Playing the saxophone Mustang sally d major

Well, as I noted above, Pickett in his recording sings a LOT of major thirds (F# in D)
You may be right, but I was under the impression we are talking about the Commitments version here.

I get the feeling Pickett often sings something between a major and minor 3rd, or major 3rd with bend so it's very hard to pinpoint as with a lot of soul, blues and R & B singers.

And so a lot of sheet music is fairly irrelevant because it can't actually show some types of blue notes which are "between the cracks" so I would ignore notation of that kind of thing mostly and do it by ear or just add my own feel/interpretation of the pitch which would probably change on a daily if not hourly basis.
 
You may be right, but I was under the impression we are talking about the Commitments version here.

I get the feeling Pickett often sings something between a major and minor 3rd, or major 3rd with bend so it's very hard to pinpoint as with a lot of soul, blues and R & B singers.

And so a lot of sheet music is fairly irrelevant because it can't actually show some types of blue notes which are "between the cracks" so I would ignore notation of that kind of thing mostly and do it by ear or just add my own feel/interpretation of the pitch which would probably change on a daily if not hourly basis.
Yes, that's probably true, he was probably singing blue thirds, partway between major and minor.

Yet another reason why this kind of music is often best communicated aurally.
 
Probably a good call but it wont be ready for a while..I need twenty songs that i can play noted..then i want to look at intro outros and improv over chord changes.All part of my cunning plan. Hope it warms up soon for you..
I understand. I need to get more used to play songs. I never play melodies/songs, just been playing in groups. Fillings, background/riffs and solos. And just on a low/basic level. So this is useful for me. Maybe to other players as well? It's not easy for me.

- So far I've been singing. - I bought a backing track in the style of Wilson Pickett. I have dms, gtr, bass and organ left. A little bit naked? - How to start this song and how to finish? I start with a long increasing D2 . I'm just going to fade out playing two bars over D7 chord. - Wrote down the chords. - I'm going to play verse 1 and verse 2 close to the melody/ singing. But I guess I've to fill out with longer tones , trills .... ? I'm going to try to play a solo instead of playing "All you wanna do is...". Intro- vers 1 - solo - vers 2 - outro.

What scale to use? I think a combine of D blues- D major pentatonic, D minor pentatonic. The G mixolydian scale (G, A, B, C, D, E, F, G) can also be used over the G7 chord.

Fun topic/thread and thank you Ed for starting it. Or starting me up.
sallytext.JPG
sallyackord.JPG
 
I understand. I need to get more used to play songs. I never play melodies/songs, just been playing in groups. Fillings, background/riffs and solos. And just on a low/basic level. So this is useful for me. Maybe to other players as well? It's not easy for me.

- So far I've been singing. - I bought a backing track in the style of Wilson Pickett. I have dms, gtr, bass and organ left. A little bit naked? - How to start this song and how to finish? I start with a long increasing D2 . I'm just going to fade out playing two bars over D7 chord. - Wrote down the chords. - I'm going to play verse 1 and verse 2 close to the melody/ singing. But I guess I've to fill out with longer tones , trills .... ? I'm going to try to play a solo instead of playing "All you wanna do is...". Intro- vers 1 - solo - vers 2 - outro.

What scale to use? I think a combine of D blues- D major pentatonic, D minor pentatonic. The G mixolydian scale (G, A, B, C, D, E, F, G) can also be used over the G7 chord.

Fun topic/thread and thank you Ed for starting it. Or starting me up.
View attachment 22687View attachment 22688
Glad you enjoyed it..only line im stuck on now is verse 2 " you won't you won't let me ride" if you get that line drop mecyhe notes pleeeeease, songs driving me mad..lol
 
Thomsax, I appreciate the education that I just had looking at #6. I'd never seen a double dotted half note before, so I did a quick google check, and now I know what it means! 3.5 beats plus the 1/8 note fills out the measure.
Pretty cool! I can't wait to impress my director if that ever comes up in our music.
Just another reason to hang out here!
 
How do you know it's a blues d scale and not just a d scale..
I think you're making this much more complicated than it needs to be. You should just listen to each note/phrase and hunt around on your horn until it matches. With more experience you'll be able to hear patterns without your horn. Just ignore the key when transcribing by ear. Write down the note you hear.
 
Hi I was just wondering from a learning perspctive if there ws something in the score..Only reason was because the orginal key was C so i transposed it to d for tenor so assumed unlessvtherecwas an acvidental all Fs were sharp and the same with Cs
 
I haven’t seen the score, but it probably had some Eb’s and Bb’s which would be F natural and C natural transposed. If it didn’t, then it was wrong. If you don’t know why Eb transposed up one step is F natural, etc., then you need to go back and learn some fundamentals.
 
I'm going/trying to play the Wilson Pickett's vocal. No horns and additional vocals. Pickett sang it in dynamic way. Now I'm going to play it in the same way??? Of course to play it on the saxophone in the same style as Pickett sang it's hard. Blues, Rock, R&B, Soul .... scales, modes, grooves .... D, F, F#, natural C, C# .... the song is a dynamo. The more speed/energy you add, the more it shine. But be careful. A rocker was playing an improvised Sally solo. I guess he was playing the same (almost) tones as he had done many times before. But one evening a guy step forward the stage and grab the bell and screamed into the clip-on mic: "MUSTANG SALLY". No damage on the teeth but the lips .... On the other side this is improvising in its purest form. Unpredictable and hopefully just made/played once.

I was playing "Make You Feel My Love", Dylans voicing, and it's easier for me to play song like that on tenor. The lyrics have a rhythm in it self that I don't find in Mustang Sally. " ... And there is no one there to dry our tears ..." is easier for me to play on a tenor sax instead of ".... Mustang Sally, now baby, oh no ...". But I like it all.

How to get words on the right place in a song? Just make sure so they land in right chord. I don't play the English/American words, I have Swedish/Scanish rural words running in my head when I'm playing. Transpose and and translate.
 
I'm going/trying to play the Wilson Pickett's vocal. No horns and additional vocals. Pickett sang it in dynamic way. Now I'm going to play it in the same way??? Of course to play it on the saxophone in the same style as Pickett sang it's hard. Blues, Rock, R&B, Soul .... scales, modes, grooves .... D, F, F#, natural C, C# .... the song is a dynamo. The more speed/energy you add, the more it shine. But be careful. A rocker was playing an improvised Sally solo. I guess he was playing the same (almost) tones as he had done many times before. But one evening a guy step forward the stage and grab the bell and screamed into the clip-on mic: "MUSTANG SALLY". No damage on the teeth but the lips .... On the other side this is improvising in its purest form. Unpredictable and hopefully just made/played once.

I was playing "Make You Feel My Love", Dylans voicing, and it's easier for me to play song like that on tenor. The lyrics have a rhythm in it self that I don't find in Mustang Sally. " ... And there is no one there to dry our tears ..." is easier for me to play on a tenor sax instead of ".... Mustang Sally, now baby, oh no ...". But I like it all.

How to get words on the right place in a song? Just make sure so they land in right chord. I don't play the English/American words, I have Swedish/Scanish rural words running in my head when I'm playing. Transpose and and translate.
Great song by Dylan...my mate does the new Adell version..now you got me thinking...lol
 
Hi I was just wondering from a learning perspctive if there ws something in the score..Only reason was because the orginal key was C so i transposed it to d for tenor so assumed unlessvtherecwas an acvidental all Fs were sharp and the same with Cs
What we keep trying to tell you is there IS NO "the score". This music is learned by ear. In the studio the musicians MIGHT have some pencil scratched horn parts and the singer MIGHT have a lyric sheet. Rhythm players MIGHT have a chord chart, though by the time the Replacements got around to it the song was so well known by all professional musicians that no one would have needed one.

If you've got some printed music that purports to be "what the Replacements did", someone's come along after the fact, listened to the recording, and copied it down as best they could. Why not do the same thing yourself? Or skip the paper and go straight to playing the tune? We're not talking about the Rite of Spring here.
 
I think you're making this much more complicated than it needs to be. You should just listen to each note/phrase and hunt around on your horn until it matches. With more experience you'll be able to hear patterns without your horn. Just ignore the key when transcribing by ear. Write down the note you hear.
I do find your posts interesting you ask good/awkward questions which maybe others would not ask,me being one,but if you do not ask,you will never know but i with my little knowledge think sometimes you may over think some of your answers,but good luck and carry on.Bumnote
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,577
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom