Saxophones New sax questions

1) My budget will be around £450-£500. Is this a reasonable budget for a second hand instrument?

2) Is it a reasonable budget for a NEW alto? I am thinking of brands like the Trevor James classic horn - would that make a good starter horn or would it just frustrate me?

It's definitely a reasonable budget for second hand, but you need to be cautious about the condition, especially if going the ebay route.

I'm not too keen on the cheaper TJ horns, but I will second the recommendations for Bauhaus walstein.

Hi Pete

Welcome to the cafe, can I suggest you introduce yourself on the Doorbell section of the forum, you may get more response on there.🙂

Yes, it's definitely a good idea to introduce yourself there, but this is actually the correct forum to be asking saxophone questions.
 
....whereas alto players are less insecure in their identity and can concentrate on the more challenging aspects of their instrument...................;}

...and those who play all the saxes can disdain this argument in its entirety, knowing that all saxes are born equal. That said, there are far too many beginners who start on alto, and then feel they need to move on to something else - and end up playing the ever-popular tenor. As a consequence, at any jam session I've been to, there's an overwhelming majority of sax-players holding a tenor. Which is tedious.:shocked:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Forgive us Zebrafoot. It is just good humoured joshing.

Whatever turns you on, whether it is the sound or the feel and size of the instrument that appeals to you, that is so important. That nice Mr Thomas's information is worthwhile as he can blow most of us into the weeds, whatever sax he picks up. Mind you, he has a wicked sense of humour too, as I've found out to my cost.

Each to their own and ENJOY!™
 
One consequence of most people starting out (as I did) on alto is that there always seem to be a lot more alto players around, at least at my fairly low level of competence. If you want to play in bands you may find yourself more in demand as a tenor player. I play alto, tenor and sop now and love all three. My favourite (if any) may well be alto, but the tenor is the one that I play most outside the house, so that's the one I practice most and have my lessons on.
 
Time and time again the Trevor James horns are put down on this forum and yet the Bauhaus Walstein aways gets recommendations :verysad :confused2:

I've rarely seen TJ horns put down, they seem to have quite a solid reputation. But I do believe you get better value with the bauhaus.

I think Stephen Howard has some very good things to say about Trevor james though.
 
I am aware of the Trevor James thread that you started on SOTW on 24-12-2008 (or 12-24-2008 in US) where Pete does say "These days many of the saxophones from China are better IMO, and likely to cost you less". This view was supported by jonf who "had played them myself" and saw them as middle ground quality. You responded "thanks for the replies" and mentioned that you had bought a TJ Alto a year previously.

I've personally never tried one but am aware of the more recent top end TJ Horns which seem very highly rated.
 
On the subject of Bauhaus Walstein, does anyone have an opinion on the brass altos (AS-Y)? I notice Woodwind and Brass have them for £517 which is slightly more than I wanted to spend, but you know.... Also, if the local shop doesn't have anything to suit, how confident can I be about buying on the internet? Will the sax be set up correctly?
 
I've personally never tried one but am aware of the more recent top end TJ Horns which seem very highly rated.

I tried the Signature Customs a couple of years ago and was underwhelmed, but I'm very prepared to revisit that opinion if I get a chance to play any of the more recent ones, which I believe are what Stephen has been highly rating.
 
I am aware of the Trevor James thread that you started on SOTW on 24-12-2008 (or 12-24-2008 in US) where Pete does say "These days many of the saxophones from China are better IMO, and likely to cost you less". This view was supported by jonf who "had played them myself" and saw them as middle ground quality. You responded "thanks for the replies" and mentioned that you had bought a TJ Alto a year previously.

I've personally never tried one but am aware of the more recent top end TJ Horns which seem very highly rated.

You are correct, :thumb: which proves my point (still have one year left on my alto of the five year guarantee that come’s with TJ horn’s) they are good horn’s.

You will also note that I no longer post on SOTW because I found this the Café Saxophone Forum.

If you also look back on my post’s in this forum you will see that I bought from Café Saxophone forum member Sharon a Bauhaus Walstein tenor.

Quote

Hi all I'm thinking of selling my Walstein Bauhaus Tenor sax which I bought from Woodwind and Brass about 1 year ago. I'm finding I haven't the time to really play it and justify having the two saxes.

I'm also rather enjoying my alto at the moment and not enjoying the tenor as I just can't get the low notes and havn't got so much time to put into playing it.


It's the phospher bronze one with the italian leather pads. It's the same as the one that's currently on the woodwind and brass website

In view of what is mentioned above
(ignore the spelling mistakes Sharon’s not mine)

I have to ask my self was the Bauhaus Walstein tenor ever checked before it was sent to Sharon with what happen later. Look back on my post’s here on the Café I think not.


Teebones another Serious :old:
 
Hi Teebones.

I don't quite follow your argument, though you have quoted my earlier post. You asked a question about why members seemed to be hostile towards TJ horns, and I noticed the SOTW thread which seemed to shed some light on the situation to which you referred.

There sounds to be an implication in your post that WW&B may not have set up Sharon's sax properly, and my BW curved soprano did require some significant adjustment after I had bought it from WW&B - albeit 3 years ago.

Kind regards
Tom
 
Hi Teebones.

I don't quite follow your argument, though you have quoted my earlier post. You asked a question about why members seemed to be hostile towards TJ horns, and I noticed the SOTW thread which seemed to shed some light on the situation to which you referred.

There sounds to be an implication in your post that WW&B may not have set up Sharon's sax properly, and my BW curved soprano did require some significant adjustment after I had bought it from WW&B - albeit 3 years ago.

Kind regards
Tom

Hi Tom.

I know nothing of your BW curved soprano. :confused: :shocked:

I quoted only on the Bauhaus Walstein Tenor horn I bought from Sharon.

I think it may be time I left Cafe Saxophone.

Best Regards Teebones
 
Thanks for all the responses, everyone. I thought I would give a bit of an update and (inevitably) ask a few more questions.

So I have now been to my local sax shop and seen what is available - I've also played my friend's alto and tenor again and I think I really have to go with tenor. I'm sure a lot of the problems I have with alto are my own lack of ability, or possibly reed/mouthpiece issues, but the tenor sounds good to me, the alto is far harsher and I can't play it any other way than LOUD!

I am now faced with choices with how I go about acquiring a suitable instrument - the guy in the sax shop did not seem keen on selling me a second hand yam, plus I would have no guarantee if there were any problems with it (sold on commission). The alternative he has is the cheapest Bauhaus Walstein (the yellow laquer version) plus a phosphor bronze model (way out of my price range). The advantage with buying locally is obvious - I have some come back if there's a problem, plus I'll obviously want to use him for servicing/new reeds/etc.

Other things I have been looking at include the Hanson (I think it's the ST-5) which comes in at a shade under £600; the advantage with this is a good guarantee plus free servicing.

Any thoughts appreciated. Are there any other good tenors at a similar price point? If so, can anyone recommend any shops or internet outlets which offer good price and service?

Cheers,
Pete
 
The alternative he has is the cheapest Bauhaus Walstein (the yellow laquer version) plus a phosphor bronze model (way out of my price range).

Unless anything has changed, there is no actual difference in sound between the cheaper yellow BW and the bronze one. The good thing about BWs is they all leave the distributor fully tested and set up.

As for servicing, get yourself the Haynes manual, a screwdriver and a small bottle of oil and you won't need to take it in to a tech for years.
 
Most of us can only play LOUD when we start. Altos will play quietly, but not so easily as the tenor.

But go with what sounds best to you.

And I guess another lesson for you is: "Don't ask this guy to sell something for you on commission in future".
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,628
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom