Tech/maintenance Need to use low B/Bb when playing low A

May be I did not explain clearly enough.
I think technically you aren’t going to be adding extra length (e.g. 30 cm of tube) to the top, the “extra” length would always have to be between the Bb and A key, which is what Conn literally did with the 11m. But making the pigtail wrap longer (and keeping the tone hole distances the same) is a nice idea.
 
I went looking for video of the straight baritone sax that was made a few years ago but I didn't find anything. If I remember correctly from the Saxophone Journal article, it had the standard neck and pigtail at the top and then it went straight downhill from there. It required the player to stand on a box !

But I did find this short video of a straight alto and straight tenor being played together (each with their standard neck). You can imagine what the bari equivalent would look like.

View: https://youtube.com/shorts/Zv5HdFRaHxw?si=3f6FwlBS7VcWkVpX


Rhys
 
1744032185256.webp

1744032327422.webp
 
Ah yes, that's a more recently-modified one than the 1920s (possibly Buescher ?) I read about in the Saxophone Journal.

In this tasteful pink one it looks like the neck has been turned a bit sideways and the pigtail modified to go up and down rather than round and round. This would lift the bottom of the instrument a bit higher up but it also seems to raise the Left Hand keys up to face level which I would find awkward.

Rhys
 
My Bauhaus bari performs the same satisfying trick

Reading @Stephen Howard's observations on low A mechanisms, it seems my bari low A lever is a Yamaha clone

Does your Jupiter have the same template?
Hi Ivan,
I don't know, how the Yamaha low A-mechanism works. With my Jupiter, pressing down the thumb key lifts an arm that forces the complete left pinkie table to close. There is some cork for regulation on that arm, but it seems to me that if Bb and B are in regulation and shut together (as it should be without low A too) and the cork has the right thickness to close A and Bb at the same time everything is fine. As the thumb is fairly strong it, doesn't need too much force to close the whole shebang.
Is this similar to the Yamaha mechanism?
 
I think technically you aren’t going to be adding extra length (e.g. 30 cm of tube) to the top, the “extra” length would always have to be between the Bb and A key, which is what Conn literally did with the 11m. But making the pigtail wrap longer (and keeping the tone hole distances the same) is a nice idea.
If you make the tube longer you will have a Baritone in the key of D? And an extension on the bell will give bigger tone/sound.

Here is an PRC bassaxophone with a longer neck and an extension. More a bassax in the key of A. The bassax is a copy of an old american bassax.

View: https://youtu.be/_R43kY-VkEk?si=76qkX6jLY7YLWeLv
 
If you make the tube longer you will have a Baritone in the key of D?
No, I was talking about the extra length of tube for a manufacturer to make a Bb into an A.

But also purely making a tube longer, unless you change the distance of the tone holes you don't change the key, you just add extra notes. e.g. a flue loW b foot joint is still a flute in C.
 
When they designed the low A they should have added the extra length at the top in the pigtail. That would look like a small bass instead of a deformed bari.
That would be a... huge project!
Given that the low A got added after the
'golden age of saxophones' had pretty much given way to the
'music education mass production era...'

...well, designing a new instrument mostly from scratch just
wasn't in the 'build mass quantities' mentality, when they could
reach over, grab a brass soup can, solder it in and 'sell twice as many!'

The musician and I were halfheartedly contemplating building a straight
bass out of plastic in the back yard, just for the pure goofiness of it.

t
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,396
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom