Tech/maintenance New Springs for a Martin Medalist Alto

My understanding is that any burnishing or "improving" of internal surfaces is likely have an effect, but not necessarily an improvement. I know it isn't the same but I remember Curt Altarac mentioning that the PPT chamber appeared too perfect, that the uniformity and smoothness might be improved by being less burnished. Maybe he was just joshing me I don't know but I do know that whistle makers set great store by introducing perturbations into the bore.

So what I'm getting at is there needn't be a correlation between cosmetic perfection and acoustic perfection. Making something burnished, smoother, more symmetrical, might improve things or it might make them worse.


I find this difficult to fathom out. Are you saying they actually nobbled it in order to call it student and so hopefully sell more pro models. Sounds very dodgy. Like we saw in another thread where it was mentioned Selmer de-qualitised the S80 mouthpiece in 2013 ing order to sell more expensive models.

But what I'm getting at is that cosmetic perfection
Smaller neck bore saxes are a little easier to control tuning wise (I find the yani 991 neck harder tuning wise, whereas the 901 is narrower bore and easier to control - It could be that Martin restricted the bore for similar reasons on the so called "Student" model. Manufacturing has a history of restricting entry level products 🙁 we'll never know for sure though with Martin. Obviously I should have quoted my above assertion 😛 I think it was a (insert expletive) idea from them though.
 
Last edited:
Manufacturing has a history of restricting entry level products
Of course, but I would still have doubts about what amounts to nobbling the neck just to make it student. ie they intentionally put something there they knew was worse, and wasn't actually cheaper for them to do it like that.

But maybe they did.

Interesting parallel now with car manufacturers who obviously do basic and premium models with walnut dash, leather seats, alloy wheels etc. as we all know. But it now seems vehicles are equipped with certain electric features such as heated seats on Beemers which actually have the function in place on basic models, but you then subsequently pay (by subscription) to unlock the features. It probably makes sound economical sense due to consistency of manufacture and adaptability of stock, dealers can offer a vehicle with or without and only need the one vehicle in stock. Clever idea.

Maybe that will happen to saxophones. "pay a subscription and suddenly your saxophone will play more in tune and the sound will open up"
 
Last edited:
That's sounds awful

...going back to the action... the G# key is the other issue i have, look at it compared with my yani, its almost at 90 degrees - thinking large triangular wedge of milliput on there...as I keep missing it. Not sure if bending key will help much
20230321_113241.jpg
 
Last edited:
Of course, but I would still have doubts about what amounts to nobbling the neck just to make it student. ie they intentionally put something there they knew was worse, and wasn't actually cheaper for them to do it like that.

But maybe they did.

Well, Pentax did the same in the past with the Takumar 55mm lenses. The difference between the f/1.8 and cheaper f/2 lenses was a metal ring that limited how much light was let in at the maximum aperture.

So ironically the cheaper lens had an extra part.
 
OK milliput here we go. You can see what I'm trying to do with g# key....IF its worse going to be a pig to remove. Actually think I may probably want to build up some more...not pretty...but what were u saying about relationship between cosmetics and sound @Pete Thomas 😀
milliput.jpg
 
but what were u saying about relationship between cosmetics and sound @Pete Thomas 😀

I didn't say that there was or that there wasn't.

So what I'm getting at is there needn't be a correlation between cosmetic perfection and acoustic perfection.
In other words there might be or there might not be.
 
1) The big steps in the bore at the tenon area are common on many saxophones. I think Ockham's razor would suggest you ascribe these to manufacturing cost rather than to any intentional design choices.

2) You're comparing the left hand actions of two horns wiith fundamentally different mechanical designs of the bell keys. The more recent, Selmer-style mechanism has the pivot to the right of the keys if you are looking down on the horn from above in playing position. Wiht this design, the little finger is using its clamping motion to close the keys, similar to the other three fingers. The older mechanism has the pivot to the left of the keys. Because there would be no leverage if you tried to tuck the pivot under the knuckles of the left hand, the keys are located almost perpendicular to the last joint of the little finger, so the finger exerts a pushing action.

You are not going to be able to add angled pieces of stuff to keys to convert one to the other. All you'll end up doing is shortening the effective lever arm of the keys and increasing actuation force. You have to learn how to play the older horn the way it was designed to be played. Look at your first picture. The direction of view is pretty close to perpendicular to the stack keys on both horns. On the left, the low B key has a lever armd of an inch or a bit more. Now I happen to know that if you rotated the horn on the right 90 degrees, the lever arm on that low B is also about an inch. But the way you're showing it, the direction from which you want to press the key, the pivot is RIGHT BEHIND the place where you want to press - i.e., near zero lever arm, near zero mechanical advantage. You'll never be able to get the key closed without excessive force if you bend the key or add material. You have to learn how to play that horn the way it's designed.

Now if you're willing to learn how to finger the left hand little finger keys on that old Martin, I'll let you in on a little secret: the old layout is actually BETTER. The modern layout requires the little finger to arch over the C# key to reach the B (which is why almost all the tilting-low-Bb-key horns have a "C# helper" arm that closes the C# when you play B, because otherwise it's darn near impossible to avoid opening C# when you play B). Unless you have particularly long fingers, you end up needing the little finger to become longer and shorter, which of course it can't do, so you have to constantly move your hand out of position to reach low B and then again to get back to C#. Secondly, the location of the Bb below (meaning, closer to the floor when the horn's in playing position) requires you to use the little finger in its weakest direction - to be holding down the B key and then simultaneously slide it DOWN, away from the other fingers, to press the Bb. That's why so many modern horns have the tilting low Bb, which in theory (the French love to design things to a theory, see Citroen DS) will make it easier to make that sideways slide. Of course, then the tilting low Bb adds slop and flex to the mechanism and it falls away from your finger just when you want that weak finger, extended out from the side of your hand and trying to push in two directions at once, to press on a firm positive short-travel key. Instead it gets a mushy key whose angle is changing while you press on it and the bottom of whose travel is never quite clear.

By contrast, the older style little finger keys are dead easy to play. You don't try to pull on the keys, you push on them, The little finger is strong when applying force along its length. To move from one key to the next, you simply pivot the finger about its big knuckle. All the keys are right there, at about the same distance from your big knuckle, so the finger doesn't have to extend and retract. The key action is short, stiff, and positive. You don't need the C# helper, because your little finger doesn't have to reach over the C# touch at a low angle; it's at almost 90 degrees to it so you can easily touch the low B without the lower joints of your finger inadvertently pressing on C#.

The only negative of the old style key layout is that the key forces are higher; but the finger's being used in a stronger direction. And the key travel is less.
 
Well, Pentax did the same in the past with the Takumar 55mm lenses. The difference between the f/1.8 and cheaper f/2 lenses was a metal ring that limited how much light was let in at the maximum aperture.

So ironically the cheaper lens had an extra part.
good example that. Things like this prevail in IT industry also, recently Apple were taken to court over new software that was made to run slower in older phones so people bought new ones. Early PCs 286, 386, 486 etc. were quite often staged releases...I know as went out and bought a new 386 whereas they had already developed the 486 🙂 crafty buggers. Its called planned obsolescence.

Its not extra metal or feature on the neck, its a massively under-size tenon that causes the restriction and large edge, pretty sloppy tbh. I have taken feeler gauge measurements of receiver and tenon, will publish photos later, the outside of tenon is around 23.6mm, average newer necks are around 24.5mm, so quite a difference.
 
Last edited:
1) The big steps in the bore at the tenon area are common on many saxophones. I think Ockham's razor would suggest you ascribe these to manufacturing cost rather than to any intentional design choices.

2) You're comparing the left hand actions of two horns wiith fundamentally different mechanical designs of the bell keys. The more recent, Selmer-style mechanism has the pivot to the right of the keys if you are looking down on the horn from above in playing position. Wiht this design, the little finger is using its clamping motion to close the keys, similar to the other three fingers. The older mechanism has the pivot to the left of the keys. Because there would be no leverage if you tried to tuck the pivot under the knuckles of the left hand, the keys are located almost perpendicular to the last joint of the little finger, so the finger exerts a pushing action.

You are not going to be able to add angled pieces of stuff to keys to convert one to the other. All you'll end up doing is shortening the effective lever arm of the keys and increasing actuation force. You have to learn how to play the older horn the way it was designed to be played. Look at your first picture. The direction of view is pretty close to perpendicular to the stack keys on both horns. On the left, the low B key has a lever armd of an inch or a bit more. Now I happen to know that if you rotated the horn on the right 90 degrees, the lever arm on that low B is also about an inch. But the way you're showing it, the direction from which you want to press the key, the pivot is RIGHT BEHIND the place where you want to press - i.e., near zero lever arm, near zero mechanical advantage. You'll never be able to get the key closed without excessive force if you bend the key or add material. You have to learn how to play that horn the way it's designed.

Now if you're willing to learn how to finger the left hand little finger keys on that old Martin, I'll let you in on a little secret: the old layout is actually BETTER. The modern layout requires the little finger to arch over the C# key to reach the B (which is why almost all the tilting-low-Bb-key horns have a "C# helper" arm that closes the C# when you play B, because otherwise it's darn near impossible to avoid opening C# when you play B). Unless you have particularly long fingers, you end up needing the little finger to become longer and shorter, which of course it can't do, so you have to constantly move your hand out of position to reach low B and then again to get back to C#. Secondly, the location of the Bb below (meaning, closer to the floor when the horn's in playing position) requires you to use the little finger in its weakest direction - to be holding down the B key and then simultaneously slide it DOWN, away from the other fingers, to press the Bb. That's why so many modern horns have the tilting low Bb, which in theory (the French love to design things to a theory, see Citroen DS) will make it easier to make that sideways slide. Of course, then the tilting low Bb adds slop and flex to the mechanism and it falls away from your finger just when you want that weak finger, extended out from the side of your hand and trying to push in two directions at once, to press on a firm positive short-travel key. Instead it gets a mushy key whose angle is changing while you press on it and the bottom of whose travel is never quite clear.

By contrast, the older style little finger keys are dead easy to play. You don't try to pull on the keys, you push on them, The little finger is strong when applying force along its length. To move from one key to the next, you simply pivot the finger about its big knuckle. All the keys are right there, at about the same distance from your big knuckle, so the finger doesn't have to extend and retract. The key action is short, stiff, and positive. You don't need the C# helper, because your little finger doesn't have to reach over the C# touch at a low angle; it's at almost 90 degrees to it so you can easily touch the low B without the lower joints of your finger inadvertently pressing on C#.

The only negative of the old style key layout is that the key forces are higher; but the finger's being used in a stronger direction. And the key travel is less.
Well you're right about that, it doesn't pivot very well. Removed before dried... 😀 Will try to process what you're saying above.

I like the left-hand low notes where they are atm, they feel ok and easy to play, but G# gets used way more than these, in faster passages. My hand is at right angles to keys (which i think they should be - I think some people hold them at a downward angle ), and my pinky seems to hit the edge of the G# a lot which results in a delayed or missed G#.
 
Here's the gist of the other thread. Rather than dismiss it as B*llocks I thought might be something in it, it did seem to mostly match my experience when my horn arrived, with exception of tuning points, mine plays as well in tune now as my yani, but I did alter some key heights to get this!
...snip....
This is interesting stuff...except having done over 200 refurbs on Martins, I don't agree with a some of it. Indianas lack projection ? Hardly...in my experience, they are significantly edgier with more 'cut' to their tone than the Committees.

A Medalist and an Indiana...are the same horns. Same specs.

I am guessing this was written by Lance from MartinMods...the guy who produced and sold both the 'conical tenon' and the 'non-protruding octave pips' as products of his.
Something to take into account...

Not saying it's all BS, just saying that the excerpt reads a bit like an advertisement.

Regarding the late Imperial...I am with Pete on this one...why would a company intentionally spec a neck tenon to play with more resistance on a model which was intended to be their base/student model ?
This actually runs counter to what Conn, Buescher, King, Holton, etc did...which was make their base models quite free-blowing and user friendly in that category.

More likely they thought the neck spec change offered something...and it turned out, it didn't. Heck, that's not that unusual... even Selmer made that mistake in their history...or maybe they just needed to produce something more cheaply or to be not a clone in tone to the Indiana ? Which they succeeded in, but not in a good way ...

The Imperial is a strange one...it is claimed that it was produced concurrently with the Indiana, and it has a lot of Indiana specs (I can use an Imperial as a parts hor to fill in a lot of missing pieces on an Indiana, with no modifications required, for example) ...but is just an inferior horn in tone and key action....and it survived as the last Martin base model while the Indiana went extinct several years before it.
(I am gonna assume rather than there being some highfalutin' reason for this - it was simply because as Martin was fading and kept switching owners, the Imperial was cheaper to produce thus they kept it)...but I am not certain what its intention ever was while it existed alongside the better Indiana.
That the Medalist may also have been offered during the same period, thus overlap of Indiana, Medalist, and Imperial....is also head-scratching and I am not sure anyone has really definitively determined if they all REALLY overlapped like that. Indianas had theoir own serial sequence, yet Imperials and Medalists are assumed to have the Martin serial sequence.
This may be an incorrect assumption.
I have been told companies did sell the same model under two different model designations back then for legal reasons (?)...but not sure about this....

I certainly agree with you...the tonality and blowing feel of the Imperial always left something to be desired...so if you think you found a mod which improved that, and I will buy that your mod improved that....I applaud your discovery.
 
Last edited:
This is interesting stuff...except having done over 200 refurbs on Martins, I don't agree with a fair amount of it. Indianas lack projection ? Hardly...in my experience, they are significantly edgier with more 'cut' to their tone than the Committees.

I am guessing this was written by Lance from MartinMods...the guy who produced and sold both the 'conical tenon' and the 'non-protruding octave pips' as products of his.
Something to take into account...

Not saying it's all BS, just saying that the excerpt reads a bit like an advertisement.

Regarding the late Imperial...I am with Pete on this one...why would a company intentionally spec a neck tenon to play with more resistance on a model which was intended to be their base/student model ?
This actually runs counter to what Conn, Buescher, King, Holton, etc did...which was make their base models quite free-blowing and user friendly in that category.

The Imperial is a strange one...it is claimed that it was produced concurrently with the Indiana, and it has a lot of Indiana specs (I can use an Imperial as a parts hor to fill in a lot of missing pieces on an Indiana, with no modifications required, for example) ...but is just an inferior horn in tone and key action....and it survived as the last Martin base model while the Indiana went extinct several years before it.
(I am gonna assume rather than there being some highfalutin' reason for this - it was simply because as Martin was fading and kept switching owners, the Imperial was cheaper to produce thus they kept it)...but I am not certain what its intention ever was while it existed alongside the better Indiana.

I certainly agree with you...the tonality and blowing feel of the Imperial left something to be desired...so if you think you found a mod which improved that, I applaud that.
thanks for this. "Imperial" being synonymous with "Medalist"? Mine's a medalist. I thought Imperial was older no? Interesting what you say about Indiana vs Medalist. I thought the Indiana was the little brother / student model of the Committee III?
I'll try do a side by side comparison of my 902 yani vs martin, maybe on a separate thread. To me, and my friend that tried it, the Martin is both louder and darker, particularly rich at the bottom now, and there's a tonehole or two not level! Will get to that later...
Now I think I want to get a committee III (The Martin). Just seen this, pretty sure its The Martin...look at neck and left hand section... could be a fun re-pad project? What do you think: The Martin Alto Committee? Alto Saxophone 1948 | eBay
 
Last edited:
That's sounds awful

...going back to the action... the G# key is the other issue i have, look at it compared with my yani, its almost at 90 degrees - thinking large triangular wedge of milliput on there...as I keep missing it. Not sure if bending key will help much
One of the basic differences between modern and vintage keywork, it's just a matter of what one likes/is used to.

For me, the G# on a modern-table horn...is way too CLOSE to the stack G touch. I often have to bend the G touch out of factory-intended location so I don't keep hitting the G# by accident.

That one may be 'better' than the other ...is sorta subjective, IMHO. Some modern tables are located such that this situation doesn't happen for me....
 
Hardly...in my experience, they are significantly edgier with more 'cut' to their tone than the Committees.
A late Martin Handcraft (Committee) and Martin Handcraft Comm II are very "cutting" and "punchy". Just four models of "Committees" were made: Martin Handcraft, Martin Handcraft Comm II, Martin Centennial and "The Martin XXXXX (Magna). I think there is a big difference between a Committee sax and other Martin made saxes.
 
thanks for this. "Imperial" being synonymous with "Medalist"? I thought Imperial was older no? Interesting what you say about Indiana vs Medalist. I thought the Indiana was the little brother / student model of the Committee III?
Not sure you were referring to me here (?)...I never said the Imperial and Medalist were synonymous.
I noted that (TheMartinStory site, specifically) claims they were produced/offered during the same period...this, I am gonna doubt a bit and there is info on that site which is great, and some which is inaccurate and has never been revised.

Medalists and Indianas are the same horn design, again. Imperial seems a dumbed-down Indiana...but the intent of that ? Not sure, but I think the hypothesis of 'to make the Imperial worse'...is debatable....

Comm III has a completely different body tube, bow, bell, and neck tube than an Indiana. So the Committees, all three versions, ARE different beasts from Indianas.

It has been said that Indianas are old Handcraft body specs. I will not contradict that as I never measured up a Handcraft and compared it to an Indiana. Might be so...but something changed (neck, at least ?) because an old Handcraft and an Indiana do not have the same tonalities....
 
A late Martin Handcraft (Committee) and Martin Handcraft Comm II are very "cutting" and "punchy". Just four models of "Committees" were made: Martin Handcraft, Martin Handcraft Comm II, Martin Centennial and "The Martin XXXXX (Magna). I think there is a big difference between a Committee sax and other Martin made saxes.
Yes, all Martins are cutting and punchy. But the Indiana doesn't have the darkness and spread of the Committees, IMHO.

It was the excerpt from Lance's comment I was addressing there, it claimed:


"The Indiana, which is acoustically a Handcraft without the trill Eb, has a very nice, complex, and sophisticated core to it's tone, which reminds me of a nice Mk6, SBA, or Balance Action, but, it lacks projection, dynamic range, and cutting edge highs at louder dynamic level attacks. I have the impression of hearing the core through a fog of cotton fibers that surrounds every note".


I find that a bit silly, honestly...in describing an Indianas tonality and blowing response, I would never characterize it the way he did.

That was my point, really.
 
I thought the point of playing a vintage horn was to play a vintage horn and enjoy owning it.

Butchering a survivor, to make it more modern, sort of misses the point imo, and removes one more survivor from the diminishing pool of originals.

It's only original once and modifications to personal specifications reduce its monetary value and saleability. imo.
 
Now I think I want to get a committee III (The Martin). Just seen this, pretty sure its The Martin...look at neck and left hand section... could be a fun re-pad project? What do you think: The Martin Alto Committee? Alto Saxophone 1948 | eBay
III's are different beasts entirely. IF you think you have an idea of what Martins are all about based upon an Indiana or late Imperial, the III will blow your socks off. I like Indianas a lot, the II again is something unto its own.

This one is overpriced by $150 really...will need more than just a repad. Full thorough chem cleaning for sure, likely key swedging additionally. I'd imagine it isn't gonna sell fast.
 
III's are different beasts entirely. IF you think you have an idea of what Martins are all about based upon an Indiana or late Imperial, the III will blow your socks off. I like Indianas a lot, the II again is something unto its own.

This one is overpriced by $150 really...will need more than just a repad. Full thorough chem cleaning for sure, likely key swedging additionally. I'd imagine it isn't gonna sell fast.
yeah I was thinking offering £100 less, that would be worth a punt and a fun project. I did have The Martin tenor and played for many a year, cracking sax! Couple years ago I got an unlacquered used T992 which just felt so good and easy to play with sound to match. Sound wise it was similar richness to The Martin at the mid range to bottom, but the Martin was darker and richer at the top with more resistance. Have a ref 54 neck and actual Mark 6 neck on the yani tenor now which have improved the sound somewhat, particularly control and feels a shade more resistance. Not even played a mark 6 that could match The Martin note for note, If the alto is good, then worth a punt...its just the friggin ergos on the older saxes, like driving a vintage car vs modern I suppose (I'm now a TVR Griff and a BMW owner 🙂). TVR wins for fun and noise, but nightmare taking round town and not very reliable so BMW gets the most use and keeps the misses happy.
 
Ah yes, the old thing "ergonomics of older horns". Put in some time in the shed, learning how to play them the way they were designed, and those issues will disappear.

Last time I checked, each of us was issued at birth 16 multi-degree-of-freedom joints at the end of each arm allowing us to place our fingers on, and actuate, keys of a wide variety of musical instruments. In a world that contains double-basses, violas, bassoons, sousaphones, and trombones, complaining about the "bad ergonomics" of the most ergonomically accurate instrument out there, with its superior adjustability and all its weight taken by a wide padded neck strap, strikes me as whingeing about something a few dozen hours would accustom one to.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,611
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom