Playing the saxophone Mustang sally d major

I am doing the commitments version..and just for fun..
So why not make it more fun by not trying to play the exact same notes on a saxophone as a singer is singing. Because it isn't the Commitments version anyway as soon as you replace voice with saxophone. It's your version.

I think you are making this much harder and less fun than it needs to be.
 
Last edited:
Two observations:
will anybody actually appreciate which particular version you're doing?
how about doing YOUR version, and not getting too hung up on what other people have done with it?
Hey im not..I find that once i can play the lyric part I can wander into the other bits intro outro etc..The key is only relevant as its what the backing track is in. That only relevant until i take the words away and feel a little more comfortable with the song...
 
I'd suggest learning to SING the song; then doing on sax what you're doing with your voice.
Yes spend some time listening to the track, headphones on the way to work (or at work!) sing a long with it.

Then just play it and make yourself do it without sheet music or written down notes. There’s only 4 or 5 of them you need. Just make yourself do it.
 
That so-called blues style and blues scale that's being imposed nowadays is like taking your dinner and just pouring ketchup on everything - the baked fish, the broccoli, the squash casserole, the apple pie, your coffee....
This explains a lot. How do expect to play the blues without collard greens and maybe some corn bread? And some ribs…
 
@turf3

He's not playing the original but some version from a movie linked earlier in the thread for which Pete and I have already posted the notes. I was quite confused as well at first. He’s usually adamant about sticking with originals.

@eb424

It's a D blues so it's going to have a lot of flat 3rds and flat 7ths, which is pretty obvious from listening. What you hear always trumps the key signature.
 
@turf3

He's not playing the original but some version from a movie linked earlier in the thread for which Pete and I have already posted the notes. I was quite confused as well at first. He’s usually adamant about sticking with originals.

@eb424

It's a D blues so it's going to have a lot of flat 3rds and flat 7ths, which is pretty obvious from listening. What you hear always trumps the key signature.
Thanks @lydian that answers a lot..TBF its the same score for both versions..I'd love to be able to tell notes by hearing but im not there yet and don't know if i ever will be.Youd think there would be a clue in the key sig so idiots like me would know..⁴once i start playing to the track and familiarising myself with the song it gets a bit easier..thanks forvthe help i know its frustrating for you..
 
@eb424

I'm going to sing the Sally lyrics on my tenor. Started yesterday. Now I'm waiting for warmer weather. No heating out in the woodshed. I think the "beginner" section is a good place to post songs like this. You post your recording and get some nice and constructive comments. I think it's less competition on the "beginner" section on "Your soundclips?
 
@eb424

I'm going to sing the Sally lyrics on my tenor. Started yesterday. Now I'm waiting for warmer weather. No heating out in the woodshed. I think the "beginner" section is a good place to post songs like this. You post your recording and get some nice and constructive comments. I think it's less competition on the "beginner" section on "Your sound clips?
Probably a good call but it wont be ready for a while..I need twenty songs that i can play noted..then i want to look at intro outros and improv over chord changes.All part of my cunning plan. Hope it warms up soon for you..
 
@turf3

He's not playing the original but some version from a movie linked earlier in the thread for which Pete and I have already posted the notes. I was quite confused as well at first. He’s usually adamant about sticking with originals.

@eb424

It's a D blues so it's going to have a lot of flat 3rds and flat 7ths, which is pretty obvious from listening. What you hear always trumps the key signature.
Well, as I noted above, Pickett in his recording sings a LOT of major thirds (F# in D) instead of the minor third more modern people would sing - thus my snarky comments abot slathering the "blues scale" all over everything.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom