Saxophones neck replacement

That's a very good point. However, unless I missed it somewhere, the OP didn't say they were having any kind of problem with the neck. Just asking why some players want to replace the neck and whether there is any advantage in doing so.
I was kind of following the flow of this discussion, didn't even think of going back to the 1st poster's original question.

In a way seems to be quite an expensive fix for whatever perceived problems, as some of those necks exceed even the price of a budget sax.
 
ok, only one type of leg,
A bit like the old days when mostly there was only one type of ligature. There were obviously some exception where ligs were specific to the mouthpiece such as Otto Link, but nobody ever worried about types of lig or talked about them. They weren't important,.
 
I got an eastern music power neck for my Conn. sounds great, does give a bit more probjextion and plays a bit brighter / more focussed then original, which sometimes I like. It also makes tuning al lot easier especially on cold outdoor gigs, the original neck is requires more effort to keep in tune. It only cost me £78
 
I have an aftermarket neck on my Mark VI tenor. I got it because I had purchased a backup tenor, and noticed that palm key and altissimo ranges were both stronger and easier to play on the new (and cheaper) horn, so I tried a different neck. It fixed these issues, and I’ve been playing that neck on my VI now for 10 years or so.

FWIW, I have noticed the same palm key thinness and altissimo issues with other Mark VIs around this vintage. All 3 of my altos are keeping their original necks 🙂
 
The only time I ever bought an 'aftermarket' neck was for an old battered baritone, that came as a wreck with no neck at all, so not much option really 😉
 
My 1980's Selmer Bundy II alto sax bought used a while back came with an extra neck.

Been looking for a used Bundy II without neck to complete it but thus far, those missing the neck are in such poor shape it would not be worth my effort. (Require complete overhaul and servicing. Otherwise, they make good donor student instruments.)
 
Hi I notice some sax players like to replace their sax necks with another, probably more expensive one. What difference does this make. if I replaced the neck on my Bauhaus with, say, a Selmer or Sanigasawa neck, would this improve the sound, or just look good? is a silver neck on a brass sax appealing, or what?
There's no guarantee that it will improve the sound - if the sound is already good. In fact, there is no guarantee that it will be any different at all. That aside, I have played several necks of the same model (Selmer Ref 36) and found drastic (to me) differences between them. The particular neck that was best on my Ref 36 happened to be the one that came with the horn.

I had an alto that came with three necks. They played very different from one another and I had the same distinct favorite each time I did comparisons over the span of several months. I sold the extra necks as there was no point to me keeping them. Others like to have multiple necks to fit a range of mouthpieces. I prefer to have as few mouthpieces as possible to meet my needs.

FWIW, I like shiny.
 
A bit like the old days when mostly there was only one type of ligature. There were obviously some exception where ligs were specific to the mouthpiece such as Otto Link, but nobody ever worried about types of lig or talked about them. They weren't important,.
Would be interesting to know who first came up with the "perfect " ligature, and what did it look like. Some entrepeneur with an eye to make money from the gullible.
 
Would be interesting to know who first came up with the "perfect " ligature, and what did it look like. Some entrepeneur with an eye to make money from the gullible.
The first ligature I think to grab the market in regard to using something other than "the lig that came with the mouthpiece" was probably Rovner.
 
The first ligature I think to grab the market in regard to using something other than "the lig that came with the mouthpiece" was probably Rovner.
Ok, thanks for that. I use the Rovner, I like the ease of application and just one screw. If I was gullible I might say it gives a nice "leathery" tone to my instrument 😀😀
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,351
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom