Tech/maintenance Neck/Crook surgery?

Thanks once again to all for your comments and suggestions. Have tried the "sting" treatment. Unfortunately it did what was reported for lowering the pitch for "high pitch" instruments down to low pitch. Great for that use. Unfortunately my problem is the opposite. The pitch of this instrument is too low already. I'm having to drop the templates of material I'd recorded by 25 cents in order to play in tune. The fix may be possible with a neck modification, but I've still got to successfully dummy model what may be required.

I've been hesitant about sending the neck/crook off without a good idea of what might fix it. The suggestion of buying a few cheap Chinese necks is good, but probably a waste if they don't work.

Does anyone know much about the Warburton Ultimate Sax Neck? This seems to incorporate a flexible system that could be an answer. It's not cheap, but may ultimately be cost effective. Any clues would be appreciated.

Thanks again all.
Can you push the mouthpiece in a bit more? Do you have the old tuning neck?
 
Can you push the mouthpiece in a bit more? Do you have the old tuning neck?
If the mouthpiece is pushed on further the top end goes way sharp without the bottom end coming up as much. The horn is in tune with itself (best intonation) when it's slightly flat. Just pushing in a mouthpiece doesn't make the whole horn raise its pitch uniformly. Playing a series of overtones compared to the keyed note lets one hear where the pitch is right for the horn...that pitch is too low.

I'm not sure what you mean by "having the old tuning neck". If you're familiar with something not already mentioned that could help I'd like to hear it. Thanks.
 
If the mouthpiece is pushed on further the top end goes way sharp without the bottom end coming up as much. The horn is in tune with itself (best intonation) when it's slightly flat. Just pushing in a mouthpiece doesn't make the whole horn raise its pitch uniformly. Playing a series of overtones compared to the keyed note lets one hear where the pitch is right for the horn...that pitch is too low.

I'm not sure what you mean by "having the old tuning neck". If you're familiar with something not already mentioned that could help I'd like to hear it. Thanks.
Ah ok. I understand. That’s very annoying that the lower register doesn’t also rise in pitch and also hard to understand why it doesn’t.

When I mentioned the tuning neck I just mean the old style rolling tuner that’s on some older saxes like Conn, Kohlert, etc
 
As stated in the beginning of this post this is a Keilwerth modern prototype. It's not an old Conn with a micro-tuner neck. There are others here who can describe the physics of tuning much better than I can. However as said there is a "sweet spot" where the horn's intonation is as good as it will get. If you pull out the mouthpiece it goes flat, but not uniformly. If you push in it goes sharp, but again not uniformly so there is nothing gained just your intonation goes out of whack. The horn should be in tune (low pitch 440) at the sweet spot. Changing the mouthpiece and to some degree the reed can make a difference. That's the easy fix. I've tried various mouthpieces and reeds without it making enough of a difference. The next step is possibly dealing to the neck.

I don't know what your experience in playing might be, so possibly you're thinking I'm a beginner and just need to push the mouthpiece on further? Not the case. Once again this is a prototype, so not standard and never went into production (for obvious reasons?). The tone is beautiful (check post #41 for an example) so I'm just trying to find a physical fix that will hopefully bring the tuning up to where it should be. If you read the whole thread you'll get the entire picture as well as some of the technical explanations.
 
As stated in the beginning of this post this is a Keilwerth modern prototype. It's not an old Conn with a micro-tuner neck. There are others here who can describe the physics of tuning much better than I can. However as said there is a "sweet spot" where the horn's intonation is as good as it will get. If you pull out the mouthpiece it goes flat, but not uniformly. If you push in it goes sharp, but again not uniformly so there is nothing gained just your intonation goes out of whack. The horn should be in tune (low pitch 440) at the sweet spot. Changing the mouthpiece and to some degree the reed can make a difference. That's the easy fix. I've tried various mouthpieces and reeds without it making enough of a difference. The next step is possibly dealing to the neck.

I don't know what your experience in playing might be, so possibly you're thinking I'm a beginner and just need to push the mouthpiece on further? Not the case. Once again this is a prototype, so not standard and never went into production (for obvious reasons?). The tone is beautiful (check post #41 for an example) so I'm just trying to find a physical fix that will hopefully bring the tuning up to where it should be. If you read the whole thread you'll get the entire picture as well as some of the technical explanations.
I’m sorry. I’ve followed this thread for a while and I mistakingly thought your last post was by someone else hence the not very helpful replies. Sorry about that.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,703
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom