up the ceiling at the heel of the table, widening the window (and very slightly lengthening it), and redistributing/thinning the rails. I might be thinking about selling the Couf if I did not have this piece for it. Instead, I want to play the Couf a lot. I probably like playing it more than my SBA or new Martin Committee, despite that I don't sound best on it and it isn't the easiest of the 3 to play in tune.

That is most of the notes. TDLR version: these pieces, as I got them from the distributor, looked bad but played surprisingly well, but not so well that I would recommend or take them over better boutique pieces at a higher price. BUT, after refacing the 7*, I don't have any pieces by anybody (including much better refacers than me -- I am a know-nothing noob, which is why I'm enthusiastic about sharing findings) that made me want to keep the Couf and play it more than any other horn, which hints at a lot of promise for these pieces as blanks to be sent to your most sympathetic refacer.

Ah OK: the last thing -- much shorter to explain, note: for the 8*, now that I was happy with the 7*, I took the baffle all the way to even, just to see what I would end up with if that was my starting point. The piece looks good now. It plays terrible. It has no character, it lacks the bottom end skin, there is no sparkle or crackle, though the facing numbers match the 7*. I'm guessing if I change the window (I didn't do that on the 8* as on the 7*, because I didn't change the facing much, in part because I did not need to change the rails as much) that may help. But the piece looks better -- people would think "Oh, that's a lot of progress, good job," on Instagram, from pictures -- but it sucks, now.

Other last thing: a primary reason for posting this: my personal quest is to come up with good designs I can use and maybe even work from as blanks in the future. To Otto Link's credit, for me their pieces aren't really workable for that because so far the only good results I get are with a piece that physically (separate from the bad finishing that I did, and primarily related to the baffle), to me, isn't presentable. But that has nothing to do with the pieces' viability for use, or promise if refaced just to a point of happiness, possibly without regard for looks or technical "correctness." Correct would be an even baffle. If I made the 7* baffle even, I wouldn't want it any more, not without totally remaking the piece again. It's great now, as it is, with the uneven baffle and the hideous appearance.

I haven't really kept a new tenor piece for myself that I actually intend to play in over 10 years, probably 15 years. Pretty cool. And in a piece that I not only don't want to sell, but that I wouldn't put my name on if I did, because of the possible consquences. Also cool.
 
So nobody misunderstands: I don't expect anybody to read all that, or think that I'm more important than others because I took up a lot of space there. I want to be one & done with this info. It's all there for anybody else who might be curious/interested in the future, maybe years from now. It's what I would have loved to have been able to read, and make up my own mind about, if it were here before I posted it.

Do want more views of that baffle, JT!
 
Would have posted this earlier, but didn't have permission yet: a friend/client has the 7* now. He sent me a couple of files of him playing it -- really nice to get the feedback. I can't post vids here, I don't think. Instagram only let me put up one, in this post, because the one with the high notes is apparently too long for a multi-vid post.


If any Santa Cruz people happen to be seeing this, John's playing this Friday 5-8 at the New Bohemia Brewing Co on 41st Ave. He's playing a Borgani unlacquered tenor in the post/file.
 
You keep commenting on how bad the piece looks. Are you not going to clean it up and polish it? Maybe I missed something.

My own OL "New Vintage Series" mouthpiece looks better than my regular Tone Edge (which is not a great mouthpiece), and certainly plays a lot better too.

I made the video that Just Saxes requested, but it is over 30 MB, so I cannot include it as an attachment here. From looking at my mouthpiece, my impression is that the baffle is fine. Again, mine is an early one; maybe something happened to the Otto Link molds over time? (I have no idea)
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,678
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom