Tech/maintenance Neck/Crook surgery?

OK, have made the insert that fills the void from the end of the neck to the mouthpiece. I'm surprised how much better it is, so that's really good. Unfortunately with the sax in tune with itself it's still about 10 cents flat. Not good. but so much better! Probably with a smaller chamber piece it will (finally) work.

Here's an example of the tone of this sax (corrected by dropping 25 cents, recording, then putting the pitch back up). Hopefully you'll agree the tone makes it worth persevering.

View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-221743.php
 
Last edited:
Thanks Jaye. The only other alto neck I have right now is for a Martin. I'm not even sure if a J Keilwerth neck will fit this prototype G Keilwerth. Unfortunately I don't know anyone with a Keilwerth alto to give it a try. Would you know if any other makes are interchangeable with Keilwerth?
All I can suggest is, get a tenon measurement of the horn's original neck and maybe see if you can buy a cheapie chinese one or two off eFlay with a tenon diameter within .1mm of the original. Just see if it does anything...if you are OK with potentially just eating the purchase on a cheapie neck....
 
OK, have made the insert that fills the void from the end of the neck to the mouthpiece. I'm surprised how much better it is, so that's really good. Unfortunately with the sax in tune with itself it's still about 10 cents flat. Not good. but so much better! Probably with a smaller chamber piece it will (finally) work.

Here's an example of the tone of this sax (corrected by dropping 25 cents, recording, then putting the pitch back up). Hopefully you'll agree the tone makes it worth persevering.

View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-221743.php
An interesting result...matter of fact I would argue a 10-15 cents differential up and down the registers ?....you have a sax which is perfectly within 'in-tune' tolerances, really.

Are YOU satisfied that the tonality didn't change to a degree significant enough to have made the fix a 'compromise' ????
 
An interesting result...matter of fact I would argue a 10-15 cents differential up and down the registers ?....you have a sax which is perfectly within 'in-tune' tolerances, really.

Are YOU satisfied that the tonality didn't change to a degree significant enough to have made the fix a 'compromise' ????

The tone is the same (excellent) so no problem there. The problem is the same, but less severe. With the sax perfectly in tune with itself it's around 10 cents flat. Push in to bring up the bottom notes up makes the top end go way sharp. When recording with a template this is just about tolerable, but the tendency is to still try and match the tone of the template. That's easier to do with the high notes, but doesn't work that well with the low notes. If I ignore it all I can then tweak the sax track up the extra 10 cents. Before it was so horribly flat that it just wasn't possible so I dropped the template 25 cents so that I could match the template without a problem with intonation. I could still drop the template 10 cents, but most people can't hear the difference anyway. It's only my trying (mostly unconsciously) to compensate that doesn't work.
 
Ernest Ferron writes in "The Saxophone is My Voice" that the sound rises approximately 25 cents for each 10°F or 6°C rise in temperature. That would mean that the pitch rises about 2.5 cents for each 1°F rise in temperature. Theoretically if you raise the temperature 4° your pitch would be 10 cents higher.
 
Ernest Ferron writes in "The Saxophone is My Voice" that the sound rises approximately 25 cents for each 10°F or 6°C rise in temperature. That would mean that the pitch rises about 2.5 cents for each 1°F rise in temperature. Theoretically if you raise the temperature 4° your pitch would be 10 cents higher.

We all know that the horn has got to be warm, and I'm always warming up the horn before playing. In winter I have an electric fan heater that does this. In summer it just takes five minutes of playing. Interesting idea to have a hot(ish) room for playing. Also a lot cheaper than having the neck/crook modified. I've always hated playing outdoors when it's cold as the tuning is awful. I don't know how anyone plays in tune in a wintertime marching band.
 
A wild idea has been bothering me as I read this thread. Would narrowing the tube do the job? By that I mean reducing the volume all along the tube rather than in a specific spot as with an iron ball or a small chamber mouthpiece.

I realize that's not so easy to do. But most of the time, there is a fairly accessible straight area down the tube from the neck that could receive an appendice to diminish the volume of the tube by a fraction at least from the neck down to the bow.

Would that be an option?
 
Apparently clarinet players in years gone by would convert a HP instrument into a LP one by dangling a frayed string within the bore, clamped by the barrel. By all accounts results were mixed ...
Mind you, no harm in trying something similar with the crook and/or body - imagine the astonishment if it worked!
 
Last edited:
Thanks saxyit and stitch. Certainly worth a try and I like the idea of a bit of experimentation. I've also heard back from a few of the guys that make custom necks who think they could do something. However since I'm not sending the whole sax away it's pretty necessary to have a good idea of what might work before commissioning a new neck/crook.
 
Hi. Haven't posted for a long time.
Wondering if this was ever resolved and how?
I have a similar JK 'best in the world. Toneking alto with a similar problem.
Definitely partly the fault of my embouchure but wondering if anything you tried actually helped.
@JayeNM
 
Hi. Haven't posted for a long time.
Wondering if this was ever resolved and how?
I have a similar JK 'best in the world. Toneking alto with a similar problem.
Definitely partly the fault of my embouchure but wondering if anything you tried actually helped.
@JayeNM

Thanks for asking. I've checked with several people who specialize in neck modifications or building necks. I also got a tuner, but found that it's only accurate in low tones and not very accurate beyond the first octave of an alto. So that's limited some of the information specifically asked for by those techs. I've also tried some "dummy" contouring using various materials to change the internal shape (that's accessible) in the neck/crook. Those (modest) modifications didn't work.

Being in New Zealand, and none of those neck tech folks working here, is a problem. Does one send their neck/crook to Germany or the USA hoping that whatever (expensive) modification they do will work? And what happens if it doesn't work? Do I send the whole horn and have the nightmare of customs/duty when shipped back?

So for now I'm stymied by Geography and not having found any clues on my own as to what type of modificatioon is most likely to work. My short term solution was to buy an excellent condition 6M that has nearly perfect intonation. It's not as pretty, and doesn't have the same tone, but it certainly can play. It's also likely to be the cheaper option when considering that I'd be very lucky just sending the neck/crook off and that working perfectly the first time.
 
Hi Wade and thanks for your reply.
I’m not sure if I have the same problem as you as it doesn’t seem unfixable. I am able to fix the problem with my embouchure. After reading a lot on different forums and also Steve Lacys soprano book I realised that I was unconsciously squeezing the mouthpiece in the higher register. I also switched to a Rico Graftonite 5A which helped but not an awful lot. Im going to ask my tech about it soon and I’ll report back. Im just surprised I have no problem with intonation on an Amati soprano of similar vintage. Im almost always perfectly in tune (to my ears anyway ) with a Marca 2.5 Reed and S80 C*.
 
Hi Wade and thanks for your reply.
I’m not sure if I have the same problem as you as it doesn’t seem unfixable. I am able to fix the problem with my embouchure. After reading a lot on different forums and also Steve Lacys soprano book I realised that I was unconsciously squeezing the mouthpiece in the higher register. I also switched to a Rico Graftonite 5A which helped but not an awful lot. Im going to ask my tech about it soon and I’ll report back. Im just surprised I have no problem with intonation on an Amati soprano of similar vintage. Im almost always perfectly in tune (to my ears anyway ) with a Marca 2.5 Reed and S80 C*.
Thanks for your reply frguscullen. Mine isn't a vintage horn. It's a modern prototype. I've played many different types of horns, some of which required a very tight embouchure on the top end (Yanagisawa sopranino). Since the Yani nino was my first sopranino (20 years ago) I had no basis of comparison. When I switched to a Selmer sopranino I had to loose the tightening in the embouchure. That was the most extreme case. I'm very familiar with embouchure adjustments on all horns. As an (99%) ear player I'm not just reading and pushing keys. Playing in tune is an absolute must as I mostly record with others. There is a limit to how much one can adjust and play naturally. This horn I have is beyond that limit. As stated in the first post it's a technical problem.
 
Source material:

ABainesWIatH.webp



Anthony Baines; Woodwind Instruments and their History
 
Thanks once again to all for your comments and suggestions. Have tried the "sting" treatment. Unfortunately it did what was reported for lowering the pitch for "high pitch" instruments down to low pitch. Great for that use. Unfortunately my problem is the opposite. The pitch of this instrument is too low already. I'm having to drop the templates of material I'd recorded by 25 cents in order to play in tune. The fix may be possible with a neck modification, but I've still got to successfully dummy model what may be required.

I've been hesitant about sending the neck/crook off without a good idea of what might fix it. The suggestion of buying a few cheap Chinese necks is good, but probably a waste if they don't work.

Does anyone know much about the Warburton Ultimate Sax Neck? This seems to incorporate a flexible system that could be an answer. It's not cheap, but may ultimately be cost effective. Any clues would be appreciated.

Thanks again all.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,703
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom