Saxophones New sax questions

Makes sense, plus when I started with alto, I was trying to blow it like a tenor. Took a long time to get used to it.

And thinking about it, I was playing with a couple of altos recently, blown by kids. I couldn't hear them over the tenor.... I think most of them were using Yamaha mouthpieces (it's about all that gets recommended here) and I'd guess they were 4c. One guy had just traded up from a YAS 275 to a Hohner President, didn't notice what mouthpiece he was using. But I could easily hear the leader/music teacher on his Yani alto, as well as the clarinets.
 
I do think that equipment does play its part. I have been playing my tenor with various mouthpieces and reeds. The harder the reed the louder the sound, partly as I have to blow harder to produce one. I would recommend trying some noticeably soft reeds to see whather they allow/encourage quieter playing - such a a Rico Jazz Select 2S filed or Marca Jazz 2 reed. I don't think I've ever really found a soft Vandoren reed. Similarly some mouthpieces are too small IMO to be able to play quietly - as the tip opening is not unlike using a pea shooter. Commonly we think of Large tip openings as loud mouthpieces (depends on how much air we put through them, of course), but I would say that too small can be loud as well. Ideally we find a tip opening which is "just right", and reeds which are just right also.

Playing quietly does naturally develop as your embouchure develops. At the same time we can adjust our equipment sufficiently to aid this process IMO - so at the very least try some good quality soft reeds, and play them after soaking for a while first, so thay play more flexibly.
 
Recent experience: When I play on with my Legere Signature #2.5, I use about ~60dB gain when recording. I recently tried a Bari Medium, and I needed to back off my preamp to roughly 55db-ish so that it doesn't clip. It was really much louder to my ears as well.

This was with a Hanson SA5 with Vandoren V5 A27. So er.... different reed brands also make a difference in volume?
 
Is there a simple way to mute a sax? When I start I would like to be able to limit the damage to neighbours and family.

Hi There!

Commonly 3 themes emerge on this topic.

1. Negotiate with neighbours etc. openly - and stick to certain defined times (when they are at work etc.) They may not mind, may be musicians. They will appreciate your openness and know that it is not likely to occur endlessly, without warning.

2. Mute the sound by where you play in the house. Best to play facing an internal or non party wall, or play into a damped area (such as facing the airing cupboard or open wardrobe where sound can be absorbed). For example playing towards the hallway etc. may mean playing into 2 or 3 doors, which will provide some sound absorption, or playing pointing away from people can be helpful.

3. Actual Sax mutes are not that highly thought of (be they cheaper sponge like material to stick in the bell or ridiculously costly bags that will cover the whole sax, apart from places to put hands on sax. General advice would be to occasionally play with a sock over the bell or place a scruched up teatowel a few inches down the bell if/when necessary. It may not help your sound/tone but will reduce volume by a certain percentage.

All these are variously recommended on Sax On The Web (SOTW) but preference is given to the first 2 points.
 
Is there a simple way to mute a sax? When I start I would like to be able to limit the damage to neighbours and family.

I thought that since we live in a detached house, I was probably not heard by the neighbours. Recently, we were visiting the lady next door but one (also a detached house) when she commented (positively) on my playing :shocked:

I now hate to think how much neighbours in semi / terraced houses can hear :w00t:
 
It's not only the sax that's noisy...













My neighbours also have to put up with drums, clarinet..... & I have to put up with their accordian, guitar and viola. Probably explains why one of the others (no instrument household) slams his garage door so loudly every night. His only chance of revenge.
 
My neighbours also have to put up with drums, clarinet..... & I have to put up with their accordian, guitar and viola. Probably explains why one of the others (no instrument household) slams his garage door so loudly every night. His only chance of revenge.

I can't imagine the viola being much of a problem, unless it's been electrified.

(Obligatory viola joke: What's the difference between a seamstress and a viola player. The seamstress tucks up frills...

Apologies for the sexist assumption, but I don't think there's a gender-neutral term)
 
I know I can be heard by people passing in the street by the speeded up walk and the frightened looks.
A few weeks ago a few children went past and a girl stopped at the gate, when I stopped playing she clapped and shouted 'bravo, well done'. As I was playing Coltrane and she was about eight she had a well developed sense of either musical appreciation or sarcasm.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,628
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom